UPSC Prelims 2020 GS Paper 1 Q14 · Modern History
Year2020
PaperGS Paper 1
QuestionQ14
SubjectModern History
One common agreement between Gandhism and Marxism is
- athe final goal of a stateless society
- bclass struggle
- cabolition of private property
- deconomic determinism
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Correct answer(a) the final goal of a stateless society
Both see a stateless society as the ideal, Marx as the end of history after the 'withering away' of the state and Gandhi as 'enlightened anarchy'.
Statement-by-statement analysis
✓ Option (a)
- Marx: after the proletarian dictatorship, classes disappear and the state 'withers away' into communism.
- Gandhi: the state is 'violence in a concentrated form'; the ideal is a stateless society of self-governing village republics (Ram Rajya).
✗ Option (b)
- Class struggle is the motor of history for Marx; Gandhi rejected it and sought harmony between classes through trusteeship and change of heart.
✗ Option (c)
- Marx called for abolishing private ownership of the means of production; Gandhi let owners keep property as 'trustees' for society.
✗ Option (d)
- Economic determinism (the economic base shapes all of society) is Marxist; Gandhi gave primacy to moral and spiritual forces.
Concept to know
- The two agree on the end and differ on the means: Marx accepts violent revolution and a transitional proletarian dictatorship; Gandhi insists on non-violence because the means shape the end.
- Marxism rests on historical materialism, class struggle, surplus value and economic determinism.
- Gandhism rests on truth (satya), non-violence (ahimsa), trusteeship, swadeshi, decentralisation and sarvodaya (welfare of all).
- Both criticised capitalist exploitation and wanted an equal society; Gandhi also opposed large-scale industrialisation and centralisation, which Marxism accepts.
- Gandhi's model of the state appears in Hind Swaraj (1909): self-reliant villages, minimal government, power flowing upward from the village.
Related facts for revision
- 'Unto This Last' (John Ruskin) inspired Gandhi's sarvodaya; he translated it into Gujarati as 'Sarvodaya'.
- Vinoba Bhave's Bhoodan (from 1951, Pochampalli) and Gramdan movements applied Gandhian trusteeship to land.
- Gandhian ideas in the Constitution are Directive Principles: Article 40 (village panchayats), 43 (cottage industries), 47 (prohibition) and 48 (protecting cows).
- M.N. Roy moved from Marxism to 'Radical Humanism'; Jayaprakash Narayan moved from socialism to Gandhian 'total revolution'.
- Ram Manohar Lohia's 'Chaukhamba Raj' (four-pillar state) is another model of decentralisation.
How UPSC tests this
Comparing ideologies by their ends and their means, not just by their slogans.
Trap: Options (b), (c) and (d) are all genuine Marxist tenets, so they feel familiar; the question asks for common ground, which only (a) is.
← Previous · Q13Consider the following statements : 1. The Constitution of India defines its…Next · Q15 →In the context of India, which one of the following is the characteristic…
More Modern History PYQs
Which of the following factors contributed to the formation of the Forward Bloc by Subhas Chandra Bose in 1939? 1. Bose failed to win the confidence of Mahatma Gandhi. 2. The Congress Left was disunited and failed to support…
See the answer & explanation →
Consider the following statements regarding the British policy in Awadh immediately after its annexation in 1856 1. The taluqdars were dispossessed of their estates but allowed to retain their arms and forts. 2. A Summary…
See the answer & explanation →
Consider the following assertion: The genesis of political alliances based on community lay in the very nature of the Montague-Chelmsford Reforms, 1919. Which of the following statements support/supports the above assertion? 1.…
See the answer & explanation →
The artificially fixed rupee-sterling exchange rate prescribed by the Hilton-Young Commission (1926) was adopted by the British Government for which one of the following reasons?
See the answer & explanation →All Modern History questions →
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.