Discuss the different types of subsidies and supports provided by the Government of India to agricultural sector. Examine the related issues pertaining to Agreement on Agriculture of World Trade Organisation (WTO).
Inspect the claim closely, testing it against evidence on both sides.
Common trap: The 1986-88 external reference price is the single most important technical detail here — it is why India's measured support appears to breach a limit its actual support does not.
SyllabusIssues related to direct and indirect farm subsidies and minimum support prices; public distribution system; WTO and its implications.
Model answer
244 words · 250-word limitIndia's farm support spans price, input and income instruments. The WTO dispute is not about whether they exist but about how they are classified and measured.
Price support operates through minimum support prices for over twenty notified crops, with procurement by FCI and PM-AASHA adding price-deficiency components. Input subsidies cover fertiliser through the nutrient-based scheme, subsidised power, irrigation and seed. Credit runs through interest subvention and the Kisan Credit Card, PM-KISAN provides direct income transfer, and the NFSA food subsidy sustains demand.
The Agreement on Agriculture disciplines this through three pillars — domestic support, market access and export competition — and classifies support into boxes. Green Box measures are non-distorting and unlimited; Blue Box are production-limiting; Amber Box are trade-distorting and capped, with an Aggregate Measurement of Support limit of ten per cent of production value for developing countries. Article 6.2 gives developing countries additional room for input subsidies to low-income and resource-poor farmers.
The issues for India are structural. The external reference price is frozen at 1986-88 levels and computed in foreign currency, so decades of inflation inflate the measured support. Public stockholding for food security is counted as Amber Box, though its purpose is consumption rather than trade distortion.
The Bali Peace Clause of 2013 shields India's stockholding from challenge until a permanent solution is agreed, and that solution remains pending. India's substantive case is that a rule written for surplus-exporting economies measures food security programmes as though they were export subsidies.
Answer plan — how to structure itShowHide
Open with: India's farm support is spread across price, input and income instruments, and the WTO dispute is not about their existence but about how they are classified and measured.
Types of support
- Price support: MSP for 22-23 notified crops, procurement by FCI and State agencies, PM-AASHA with price deficiency and procurement components
- Input subsidies: fertiliser through the nutrient-based subsidy and urea price control; power and irrigation water at subsidised tariff; seed and credit subvention
- Credit: interest subvention on short-term crop loans, Kisan Credit Card, priority sector lending norms
- Income support: PM-KISAN direct transfer
- Risk: PM Fasal Bima Yojana premium subsidy
- Infrastructure and marketing: Agriculture Infrastructure Fund, e-NAM, warehousing support
- Consumer-side: PDS and NFSA food subsidy, which is also farm demand support
The WTO Agreement on Agriculture framework
- Three pillars: domestic support, market access, export competition
- Boxes: Green Box (non or minimally trade-distorting, unlimited), Blue Box (production-limiting), Amber Box (trade-distorting, capped)
- Aggregate Measurement of Support capped at 10 per cent of value of production for developing countries — the de minimis limit
- Article 6.2 gives developing countries additional space for investment and input subsidies to low-income and resource-poor farmers
The issues for India
- External reference price fixed at 1986-88 levels and computed in foreign currency, so decades of inflation inflate the calculated support
- Public stockholding for food security counted as Amber Box support, though its purpose is consumption not trade distortion
- The Bali Peace Clause (2013) protects India's public stockholding from challenge until a permanent solution is agreed — that solution remains pending
- Developed-country Green Box support is unlimited despite being large, which India argues is asymmetric
- Export restrictions India uses for domestic price stability attract criticism
- Cotton and sugar subsidy disputes brought against India
Draw: A boxes diagram — Green, Blue, Amber — with each Indian scheme placed in the box it is claimed under and the contested ones flagged.
Close with: India's substantive case is that a rule written for surplus-exporting economies measures food security programmes as if they were export subsidies — the reform India seeks is to the reference price and the stockholding treatment, not an exemption from discipline.
Read more — sources
- NCERTIndian Economic Development (Class XI) — Ch. 5, Rural Development
- BookWTO Agreement on Agriculture; Commerce Ministry briefs on public stockholding; Economic Survey
- EdiShorts appMains GS-3 — Agriculture: Subsidies & Trade
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 3 2026
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.