EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2006EssayTopic 5 · 200 marksModel answer

Globalization Would Finish Small-Scale Industries in India.

DirectiveEssay
Marks200
Word limit2200–2500
PaperEssay
What the examiner wants

2200–2500 words, 200 marks; write one essay from the six topics. The essay is graded on interpretation, structure and range of illustration — not on agreeing with the topic. A strong predictive claim ('would finish'): test it against evidence and show which small units are dying, which are thriving, and what decides the difference.

Common trap: Weak essays lament Chinese imports and conclude that small industry is doomed. The top essay of 2006 shows that globalisation is a filter, not a death sentence: protected, low-technology units under the reservation regime suffer, while clusters that upgraded (Tiruppur, Ludhiana, auto components) have found global markets; it ends with the policy needed — credit, technology, clusters, the MSMED Act, 2006.

Essay brief

2200–2500 words · 125 marks
Ways to read the topic
  • Pessimistic reading: removal of quantitative restrictions (2001), dereservation and cheap imports (especially Chinese) destroy units that survived only on protection.
  • Opportunity reading: global markets, outsourcing and value chains give efficient small firms export and subcontracting openings (strongest reading when balanced with the first).
  • Structural reading: the real constraints are domestic — credit, power, infrastructure, Inspector Raj, technology — globalisation only exposes them.
  • Social reading: small industry is the second-largest employer after agriculture; its fate decides whether growth creates jobs.
Dimensions to cover

Small industry's place

  • Commonly estimated at about 40% of manufacturing output and about a third of exports
  • Labour-intensive and spread across towns — a route out of farm dependence
  • Nehru–Mahalanobis era protection: reservation of products for SSI from 1967, Gandhian emphasis on village industry

How globalisation hurts

  • Quantitative restrictions on imports removed by April 2001 after WTO commitments
  • Cheap imports of toys, locks, electronics and firecrackers squeezing clusters
  • Dereservation exposing units to large-firm competition
  • Quality and standards demands (ISO, labelling) that small firms find costly

How globalisation helps

  • Tiruppur knitwear and Ludhiana hosiery and cycle parts exporting worldwide
  • Auto-component SMEs supplying global car makers
  • Outsourcing and subcontracting linkages with multinationals
  • Access to imported machinery and inputs at lower duty

Domestic constraints

  • Credit gap despite priority-sector lending (Nayak Committee, 1992)
  • Power shortages, poor roads and logistics
  • Rigid labour laws and inspectors; delayed payments by large buyers
  • Weak technology upgradation and marketing

Policy response by 2006

  • Abid Hussain Committee (1997) urged dereservation and modernisation
  • Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises Development Act, 2006: new definitions and a medium category
  • Credit Guarantee Fund Trust (2000), cluster development programmes, SIDBI
  • Need for common facility centres, testing labs and export promotion

Verdict

  • Globalisation will finish inefficient, protected units, not small industry as such
  • Survival depends on scale through clusters, technology and finance
  • State's role shifts from protection to enabling
Structure

Opening. Open with two scenes in 2006: a Sivakasi or Moradabad unit losing orders to cheaper imports, and a Tiruppur knitwear unit shipping to European retailers — the same globalisation, opposite fates.

Body. Establish small industry's importance; then the channels of harm; then the channels of opportunity; then the domestic constraints that decide which side a unit falls on; then policy.

Counter-view. Concede the real casualties and the social cost to workers, and answer the protectionist case: protection kept units small and uncompetitive rather than safe.

Conclusion. Conclude that globalisation is a test, not a verdict — the small that modernise will grow; the state must help them modernise rather than shield them. (Later: the reservation list was fully abolished in 2015; MSME definitions were revised to investment-plus-turnover in 2020.)

Examples to use
  • Removal of quantitative restrictions on imports (by April 2001) — Opening of the market to imports
  • Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises Development Act, 2006 — New legal framework for small firms
  • Tiruppur knitwear cluster (Tamil Nadu) — Small firms thriving in global markets
  • Ludhiana bicycle parts and hosiery cluster — Cluster-based competitiveness
  • Abid Hussain Committee on Small Enterprises (1997) — Case for dereservation and modernisation
  • Chinese imports of toys and firecrackers — Competitive pressure on low-technology units
  • Italy's industrial districts — Small firms competing globally through clusters
Quotes
  • “Small is beautiful.” — E. F. Schumacher
  • “The poor of the world cannot be helped by mass production, only by production by the masses.” — Mahatma Gandhi (as quoted by E. F. Schumacher)
Pitfalls
  • Agreeing that all small industry is doomed
  • Blaming globalisation for purely domestic constraints
  • Ignoring employment and social consequences
  • No Indian cluster examples

More from Essay 2006

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.