EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2023EssayTopic 5 · 125 marksModel answer

Girls are weighed down by restrictions, boys with demands — two equally harmful disciplines.

DirectiveEssay
Marks125
Word limit1000–1200
PaperEssay
What the examiner wants

1000–1200 words, 125 marks. One topic from each Section. The phrasing is abstract but the subject is social and political: graders reward a clear reading, Indian evidence in every section, a fair counter-view and a balanced, forward-looking conclusion.

Common trap: Most essays write only about girls, or flatly accept "equally". A top essay shows how one patriarchal system disciplines both sexes — restriction for girls, performance pressure for boys — with Indian evidence on each side, and then challenges "equally harmful": the harms are connected but not symmetrical, since restriction on girls is backed by violence and material deprivation.

Essay brief

1000–1200 words · 125 marks
Ways to read the topic
  • Mirror-image: patriarchy assigns girls the burden of protection (restriction) and boys the burden of provision (demand); both are cages built from the same blueprint.
  • Developmental: restrictions shrink girls' mobility, education and voice; demands crush boys' emotional expression and push them into risk and despair.
  • Systemic: the two disciplines reinforce each other — the restricted daughter and the over-burdened son are two halves of one household economy of honour and earning.
  • Critical (strongest): both disciplines harm, but "equally" must be questioned — the essay should argue for freeing both sexes while recognising that girls' restriction carries the heavier, often life-threatening, cost.
Dimensions to cover

Restrictions on girls

  • Curbs on mobility, clothing, friendships and phone use justified as "safety" and family honour
  • Early marriage, dowry and son preference — reflected in skewed sex ratio at birth
  • Low female labour force participation linked to mobility limits and unpaid care burdens
  • Hostel curfews and campus rules stricter for women students — challenged by student campaigns

Demands on boys

  • Pressure to be the breadwinner, to choose "safe" careers and to succeed in competitive exams
  • Emotional suppression — "boys don't cry" — leaving distress unspoken
  • Coaching-hub student suicides (Kota) and the high male share of suicides in NCRB data
  • Boys pulled out of school for paid work; pressure to prove masculinity through risk and aggression

How the two disciplines connect

  • The same ideal of family honour restricts daughters and burdens sons
  • Toxic masculinity learned under pressure feeds violence that justifies further restriction of girls
  • Media, cinema and advertising reproduce both scripts

Policy and law

  • Article 15(3) and Article 39 — the constitutional basis for gender justice
  • Beti Bachao Beti Padhao (2015), POCSO Act (2012), Prohibition of Child Marriage Act (2006)
  • Mental health — Tele-MANAS helpline, counselling in schools and coaching centres
  • NEP 2020's Gender-Inclusion Fund; gender sensitisation in curricula

Families, schools and culture

  • Shared household chores and emotional literacy taught to both sexes from childhood
  • Fathers modelling care; mothers encouraging daughters' independence
  • Sports, arts and NCC as spaces that loosen both scripts

The counter-view: are they equal?

  • Girls face sex-selective abortion, malnutrition, violence and early marriage — harms boys do not share
  • Demands on boys come with privileges — inheritance, mobility, voice — that restriction denies girls
  • False equivalence can dilute urgent measures for girls' safety and rights
Structure

Opening. Open with two siblings in the same home on the same evening: the sister told to be back before dark, the brother told he must clear the entrance exam or shame the family — one discipline in two forms.

Body. Develop each discipline with Indian evidence, then show how they interlock under one idea of honour and provision. Follow with law, policy and the role of families and schools.

Counter-view. Spend a full paragraph contesting "equally": sex ratio, missing women and violence show that girls' restriction is often the deadlier discipline, even if boys' suffering is real.

Conclusion. Close with a vision of upbringing as freedom for both — daughters given wings, sons given permission to feel — and return to the two siblings, now raised differently.

Examples to use
  • Skewed sex ratio at birth and son preference (NFHS-5) — Evidence that restriction begins before birth
  • Amartya Sen's "missing women" thesis (1990) — The counter-view on asymmetry of harm
  • Student suicides in coaching hubs such as Kota — The cost of demands on young people, often boys
  • NCRB Accidental Deaths and Suicides in India report — Male share of suicides as evidence of hidden pressure
  • Beti Bachao Beti Padhao (2015) — State attempt to change attitudes to daughters
  • Campus campaigns against discriminatory hostel curfews for women students — Restriction in modern institutions, not only villages
  • Periodic Labour Force Survey — female labour force participation — Economic consequence of restriction
Quotes
  • “One is not born, but rather becomes, a woman.” — Simone de Beauvoir, The Second Sex
Pitfalls
  • Writing only about girls, ignoring the second half of the topic
  • Accepting "equally harmful" uncritically; the examiner expects you to weigh it
  • Blaming only rural or traditional families — urban, educated settings show both disciplines too

More from Essay 2023

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.