The newly tri-nation partnership AUKUS is aimed at countering China’s ambitions in the Indo-Pacific region. Is it going to supersede the existing partnerships in the region? Discuss the strength and impact of AUKUS in the present scenario.
Explore the question from several angles with evidence; here three tasks are set: whether AUKUS supersedes existing partnerships, its strengths, and its impact now.
Common trap: Candidates often treat AUKUS and the Quad as rivals. A top answer separates their nature, a military-technology pact versus a non-military public-goods grouping, gives a clear no on supersession, and weighs the France rift, regional unease and India's interests.
SyllabusEffect of policies and politics of developed and developing countries on India's interests, Indian diaspora.
Model answer
15 marks · 250-word limitAnnounced on 15 September 2021, AUKUS binds Australia, the UK and the US in a security partnership whose first project will give Australia at least eight nuclear-powered, conventionally armed submarines, making it only the second country after the UK to receive US naval nuclear propulsion technology.
- Trilateral security pact
- Australia, UK, US allies
- Nuclear submarines, AI, quantum, cyber
- Hard military deterrence
- Informal, non-treaty dialogue
- India, Japan, US, Australia
- Vaccines, climate, critical technology
- Public goods, rules-based order
Strengths of AUKUS
- Undersea deterrence: Nuclear-powered submarines can patrol far and long undetected, raising the cost of coercion in the South China Sea and beyond.
- Technology pooling: It also covers cyber, artificial intelligence, quantum technologies and additional undersea capabilities.
- Alliance depth: It builds on ANZUS (1951), Five Eyes intelligence sharing and the UK's Indo-Pacific tilt in its Integrated Review (March 2021).
Will it supersede existing partnerships?
- Different purpose: The first in-person Quad leaders' summit (24 September 2021) focused on vaccines, climate and critical technologies; Foreign Secretary Harsh Shringla said AUKUS was neither relevant to the Quad nor would affect it.
- Narrow membership: It excludes India, Japan and ASEAN, so it cannot replace ASEAN-centred forums such as the East Asia Summit.
- Long lead time: An 18-month consultation began in 2021, and submarines are not expected before the late 2030s.
Impact in the present scenario
- Rift among partners: Australia scrapped its c. A$90 billion Attack-class submarine deal with France's Naval Group, and Paris recalled its ambassadors from Washington and Canberra.
- Regional unease: China called it a Cold War mentality, Indonesia and Malaysia warned of an arms race, and non-proliferation experts flagged the precedent of transferring highly enriched naval fuel to a non-nuclear-weapon state.
- For India: A stronger Australian navy aids Indian Ocean balance, but the pact shows US priority for treaty allies and opens room for deeper India-France ties.
- Since then: The March 2023 San Diego plan set out Australia buying US Virginia-class submarines from the early 2030s and co-developing an SSN-AUKUS class with the UK.
AUKUS adds hard military weight to the Indo-Pacific balance but layers onto, rather than supersedes, the Quad, ASEAN-led forums and bilateral ties. For India, it is a cue to build its own maritime capabilities and diversify partnerships, not a substitute for them.
Read more — sources
- OfficialJoint Leaders Statement on AUKUS, 15 September 2021, The White House
- OfficialJoint Statement from Quad Leaders, 24 September 2021, Ministry of External Affairs
- OfficialJoint Leaders Statement on AUKUS (San Diego), 13 March 2023
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 2 2021
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.