How does the draft Environment Impact Assessment (EIA) Notification, 2020 differ from the existing EIA Notification, 2006?
Compare the two instruments point by point; the answer must name each change precisely and say what it means for environmental protection, not merely describe the draft.
Common trap: Students list criticisms without anchoring them in the 2006 baseline. A top answer tabulates provision-by-provision changes with exact figures (20 vs 30 days, annual vs half-yearly, 50 vs 30 years) and notes the Supreme Court's position on ex post facto clearance.
SyllabusConservation, environmental pollution and degradation, environmental impact assessment.
Model answer
10 marks · 150-word limitThe EIA Notification, 2006, under the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986, makes prior environmental clearance mandatory for listed projects. The draft EIA Notification, 2020 (S.O. 1199(E), 23 March 2020) seeks to replace it, promising ease of business but diluting safeguards.
- Prior clearance before any work
- 30-day public hearing notice
- Half-yearly compliance reports
- SEAC screens B1 and B2
- Post-facto clearance for violators
- 20-day notice; wider exemptions
- Annual compliance reports
- Fixed B2 list; Environment Permission
Key differences
| Provision | EIA 2006 | Draft EIA 2020 |
|---|---|---|
| Projects started without clearance | Illegal; only a one-time six-month window in 2017 | Standing post-facto route for violators with remediation plans |
| Public hearing notice | 30 days | 20 days |
| Expansion of projects | Public consultation generally needed | Capacity rise up to 50% exempt from public consultation |
| Compliance reports | Every six months | Once a year |
| Validity of clearance | Mining 30 years; river valley 10; others 7 | Mining 50 years; river valley, irrigation and nuclear 15; others 10 |
| Strategic and border projects | Defence projects exempt from hearing | No information on strategic projects in public domain; linear projects within 100 km of the LAC exempt from hearing |
| Reporting violations | Not restricted | Cognisance only of reports by the violator, government or appraisal bodies |
Implications
- Against settled law: In Alembic Pharmaceuticals v Rohit Prajapati (1 April 2020) the Supreme Court held ex post facto clearances contrary to law.
- Weaker participation: B2 projects such as inland waterways escape public hearing; shorter notice hurts remote communities.
- Process concerns: Released during the lockdown, it was ordered by the Delhi High Court to be published in all 22 Eighth Schedule languages.
Faster clearances should come from digitised, time-bound appraisal and stronger monitoring, not post-facto amnesty and a weaker public voice. Since then the draft has not been notified in full; changes have come through piecemeal amendments to the 2006 notification.
Read more — sources
- OfficialMoEFCC, Environment Impact Assessment Notification, S.O. 1533(E), 14 September 2006 (as amended)
- OfficialMoEFCC, Draft EIA Notification 2020, S.O. 1199(E), 23 March 2020, and translated versions
- ReportCentre for Policy Research–Namati Environmental Justice Program, Reduced Regulations and Increased Exemptions: Draft EIA Notification 2020 (Parts I and II)
- OfficialSupreme Court of India, Alembic Pharmaceuticals Ltd v Rohit Prajapati, judgment of 1 April 2020
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 3 2020
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.