EdiShorts

UPSC Prelims 2020 GS Paper 1 Q14 · Modern History

Year2020
PaperGS Paper 1
QuestionQ14
SubjectModern History

One common agreement between Gandhism and Marxism is

  1. athe final goal of a stateless society
  2. bclass struggle
  3. cabolition of private property
  4. deconomic determinism
Show answer & explanationHide answer
Correct answer(a) the final goal of a stateless society

Both see a stateless society as the ideal, Marx as the end of history after the 'withering away' of the state and Gandhi as 'enlightened anarchy'.

Statement-by-statement analysis

✓ Option (a)
  • Marx: after the proletarian dictatorship, classes disappear and the state 'withers away' into communism.
  • Gandhi: the state is 'violence in a concentrated form'; the ideal is a stateless society of self-governing village republics (Ram Rajya).
✗ Option (b)
  • Class struggle is the motor of history for Marx; Gandhi rejected it and sought harmony between classes through trusteeship and change of heart.
✗ Option (c)
  • Marx called for abolishing private ownership of the means of production; Gandhi let owners keep property as 'trustees' for society.
✗ Option (d)
  • Economic determinism (the economic base shapes all of society) is Marxist; Gandhi gave primacy to moral and spiritual forces.

Concept to know

  • The two agree on the end and differ on the means: Marx accepts violent revolution and a transitional proletarian dictatorship; Gandhi insists on non-violence because the means shape the end.
  • Marxism rests on historical materialism, class struggle, surplus value and economic determinism.
  • Gandhism rests on truth (satya), non-violence (ahimsa), trusteeship, swadeshi, decentralisation and sarvodaya (welfare of all).
  • Both criticised capitalist exploitation and wanted an equal society; Gandhi also opposed large-scale industrialisation and centralisation, which Marxism accepts.
  • Gandhi's model of the state appears in Hind Swaraj (1909): self-reliant villages, minimal government, power flowing upward from the village.

Related facts for revision

  • 'Unto This Last' (John Ruskin) inspired Gandhi's sarvodaya; he translated it into Gujarati as 'Sarvodaya'.
  • Vinoba Bhave's Bhoodan (from 1951, Pochampalli) and Gramdan movements applied Gandhian trusteeship to land.
  • Gandhian ideas in the Constitution are Directive Principles: Article 40 (village panchayats), 43 (cottage industries), 47 (prohibition) and 48 (protecting cows).
  • M.N. Roy moved from Marxism to 'Radical Humanism'; Jayaprakash Narayan moved from socialism to Gandhian 'total revolution'.
  • Ram Manohar Lohia's 'Chaukhamba Raj' (four-pillar state) is another model of decentralisation.
How UPSC tests this

Comparing ideologies by their ends and their means, not just by their slogans.

Trap: Options (b), (c) and (d) are all genuine Marxist tenets, so they feel familiar; the question asks for common ground, which only (a) is.

More Modern History PYQs

All Modern History questions →

Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.