India and USA are two large democracies. Examine the basic tenets on which the two political systems are based.
Go into the foundations of both systems in depth: identify the principles each rests on, show where they converge and differ, and explain why.
Common trap: Many answers turn into a list of differences. The question asks for basic tenets, so begin with the shared democratic principles and then show how each system institutionalises them differently, and why.
SyllabusComparison of the Indian constitutional scheme with that of other countries.
Model answer
15 marks · 250-word limitThe US Constitution of 1787 and India's of 1950 both open with We the People and rest on popular sovereignty. They channel it differently: the US through a presidential system and strict separation of powers, India through parliamentary government in a Union of States.
- Presidential, fixed term
- Strict separation of powers
- Dual federalism; residuary powers with states
- Dual citizenship
- Rigid amendment under Article V
- Parliamentary, responsible executive
- Fusion of executive and legislature
- Union of States; residuary powers with Union
- Single citizenship
- Flexible-rigid amendment under Article 368
Common tenets
- Popular sovereignty and republicanism: Both have elected heads of state and no hereditary office; authority flows from the people.
- Constitutional supremacy: Written constitutions bind all organs, enforced by judicial review: Marbury v. Madison (1803) in the US, Articles 13 and 32 in India.
- Rights and rule of law: The Bill of Rights (1791) and Part III guarantee liberties against the state, protected by an independent judiciary.
- Federalism: Power is divided between the national government and the states.
Where the two systems diverge
| Tenet | USA | India |
|---|---|---|
| Executive | President elected through the Electoral College for four years, not answerable to Congress | PM and Council of Ministers collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha (Article 75(3)); President a constitutional head |
| Separation of powers | Strict, with checks such as the veto, Senate confirmation and impeachment | Executive drawn from and accountable to the legislature |
| Federation | Coming together of 13 states; residuary powers with states; equal Senate seats | Holding together; Article 1 Union of States; residuary powers with the Union (Article 248); Rajya Sabha seats by population |
| Judiciary and rights | Dual court system; due process of law | Integrated judiciary; procedure established by law, widened in Maneka Gandhi (1978) |
| Amendment | Two-thirds of Congress and three-fourths of states; 27 amendments | Article 368 special majority, some with state ratification; over 100 amendments, limited by the basic structure (Kesavananda Bharati, 1973) |
Why the designs differ
- Different fears: The US founders sought to restrain power after colonial rule; India needed a strong Union to hold a diverse, newly partitioned country together and transform society, hence Directive Principles and reservations.
- Responsibility over stability: Ambedkar told the Constituent Assembly on 4 November 1948 that the draft preferred the daily accountability of a parliamentary executive to the stability of a presidential one.
Both democracies share a liberal core of popular sovereignty, rights and judicial review, yet India adapted it to a welfare state in a diverse society. The comparison shows that democratic tenets are universal, while institutions must fit each nation's history and needs.
Read more — sources
- OfficialConstitution of India (Articles 1, 13, 32, 75, 248, 368) and the Constitution of the United States (1787) with the Bill of Rights (1791)
- NCERTIndian Constitution at Work (Class XI) — Ch. 4, Executive and Ch. 7, Federalism
- OfficialConstituent Assembly Debates, 4 November 1948 — B.R. Ambedkar's introduction of the Draft Constitution
- BookD.D. Basu, Introduction to the Constitution of India
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 2 2018
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.