EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2023EssayTopic 7 · 125 marksModel answer

A society that has more justice is a society that needs less charity.

DirectiveEssay
Marks125
Word limit1000–1200
PaperEssay
What the examiner wants

1000–1200 words, 125 marks. One topic from each Section. The phrasing is abstract but the subject is social and political: graders reward a clear reading, Indian evidence in every section, a fair counter-view and a balanced, forward-looking conclusion.

Common trap: The common error is an essay on philanthropy or CSR. The top essay distinguishes charity (discretionary, from the giver's goodwill) from justice (entitlement, from the citizen's right), traces India's move from welfare to rights-based laws, and still defends a residual space for compassion that no just system can fully replace.

Essay brief

1000–1200 words · 125 marks
Ways to read the topic
  • Structural: charity treats symptoms of injustice; when institutions distribute fairly, the need for alms shrinks.
  • Rights-based: justice turns the poor from supplicants into right-holders — food, work and education as entitlements, not favours.
  • Moral-psychological: dependence on charity erodes dignity and entrenches the giver's power; justice restores agency.
  • Complementary (strongest): justice should shrink the need for charity, but compassion remains necessary for disaster, loneliness and the gaps any system leaves — charity at its best becomes solidarity.
Dimensions to cover

Charity and justice distinguished

  • Charity depends on the giver's will; justice is owed and enforceable
  • Charity can sustain the status quo; justice changes structures
  • Ambedkar's insistence that the oppressed need rights, not paternalistic uplift

Constitutional vision

  • Preamble — social, economic and political justice
  • Article 38: the State shall secure a social order in which justice informs all institutions
  • Article 21 read expansively by courts — right to food, shelter, livelihood

From welfare to entitlements in India

  • MGNREGA (2005) — guaranteed work as a legal right
  • Right to Education Act (2009), National Food Security Act (2013), RTI Act (2005)
  • Mid-day meals moved from charity-like provision to court-mandated entitlement and then PM POSHAN

Where injustice breeds the need for charity

  • Landlessness, caste discrimination and informal work create permanent dependence
  • Out-of-pocket health spending pushes families into debt and towards crowdfunding pleas
  • Disaster victims depend on donations when insurance and rehabilitation systems are weak

The enduring role of giving

  • Indian traditions of daan, seva, zakat and langar build social solidarity
  • Civil society fills gaps quickly — community kitchens during the 2020 lockdown
  • Mandatory CSR under Section 135 of the Companies Act, 2013 — philanthropy channelled by law

The counter-view

  • No justice system is perfect; compassion is needed for what law cannot reach — grief, loneliness
  • Charity can be a pioneer: many state schemes began as voluntary experiments
  • Rights without capacity to deliver remain on paper; voluntary effort supplements weak states
Structure

Opening. Open with a langar queue outside a gurdwara and a ration-card holder at a fair-price shop — both receiving food, but one as a gift and the other as a right; ask which a free citizen should rely on.

Body. Define the two ideas sharply, ground justice in the Constitution, trace India's rights-based laws, and show how unjust structures manufacture the need for charity.

Counter-view. Give a full paragraph to charity's enduring role — disasters, emotional care, social innovation — and concede that a society with no giving would be poorer, not more just.

Conclusion. Close with the idea that justice should make charity unnecessary for survival, leaving compassion free to do what only compassion can; return to the langar as solidarity rather than survival.

Examples to use
  • MGNREGA (2005) — The shift from relief works to a legal right to work
  • National Food Security Act (2013) and the PUCL right-to-food litigation — Food as entitlement, driven by courts and law
  • Right to Education Act (2009) — Education as a justiciable right
  • Section 135, Companies Act 2013 (mandatory CSR) — Institutionalised charity and its limits
  • Vinoba Bhave's Bhoodan movement (1951) — Voluntary giving that could not substitute for land reform
  • Community kitchens during the 2020 lockdown — Charity filling gaps of the system — counter-view
Quotes
  • “True compassion is more than flinging a coin to a beggar; it comes to see that an edifice which produces beggars needs restructuring.” — Martin Luther King Jr.
  • “Justice is the first virtue of social institutions, as truth is of systems of thought.” — John Rawls, A Theory of Justice
Pitfalls
  • Writing an essay on philanthropy and CSR alone — the topic is about the relationship between justice and charity
  • Dismissing charity entirely; the examiner rewards a nuanced place for compassion
  • Abstract argument without India's rights-based laws as evidence

More from Essay 2023

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.