Critically examine the role of WHO in providing global health security during the Covid-19 pandemic.
Look closely at WHO's role from both sides, its contributions and its failures, with evidence, and end with a reasoned judgement.
Common trap: Answers often become a one-sided attack on WHO. The best ones separate WHO's own failings from the limits of its mandate and funding set by member states, and end with reforms.
SyllabusImportant International institutions, agencies and fora- their structure, mandate.
Model answer
10 marks · 150-word limitUnder the International Health Regulations (2005), binding on 196 states parties, WHO alone can declare a Public Health Emergency of International Concern. Covid-19 was the sternest test of that mandate since 1948.
- 31 Dec 2019Wuhan pneumonia cluster reported
- 30 Jan 2020PHEIC declared
- 11 Mar 2020Characterised as a pandemic
- Mar 2020Solidarity treatment trial launched
- 24 Apr 2020ACT-Accelerator and later COVAX
- 19 May 2020WHA resolution for independent evaluation
- Jul 2020US notifies withdrawal
Contributions
- Norms and guidance: WHO shared testing protocols in January 2020 and guidance that weak health systems relied on.
- Science: The Solidarity trial tested repurposed drugs across many countries, finding hydroxychloroquine and remdesivir did not cut deaths.
- Equity: With Gavi and CEPI it built COVAX under the ACT-Accelerator to secure vaccines for poorer countries.
Shortcomings
- Delay and deference: On 14 January 2020 WHO echoed Chinese findings of no clear human-to-human spread, and its Emergency Committee held back a PHEIC on 22-23 January.
- Shifting advice: Mask guidance changed only in June 2020; advice against travel curbs was widely ignored.
- Weak powers: WHO cannot verify reports or enforce IHR duties, and assessed contributions fund under a fifth of its budget, leaving it reliant on earmarked donations.
- Geopolitics: The US withdrawal notice and Taiwan's exclusion showed rivalry eroding cooperation.
Assessment
- Reform: WHA resolution 73.1, co-sponsored by India, launched the Independent Panel led by Helen Clark and Ellen Johnson Sirleaf; India chaired the Executive Board from May 2020.
- Since then: The US reversed its exit in January 2021, but a fresh withdrawal notified in January 2025 took effect in January 2026; the World Health Assembly adopted a Pandemic Agreement in May 2025.
WHO's failures in 2020 were real but largely reflected the limits member states have placed on it. Global health security needs a WHO with stronger verification powers, predictable core funding and an equity mandate backed by states, not a weaker one.
Read more — sources
- OfficialWorld Health Organization, International Health Regulations (2005), third edition
- OfficialWorld Health Assembly resolution WHA73.1, COVID-19 response (19 May 2020)
- NCERTContemporary World Politics (Class XII) — Ch. 4, International Organisations
More from GS Paper 2 2020
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.