What are the major factors responsible for making rice-wheat system a success? In spite of this success how has this system become bane in India?
Identify the factors behind the system's success, then examine how the same system has turned harmful, ecologically, economically and nutritionally, with evidence.
Common trap: Answers often stop at stubble burning. A top answer links the success factors (technology, water, MSP and procurement, input subsidies) directly to the bane, showing that the same incentives that built the system now lock farmers into it.
SyllabusMajor crops-cropping patterns in various parts of the country, different types of irrigation and irrigation systems storage, transport and marketing of agricultural produce and issues and related constraints.
Model answer
15 marks · 250-word limitThe rice-wheat rotation, grown on about 10 million hectares mainly across the Indo-Gangetic plains, was the engine of the Green Revolution that turned a ship-to-mouth India of the mid-1960s into a country with surplus foodgrain stocks. Its success now threatens the soil, water and air of its heartland.
- HYV seeds and fertiliser
- Canals and tubewells
- Assured MSP and procurement
- Cheap power and inputs
- Food security achieved
- Groundwater over-extraction
- Soil fatigue and stagnant yields
- Stubble burning and smog
- Cereal glut, crop monotony
- Climate and fiscal costs
Factors behind its success
- Seed and science: Dwarf Mexican wheats from Norman Borlaug's programme and IRRI's IR8 rice from 1966, adapted by ICAR and Punjab Agricultural University with M. S. Swaminathan, multiplied yields.
- Water: The Bhakra-Nangal canals and a tubewell revolution, aided by free farm power in Punjab from 1997, made two irrigated crops a year possible.
- Price and market certainty: The Food Corporation of India and the Agricultural Prices Commission, both set up in 1965, offered assured MSP and open-ended procurement in Punjab and Haryana.
- Inputs and institutions: Subsidised urea, cooperative credit and regulated mandis cut risk, and the two crops fit neatly into kharif and rabi.
How the success became a bane
- Groundwater crisis: CGWB's 2017 assessment put Punjab's groundwater extraction at about 166 per cent of annual extractable recharge, with most blocks over-exploited, mainly by summer paddy.
- Stubble burning: The Punjab Preservation of Subsoil Water Act, 2009 delayed paddy transplanting to save water but narrowed the window before wheat sowing, encouraging residue burning that worsens Delhi-NCR's winter smog.
- Soil fatigue: Heavy urea use skewed nutrient ratios far from the recommended 4:2:1 NPK, zinc and other micronutrient deficiencies spread and yields plateaued.
- Economic lock-in: Central pool stocks in 2020 were far above the buffer norm while pulses and edible oils were imported; the Shanta Kumar Committee (2015) noted only about 6 per cent of farmers sell at MSP, concentrating the benefits.
- Nutrition and climate: Cereal monoculture displaced pulses and millets, and flooded paddies emit methane.
Way out
- Diversification incentives: Haryana's Mera Pani Meri Virasat scheme (2020) pays Rs 7,000 per acre to farmers who move out of paddy; similar payments, with MSP-backed procurement of pulses, maize and millets, can shift choices.
- Resource-conserving technology: Direct-seeded rice, laser levelling and Happy Seeder sowing cut water use and residue burning.
The rice-wheat system won India its food security; it cannot be allowed to cost the Punjab-Haryana belt its aquifers and soil. Rewarding water saved rather than grain produced, and making diversification as safe as paddy, is the way to keep its gains without its harms.
Read more — sources
- NCERTIndia: People and Economy (Class XII) — Ch. 3, Land Resources and Agriculture
- OfficialCentral Ground Water Board — National Compilation on Dynamic Ground Water Resources of India, 2017
- ReportReport of the High Level Committee on Restructuring of FCI (Shanta Kumar Committee), 2015
- NCERTIndian Economic Development (Class XI) — Ch. 2, Indian Economy 1950-1990
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 3 2020
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.