EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2026GS Paper 3Q17 · 15 marksEnvironmentModel answer

What are the challenges to solid waste management in India? Discuss the governmental policy framework on solid waste management. Discuss the success/failure cases of Delhi and Indore cities highlighting the salient feature of their solid waste management initiatives.

DirectiveDiscuss
Marks15
Word limit250
PaperGS Paper 3
What the examiner wants

Present the issue from more than one side with reasoning, then arrive at a considered position.

Common trap: Three explicit parts, and the city comparison is the one most answers neglect. Indore's segregated collection and Delhi's legacy landfills are the named specifics the question is built to elicit.

SyllabusConservation, environmental pollution and degradation; urbanization and related issues.

Model answer

274 words · 250-word limit
Introduction

India's waste problem is one of segregation rather than collection. Collection efficiency is high in most cities, but processing lags far behind — and unsegregated waste is precisely what makes processing uneconomic.

Body

The challenges follow from that. Source segregation remains weak despite being mandatory, so mixed waste reaches facilities designed for sorted input. The gap between waste generated and processed accumulates as legacy landfill, with sites such as Ghazipur and Deonar producing fires, leachate and methane. Municipal finances are thin, user-charge recovery poor, and technical staff scarce, while the informal sector performs much of the actual recovery without recognition or safety.

The policy framework is reasonably complete. The Solid Waste Management Rules, 2016 mandate segregation at source into wet, dry and domestic hazardous streams and place obligations on bulk generators, supported by the Plastic Waste and E-Waste Rules. Swachh Bharat Mission Urban 2.0 targets garbage-free cities and legacy dumpsite remediation, while Swachh Survekshan made municipal performance competitive and Extended Producer Responsibility supplies the financing principle.

Indore demonstrates what compliance looks like. Near-universal doorstep collection uses compartmentalised vehicles and refuses unsegregated waste outright. Large-scale bio-methanation converts wet waste into CNG that fuels city buses, and bio-remediation reclaimed the Devguradia dumpsite. Sustained citizen behaviour change, user charges and ward-level accountability held it together.

Conclusion

Delhi shows the converse — three overheight legacy landfills, low segregation compliance, processing capacity below generation, and fragmented governance across agencies that diluted accountability, drawing repeated NGT strictures. The contrast is not technological, since both had access to the same options. It is about doorstep enforcement and a single accountable authority: waste management succeeds or fails at the household, not at the landfill.

+
Value addition: A comparison table of Indore against Delhi on segregation rate, processing capacity, legacy remediation and accountability structure answers the third part directly.
Answer plan — how to structure itShowHide

Open with: India's waste problem is one of segregation rather than collection — collection efficiency is high in most cities, but processing lags far behind, and unsegregated waste is what makes processing uneconomic.

Challenges

  • Source segregation remains weak despite being mandatory, so mixed waste reaches processing facilities
  • Large gap between waste generated and waste actually processed; the residue becomes legacy landfill
  • Legacy dumpsites — Ghazipur, Bhalswa, Okhla in Delhi, Deonar in Mumbai — with fires, leachate and methane
  • Weak municipal finance and low user-charge recovery; ULBs lack technical staff
  • Informal sector does much of the recovery without recognition, safety or social security
  • Land scarcity for new facilities and consistent public resistance to siting
  • Rising plastic and e-waste volumes; construction and demolition waste largely unmanaged

Policy framework

  • Solid Waste Management Rules, 2016 — mandatory segregation at source into wet, dry and domestic hazardous; extended responsibility on bulk generators
  • Companion rules: Plastic Waste Management Rules 2016 with EPR, E-Waste, Bio-medical, and Construction and Demolition Waste Rules
  • Swachh Bharat Mission Urban, and SBM-U 2.0 with its garbage-free cities and legacy dumpsite remediation focus
  • Swachh Survekshan as an annual ranking that made performance competitive and politically visible
  • GOBARdhan and waste-to-energy and bio-methanation support; Extended Producer Responsibility as the financing principle
  • NGT oversight and the Environment Protection Act as the enforcement backdrop

Indore — the success case

  • Repeatedly ranked India's cleanest city under Swachh Survekshan
  • Near-universal doorstep collection with strictly segregated compartmentalised vehicles, and refusal to collect unsegregated waste
  • Large-scale bio-methanation converting wet waste to CNG that fuels city buses — closing the loop
  • Bio-remediation of the Devguradia legacy dumpsite, reclaiming the land
  • Sustained citizen behaviour change, user charges, ward-level accountability and political continuity

Delhi — the failure case

  • Three legacy landfills exceeding permissible height, with recurring fires and groundwater leachate
  • Segregation compliance low; processing capacity below generation, so fresh waste continues to be dumped
  • Fragmented governance across multiple agencies weakened accountability before municipal unification
  • Waste-to-energy plants contested on emission grounds; siting resistance
  • Repeated NGT strictures and missed remediation deadlines

Draw: A comparison table — Indore against Delhi — on segregation rate, processing capacity, legacy remediation and institutional accountability.

Close with: The Indore-Delhi contrast is not about technology, which was available to both, but about enforcement at the doorstep and a single accountable authority — waste management fails or succeeds at the household, not at the landfill.

Solid Waste Management Rules, 2016source segregationSBM-U 2.0Swachh SurvekshanExtended Producer Responsibilitybio-methanationDevguradiaGhazipurlegacy dumpsite bio-remediation

Read more — sources

  • NCERTIndia: People and Economy (Class XII) — Urbanisation; Biology Class XII Ch. 16, Environmental Issues
  • BookSolid Waste Management Rules, 2016; CPCB annual reports; Swachh Survekshan results
  • EdiShorts appMains GS-3 — Environment: Waste Management

Related questions from earlier years

More from GS Paper 3 2026

Q1·10 marks·150 words·Economy, Sci & Tech
What do you mean by Digital Rupee? In this context, explain the working and progress of India's Central Bank Digital Currency (CBDC).
The Digital Rupee (e₹) is sovereign currency in digital form — a direct liability of the Reserve Bank, legal tender at par with cash, and therefore distinct from both…
Read the model answer →
Q2·10 marks·150 words·Economy
Examine the view that financial inclusion is an integral part of social and economic inclusion in a country like India. Also throw light on the usefulness of the R.B.I.'s Financial Inclusion Index.
Financial exclusion is rarely the primary deprivation. It is the mechanism through which other deprivations persist, which is why inclusion works as an enabler rather…
Read the model answer →
Q3·10 marks·150 words·Agriculture
Describe the various Technology Missions initiated in Indian agriculture and examine their role in food security.
Technology Missions answered commodity-specific stagnation, each targeting one crop group with an end-to-end package of seed, extension, credit and procurement rather…
Read the model answer →
Q4·10 marks·150 words·Agriculture
Explain the factors responsible for inefficiency of agri-produce marketing. How e-commerce helps to reduce inefficiency of agri-produce marketing? Explain.
The farmer's share of the consumer rupee is low in India, especially for perishables. That gap measures marketing inefficiency, and its causes are structural.
Read the model answer →
Q5·10 marks·150 words·Agriculture, Sci & Tech
Explain by giving two examples, how biotechnology has helped the Indian farmers in processing their perishable crops.
Perishability is a biological problem — ethylene-driven ripening, microbial spoilage and enzymatic browning — so biotechnology intervenes precisely where refrigeration…
Read the model answer →

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.