Are we losing our local identity for the global identity? Discuss.
Discuss asks you to examine the claim from several angles, with evidence on both sides, and reach a reasoned position on whether globalisation erodes or reshapes local identity.
Common trap: A one-sided lament about westernisation is the usual weakness. The better answer distinguishes areas of real loss (languages, crafts, food diversity) from hybridisation and revival, and uses concepts such as glocalisation with Indian examples.
SyllabusEffects of globalization on Indian society.
Model answer
15 marks · 250-word limitGlobalisation, accelerated in India after the 1991 reforms, carries global brands, media and lifestyles into every town. Yet identity is not a fixed stock that is simply lost; sociologists describe both homogenisation and glocalisation, the local adaptation of global forms. The Indian evidence points to selective erosion alongside revival.
- Endangered languages and dialects
- Decline of handlooms and crafts
- Uniform diets, malls, fashion
- Consumerist festivals
- Glocalised products and media
- Regional-language internet boom
- Global demand for yoga, Ayurveda
- Assertion of local symbols
Where local identity is weakening
- Languages: The People's Linguistic Survey of India (2013) reported that about 220 languages had disappeared in five decades, and UNESCO's online Atlas lists 197 Indian languages as vulnerable, endangered or extinct, more than any other country; English-medium aspiration accelerates the shift.
- Livelihood-linked culture: Power looms and cheap imports have hurt handloom and craft clusters, and with them local motifs, songs and skills.
- Food and lifestyle: Packaged and fast food displace millets and regional cuisines, which is why India marked 2018 as the National Year of Millets.
- Festivals and family: Commercialised celebrations, nuclear families and migration to cities thin out community rituals and oral traditions.
Where local identity adapts or revives
- Glocalisation: Multinationals localise to succeed: McDonald's in India serves no beef and sells the McAloo Tikki, and global streaming platforms commission regional-language shows.
- Digital regionalism: A Google-KPMG study (2017) found 234 million Indian-language internet users in 2016, outnumbering 175 million English users.
- Global market for local heritage: The International Day of Yoga (UN, 2014), GI tags from Darjeeling tea onwards and diaspora demand turn local identity into global value.
- Assertion: The 2017 Jallikattu protests in Tamil Nadu, which led to a state amendment of the animal cruelty law, show local identity mobilising against perceived global norms.
Assessment
- Hybrid, not lost: In line with Yogendra Singh's idea of the modernisation of Indian tradition, Indians increasingly hold layered identities: local, national and global at once; the losses are real but concentrated among small languages, crafts and marginal communities.
We are not losing local identity wholesale, but we are losing its most vulnerable parts. Mother-tongue education, support for crafts and millets, and digital archiving of oral traditions can let India be confidently global while remaining deeply local.
Read more — sources
- NCERTSocial Change and Development in India (Class XII) — Ch. 6, Globalisation and Social Change
- NCERTSocial Change and Development in India (Class XII) — Ch. 2, Cultural Change
- BookYogendra Singh, Modernization of Indian Tradition
- ReportUNESCO Atlas of the World's Languages in Danger (2010 edition)
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 1 2019
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.