To what extent did the role of the Moderates prepare a base for the wider freedom movement? Comment.
Give a reasoned opinion on the statement; 'to what extent' means you must weigh what the Moderates achieved against what they could not, and end with a clear judgement.
Common trap: Most answers list Moderate demands and dismiss them as mendicants. A top answer links each Moderate contribution (drain theory, constitutional training, an all-India platform) to a specific later phase of the movement, and still marks the limits of their social base.
SyllabusThe Freedom Struggle - its various stages and important contributors/contributions from different parts of the country.
Model answer
15 marks · 250-word limitWhen 72 delegates met in Bombay in December 1885 under W.C. Bonnerjee to found the Indian National Congress, they began two decades of Moderate leadership (1885-1905). Their methods looked timid, but they built the intellectual, organisational and political base on which later mass struggles stood.
- Economic critique of colonial rule (drain theory)
- Educated Indians united on an all-India platform
- Training in public debate, press and petitions
- Anti-partition protest and Swadeshi (1905)
- Swaraj adopted as goal (Calcutta, 1906)
- Mass movements under Gandhi
How the Moderates prepared the base
- Economic nationalism: Dadabhai Naoroji's Poverty and Un-British Rule in India and R.C. Dutt's Economic History of India exposed the drain of wealth, destroying the myth of benevolent British rule and giving later swadeshi its intellectual case.
- All-India platform: Annual Congress sessions in different cities brought leaders from every province together and created a shared national identity above region and religion.
- Political education: Petitions, memorials and a vigorous press, with leaders such as Surendranath Banerjea, Pherozeshah Mehta and G.K. Gokhale, trained public opinion in modern constitutional politics.
- Concrete gains: Their pressure helped secure the Indian Councils Act 1892 and the 1893 House of Commons resolution for simultaneous ICS examinations, and they raised civil liberties, Indianisation of services and cuts in military spending.
- Bridge to the next phase: Under Gokhale the 1905 Benares session backed the Swadeshi and boycott movement, and at Calcutta in 1906 Naoroji declared swaraj the Congress goal.
Limits of their role
- Narrow social base: The movement remained confined to the urban, English-educated middle class; peasants and workers stayed outside it.
- Faith in British justice: Belief in the providential nature of British rule and in prayer and petition yielded few results, provoking the Extremist critique and the Surat split of 1907.
Assessment
- Foundation, not culmination: Gandhi called Gokhale his political guru, and the drain theory and constitutional demands ran through later Congress programmes, showing continuity rather than rupture.
The Moderates did not win freedom, nor did they try to mobilise the masses, but they won the argument that British rule impoverished India. That economic and constitutional critique, and the national platform they built, made the later mass movements possible.
Read more — sources
- NCERTOur Pasts - III (Class VIII) - Ch. 8, The Making of the National Movement: 1870s-1947
- BookBipan Chandra et al., India's Struggle for Independence
- BookSekhar Bandyopadhyay, From Plassey to Partition
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 1 2021
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.