Protection of Ecology and Environment is Essential for Sustained Economic Development.
2200–2500 words, 200 marks; write one essay from the six topics. The essay is graded on interpretation, structure and range of illustration — not on agreeing with the topic. A causal claim: argue that growth cannot be sustained without protecting its natural base, while acknowledging the real trade-offs a poor country faces.
Common trap: Weak essays describe pollution and end with 'plant trees'. The top essay of 2006 makes an economic argument — natural capital, the cost of degradation, the poor's dependence on ecosystems — uses Indian evidence (Bhopal, Mumbai floods, Sariska, Delhi CNG) and global frameworks (Brundtland, Rio, Kyoto, the Stern Review), and engages with the 'grow first, clean later' objection.
Essay brief
2200–2500 words · 125 marks- Economic reading: forests, water, soil and clean air are natural capital; running them down inflates today's GDP at the cost of tomorrow's (strongest reading).
- Equity reading: the rural poor depend directly on commons — degradation hits them first and pushes them deeper into poverty ('environmentalism of the poor').
- Global reading: climate change and biodiversity loss threaten every economy; protection is collective insurance.
- Sceptical reading: a developing country cannot afford rich-country standards; protection must be calibrated so that it does not freeze growth.
Concepts
- Brundtland Report (1987): development that meets present needs without compromising future generations
- Natural capital and 'green GDP' — conventional GDP ignores depletion
- Environmental Kuznets curve: pollution first rises then falls with income — but some damage is irreversible
Why the economy depends on ecology
- Agriculture needs groundwater, soil fertility and a stable monsoon; Punjab's falling water tables
- Fisheries, tourism and forest produce are livelihoods for millions
- Mangroves and wetlands cushion disasters — the 2004 tsunami and the 2005 Mumbai floods (Mithi river encroached)
- Health costs of air and water pollution reduce productivity
Costs of neglect: Indian lessons
- Bhopal gas tragedy (1984): human and economic cost of lax industrial safety
- Sariska tiger reserve found without tigers (2005)
- Ganga Action Plan (1985) and Yamuna clean-up: large spending, limited results
- Mining and deforestation conflicts in tribal belts
Policy framework in 2006
- Environment (Protection) Act, 1986; Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980
- National Environment Policy, 2006 and the new EIA notification, 2006
- Supreme Court's role: M. C. Mehta cases, CNG for Delhi public transport (2002), Godavarman forest case
- Forest Rights Act passed by Parliament in December 2006: recognising forest dwellers as partners in conservation
Global dimension
- Stockholm (1972), Rio Earth Summit (1992) and Agenda 21
- Kyoto Protocol in force from 2005: common but differentiated responsibilities
- Stern Review (2006): unchecked climate change could cost 5–20% of global GDP, far more than action now
Counter-view and reconciliation
- Poverty is itself a polluter (Indira Gandhi at Stockholm, 1972); growth funds clean-up
- Over-regulation can delay infrastructure and jobs
- Way forward: pricing pollution, clean technology, community management (Joint Forest Management), green accounting
Opening. Open with a contrast: a decade of 6–8% growth, yet the Yamuna is dead in Delhi, Punjab's water table is falling and Sariska has lost its tigers — growth that consumes its own foundations cannot be sustained.
Body. Define sustainable development; show the economic dependence on ecosystems; give Indian costs of neglect; set out the 2006 policy framework and the global context.
Counter-view. Present the 'grow first, clean up later' and 'poverty is the worst polluter' arguments fairly, then show where they fail (irreversibility, health costs, the poor's dependence on commons).
Conclusion. Conclude that ecology is not a brake on development but its balance sheet; the choice is not growth or environment but growth now or growth that lasts. (Later: National Action Plan on Climate Change, 2008; National Green Tribunal, 2010; Paris Agreement, 2015.)
- Brundtland Commission report 'Our Common Future' (1987) — Definition of sustainable development
- Stern Review on the Economics of Climate Change (October 2006) — Economic cost of inaction
- Bhopal gas tragedy (1984) — Industrial neglect
- Delhi's switch to CNG under Supreme Court orders (2002) — Regulation improving air quality without stopping growth
- Mumbai floods (July 2005) — Destroyed wetlands and drains turning rain into disaster
- Chipko movement (1973) and Joint Forest Management (1990) — Community-based conservation
- Sariska tiger reserve (2005) — Ecological loss from poaching and weak governance
- “Earth provides enough to satisfy every man's needs, but not every man's greed.” — Mahatma Gandhi (as quoted by E. F. Schumacher)
- “Are not poverty and need the greatest polluters?” — Indira Gandhi, Stockholm Conference, 1972
- Writing only about pollution and not about the economy
- Ignoring the trade-off argument of a developing country
- Listing laws without showing their effect
- Romanticising a no-growth position
More from Essay 2006
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.