Though the Human Rights Commissions have contributed immensely to the protection of human rights in India, yet they have failed to assert themselves against the mighty and powerful. Analyzing their structural and practical limitations, suggest remedial measures.
Break the issue into its parts and examine how they interact; here, weigh the contribution, separate structural from practical limitations, and end with concrete remedies.
Common trap: Answers often call the NHRC a toothless tiger and stop. Examiners reward naming the exact sections of the Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993 that limit it, distinguishing design flaws from practice, and remedies that fit the Paris Principles.
SyllabusStatutory, regulatory and various quasi-judicial bodies.
Model answer
15 marks · 250-word limitThe National Human Rights Commission was set up in October 1993 under the Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993, followed by State commissions. They have given victims of custodial abuse a low-cost forum, but their power to recommend rather than enforce leaves them weakest exactly where the violator is the State or the powerful.
- Recommendations not binding
- Barred from probing armed forces
- One-year limitation
- Police staff on deputation
- Retired judges, executive selection
- Vacancies in State commissions
- Huge complaint backlog
Contribution
- Custodial justice: The NHRC's 1993 direction that every custodial death be reported within 24 hours, and its guidelines on encounter killings, created a national monitoring system.
- Landmark interventions: It took up the Punjab mass cremations case referred by the Supreme Court and, after the 2002 Gujarat riots, approached the Court for the Best Bakery retrial.
- Wider agenda: It has worked on bonded labour, manual scavenging and silicosis, and issued COVID-19 advisories in 2020–21.
Structural limitations
- Recommendatory only: Under Section 18 it can only recommend compensation or prosecution; governments may ignore or dilute its advice.
- Jurisdictional bars: Section 19 lets it only seek a report from the Centre on armed forces cases, and Section 36(2) bars complaints made more than a year after the incident.
- Composition and selection: Members are mostly retired judges and officials picked by a panel dominated by the ruling side; Justice Arun Mishra's appointment in June 2021, enabled by the 2019 amendment, drew criticism.
- Dependent investigation: Its investigating staff come on deputation from the police, the very institution most complained against, a point GANHRI raised when it deferred NHRC's re-accreditation in 2016.
Practical limitations
- Overload and delay: Tens of thousands of complaints a year are mostly disposed of on reports from the accused department itself.
- Weak State commissions: Several SHRCs work with vacant posts, thin budgets and little follow-up.
Remedial measures
- Binding force: Make recommendations binding unless a government records reasons before the legislature within a fixed time.
- Independence: An own investigation cadre, financial autonomy and a pluralist selection panel, in line with the Paris Principles.
- Wider reach: Allow independent inquiry into armed forces cases, relax the one-year bar for grave violations and fill SHRC vacancies within set deadlines.
The commissions have built a culture of accountability but not a deterrent. Giving them binding teeth, independent investigators and pluralist membership would turn them from advisory bodies into true guardians of the Article 21 promise, especially for the voiceless against the powerful.
Read more — sources
- OfficialProtection of Human Rights Act, 1993 (as amended in 2006 and 2019)
- ReportNHRC Annual Reports — complaints and action taken
- OfficialUN General Assembly resolution 48/134 (1993) — Principles relating to the Status of National Institutions (Paris Principles)
- BookM. Laxmikanth, Indian Polity — chapter on the National Human Rights Commission
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 2 2021
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.