Discuss the evolution of the collegium system in India. Critically examine the advantages and disadvantages of the system of appointment of the Judges of the Supreme Court of India and that of the USA.
Present the evolution with its turning points, then weigh the merits and demerits of both appointment models fairly and arrive at a reasoned view.
Common trap: The question has two parts and a comparison. Answers that only narrate the three Judges cases lose marks; the US model of presidential nomination with Senate confirmation must be assessed on its own merits and demerits, not just described.
SyllabusComparison of the Indian constitutional scheme with that of other countries.
Model answer
15 marks · 250-word limitArticle 124(2) says Supreme Court judges are appointed by the President after consultation with the Chief Justice of India and other judges. Judicial interpretation turned this consultation into the collegium, a system of judges appointing judges found in no other major democracy.
- 1981First Judges case: executive primacy, consultation not concurrence
- 1993Second Judges case: CJI's primacy, collegium of CJI + 2
- 1998Third Judges case: CJI + 4 senior-most judges
- 201499th Amendment and NJAC Act
- 2015NJAC struck down 4:1; collegium revived
- 2017Collegium resolutions published online
Evolution in India
- From executive to judicial primacy: S.P. Gupta (1981) gave the executive the final word; the Second Judges case (1993) reversed it, and the 1998 Presidential reference under Article 143 fixed a collegium of the CJI and four senior-most judges.
- Failed reform: The NJAC, with the CJI, two judges, the Law Minister and two eminent persons, was struck down in 2015 with Justice J. Chelameswar dissenting; the revised Memorandum of Procedure remains unfinalised.
India and the USA compared
| Aspect | India (collegium) | USA (nomination and confirmation) |
|---|---|---|
| Who decides | Senior judges recommend; binding on the government if reiterated | President nominates; Senate gives advice and consent (Article II, Section 2) |
| Advantages | Insulation from executive and party pressure; seniority gives predictability | Democratic legitimacy; open Senate Judiciary Committee hearings; scrutiny of record |
| Disadvantages | Opaque, no written criteria; charges of nepotism; delays as the government sits on files; little diversity, with a single woman judge by mid-2025 | Politicised, near party-line confirmations; ideological court-packing; Merrick Garland's 2016 nomination was never considered |
| Tenure | Retirement at 65; frequent short tenures of CJIs | Life tenure during good behaviour; strategic retirements |
Assessment
- Neither is ideal: India trades accountability for independence; the USA trades independence for legitimacy, as the ideological sorting of its Court shows.
- Middle path: A finalised Memorandum of Procedure, a permanent secretariat, published criteria and timelines for both judiciary and government could keep primacy with judges while making the process transparent.
The aim is not to move power from judges to politicians but to make appointments defensible in public. A transparent, time-bound collegium with recorded reasons and wider diversity would preserve the independence that the NJAC verdict protected while answering the legitimacy question that the US model handles better.
Read more — sources
- NCERTIndian Constitution at Work (Class XI) — Ch. 6, Judiciary
- OfficialSupreme Court Advocates-on-Record Association v Union of India (1993) and (2015); In re Special Reference No. 1 of 1998
- OfficialConstitution of the United States — Article II, Section 2
- BookM. Laxmikanth, Indian Polity — chapter on the Supreme Court
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 2 2025
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.