In what ways would the ongoing US-Iran Nuclear Pact Controversy affect the national interest of India? How should India respond to this situation?
Trace the specific ways the controversy affects India's interests, then set out a practical policy response that balances competing relationships.
Common trap: Most answers stop at oil. A top answer covers energy, connectivity (Chabahar, INSTC), the US strategic partnership and CAATSA, West Asian stability and the diaspora, and recommends a calibrated strategic-autonomy response rather than picking a side.
SyllabusEffect of policies and politics of developed and developing countries on India's interests, Indian diaspora.
Model answer
15 marks · 250-word limitThe Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action, concluded on 14 July 2015 by Iran and the P5+1, capped Iran's nuclear programme in return for sanctions relief. On 8 May 2018 the United States withdrew and began reimposing secondary sanctions in stages, with those on Iran's oil, banking and shipping due from 5 November 2018.
- Jul 2015JCPOA signed; sanctions eased
- May 2016India-Iran-Afghanistan Chabahar transit agreement
- Aug 2017US enacts CAATSA
- May 2018US withdraws from JCPOA
- Sep 2018First India-US 2+2; COMCASA signed
- Nov 2018Oil, banking and shipping sanctions due
How it affects India's national interest
- Energy security: Iran was India's third-largest crude supplier in 2017-18 and offered generous credit and shipping terms; for a country importing over 80 per cent of its crude, losing it raises costs at a time when crude prices and the rupee were already under pressure.
- Connectivity: Chabahar's Shahid Beheshti terminal and the International North-South Transport Corridor are India's route to Afghanistan and Central Asia bypassing Pakistan, and both risk delays as banks and suppliers shy away.
- Strategic partnership with the US: Defiance invites secondary sanctions, and CAATSA overlaps with India's defence purchases from Russia, at a time when the September 2018 2+2 dialogue and COMCASA had deepened ties.
- Regional stability and diaspora: Escalation in the Gulf or around the Strait of Hormuz threatens shipping and the safety and remittances of the millions of Indians working in the Gulf.
How India should respond
- Principled position: India recognises only UN Security Council sanctions, not unilateral ones, and should keep stating support for the JCPOA alongside the EU, Russia and China.
- Negotiate carve-outs: Seek US waivers for reduced oil imports and for Chabahar, citing its role in Afghan reconstruction, a goal Washington shares.
- Hedge energy risks: Diversify to Iraq, Saudi Arabia, the UAE, the US and others, and use the strategic petroleum reserves at Visakhapatnam, Mangaluru and Padur.
- Protect payment channels: Explore rupee-based payment mechanisms and coordinate with the EU, which is seeking ways to keep a payment channel open for legitimate trade with Iran.
- Since then: India secured a six-month oil waiver and the US exempted Chabahar in November 2018, but India halted Iranian oil imports in 2019 after the waivers expired.
India's interest lies in not being forced to choose between Washington and Tehran. Calibrated strategic autonomy, combining waivers, diversification and steady investment in Chabahar, can protect energy security and connectivity while keeping the deepening partnership with the United States on track.
Read more — sources
- OfficialMinistry of External Affairs — India-Iran joint statements and briefings on Chabahar (2016-2018)
- OfficialUN Security Council Resolution 2231 (2015) endorsing the JCPOA
- OfficialMinistry of Petroleum and Natural Gas — Lok Sabha/Rajya Sabha replies on crude imports by source, 2017-18
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 2 2018
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.