EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2006EssayTopic 6 · 200 marksModel answer

Increasing Computerization Would Lead to the Creation of a Dehumanized Society.

DirectiveEssay
Marks200
Word limit2200–2500
PaperEssay
What the examiner wants

2200–2500 words, 200 marks; write one essay from the six topics. The essay is graded on interpretation, structure and range of illustration — not on agreeing with the topic. A predictive claim about technology and human values: examine how computers can isolate and mechanise human life, and how they can also humanise it — then decide what makes the difference.

Common trap: Weak essays list advantages and disadvantages of computers. The top essay of 2006 defines 'dehumanised' (loss of empathy, face-to-face community, judgement and dignity of work), takes the fear seriously (Chaplin's Modern Times, Weizenbaum's warning), shows the humanising uses in India (Bhoomi, e-Seva, telemedicine, railway reservations), and argues that the outcome depends on human choices, not on the machine.

Essay brief

2200–2500 words · 125 marks
Ways to read the topic
  • Pessimistic reading: screens replace relationships, work becomes machine-paced, decisions are left to programs — society loses warmth and judgement.
  • Humanising reading: computers remove drudgery and corruption, connect families across distances and extend health, education and services to the excluded.
  • Agency reading: technology is neutral-to-ambivalent; whether society is dehumanised depends on values, institutions and design (strongest reading).
  • Equity reading: the bigger danger is a divided society — the digitally included and the excluded — rather than a dehumanised one.
Dimensions to cover

What 'dehumanised' means

  • Loss of empathy and face-to-face community
  • Human beings treated as data or as parts of a machine
  • Erosion of judgement, craft and the dignity of work

The case for the fear

  • Long hours before screens; online chat and gaming replacing family time
  • Night-shift computer work and stress in call centres and IT firms
  • Joseph Weizenbaum (ELIZA, 1966) warned against handing human judgement to machines
  • Cyber crime, privacy loss and impersonal automated systems (IT Act, 2000 is a first response)

How computers humanise

  • Karnataka's Bhoomi land records and Andhra Pradesh's e-Seva cut queues and bribes
  • Computerised railway reservation (from 1986) made a daily ordeal simple
  • ISRO's telemedicine network linking rural patients to city specialists
  • E-mail and internet telephony reconnecting migrant families

The Indian context in 2006

  • IT and outsourcing as a source of jobs and national confidence
  • National e-Governance Plan approved in 2006
  • Digital divide: most Indians, especially rural and poor, are not yet online

History's lesson

  • Every technology — printing press, factory, television — raised fears of dehumanisation
  • Chaplin's Modern Times (1936): the danger lay in how work was organised, not in the machine alone
  • Gandhi's critique of machinery was of machines that displace and enslave, not of tools that serve

Keeping society human

  • Value education and digital etiquette for children
  • Human oversight of automated decisions
  • Work–life balance laws and practices
  • Technology designed for inclusion and local languages
Structure

Opening. Open with a contrast: a farmer in Karnataka gets his land record from a Bhoomi kiosk in minutes without a bribe, while a teenager in the same state spends evenings alone with a screen — is computerisation freeing us or emptying us?

Body. Define dehumanisation; give the fear its strongest case; then the humanising uses with Indian examples; then the historical lesson about technology and fear.

Counter-view. Acknowledge that some effects — isolation, surveillance, job loss — are real and growing, and explain why 'neutral technology' is too easy an answer.

Conclusion. Conclude that computers will dehumanise a society only if that society stops asking human questions of them; the machine amplifies the values we bring. (Later: smartphones and social media from around 2010 made these debates sharper — Sherry Turkle's 'Alone Together' (2011) — and artificial intelligence has renewed them.)

Examples to use
  • Bhoomi land records project, Karnataka (around 2001) — Computerisation reducing corruption and delay
  • e-Seva centres, Andhra Pradesh — One-stop citizen services
  • ISRO telemedicine network — Technology extending health care to remote areas
  • Joseph Weizenbaum, 'Computer Power and Human Reason' (1976) — Classic warning against delegating judgement to machines
  • Charlie Chaplin's 'Modern Times' (1936) — Image of the mechanised, dehumanised worker
  • Information Technology Act, 2000 — Law responding to cyber crime and electronic transactions
Quotes
  • “The real problem is not whether machines think but whether men do.” — B. F. Skinner
  • “What I object to is the craze for machinery, not machinery as such.” — Mahatma Gandhi
Pitfalls
  • Writing a list of advantages and disadvantages of computers
  • Never defining 'dehumanised'
  • Technological determinism in either direction
  • Projecting later technologies (smartphones, AI) as facts of 2006

More from Essay 2006

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.