Assess the role of British imperial power in complicating the process of transfer of power during the 1940s.
Weigh the British role on the evidence and reach a measured judgement; show how far imperial policy, rather than Indian actors alone, made the transfer of power difficult.
Common trap: Many answers list the 1940s plans chronologically. A strong answer shows the mechanism in each plan (minority veto, provincial opt-out, grouping, rushed deadline, lapse of paramountcy) and balances it with the roles of the League, the Congress and wartime circumstances.
SyllabusModern Indian history from about the middle of the eighteenth century until the present- significant events, personalities, issues.
Model answer
15 marks · 250-word limitBritain left India in August 1947, but the road there was strewn with offers that rewarded deadlock. From the August Offer of 1940 to the Mountbatten Plan of 1947, imperial policy repeatedly conceded vetoes, opt-outs and deadlines that turned a question of independence into a question of partition.
- 1940August Offer: minority veto on constitution
- 1942Cripps: provinces may opt out
- 1945Simla Conference fails on League's demand
- 1946Cabinet Mission grouping; Interim Government
- Feb 1947Attlee sets June 1948 deadline
- June 1947Mountbatten Plan; date advanced to 15 August
- Aug 1947Radcliffe Award published after independence
How imperial policy complicated the process
- Minority veto (1940): The August Offer promised that power would not pass to any system whose authority was denied by large and powerful elements of national life, effectively giving the Muslim League a veto.
- Seeds of partition (1942): The Cripps Mission offered dominion status after the war but allowed provinces to stay out of the new Union, conceding the principle of separation.
- Unequal treatment in war: Congress leaders were jailed after August 1942, while the League was allowed to expand and form ministries in Sindh, Bengal and the North-West Frontier Province.
- Rewarding obstruction (1945–46): Wavell let the Simla Conference collapse over Jinnah's claim to nominate every Muslim member, and the Cabinet Mission's ambiguous grouping of provinces into sections A, B and C fed rival interpretations; the League later entered the Interim Government while boycotting the Constituent Assembly.
- Haste and fragmentation (1947): Attlee's statement of 20 February 1947 fixed June 1948 as the deadline; Mountbatten advanced it to 15 August 1947, Radcliffe had about five weeks to draw borders, and the award was published only on 17 August.
The princely states
- Lapse of paramountcy: The Indian Independence Act, 1947 released over 560 states from British suzerainty, encouraging Hyderabad, Junagadh, Travancore and Jammu and Kashmir to toy with independence.
Other factors and assessment
- Indian actors: The League's Direct Action Day (16 August 1946) and the Calcutta killings, communal mobilisation and the Congress's own tactical choices also hardened positions.
- Imperial weakness: A war-exhausted Britain, the INA trials and the naval ratings' revolt of February 1946 made a quick exit, rather than a careful settlement, London's priority.
Britain did not create communal division alone, but by institutionalising it since separate electorates in 1909 and repeatedly rewarding intransigence, it made a negotiated, united transfer of power nearly impossible. The haste of 1947 then converted political failure into human tragedy on a massive scale.
Read more — sources
- NCERTThemes in Indian History – III (Class XII) — Understanding Partition (pre-2023 edition)
- BookBipan Chandra et al., India's Struggle for Independence
- BookSumit Sarkar, Modern India 1885–1947
- OfficialIndian Independence Act, 1947 (UK Parliament)
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 1 2019
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.