Discuss the role of public sector during the post-reform period of Indian economy.
Show how the public sector's role changed after 1991 — what it lost, what it kept, how it was reformed — and judge its continuing relevance.
Common trap: Avoid 'PSUs are inefficient so privatise'. Show the shift from commanding heights to strategic and competitive roles, with the policy milestones of 1991–2005 and a balanced verdict.
SyllabusOld-pattern GS Paper II (2006–12): Indian Economy — economic reforms and the role of the public and private sectors
Model answer
15 marks · 150-word limitThe Industrial Policy of July 1991 ended the public sector's monopoly of the 'commanding heights', reducing the sectors reserved for it from 17 to 8, later fewer. Yet the public sector has remained central to infrastructure, energy, finance and welfare, in a more competitive and autonomous form.
- 1991Reserved sectors cut, PSUs to BIFR
- 1993Rangarajan Committee on disinvestment
- 1997Navratna status for top PSUs
- 1999–2004Strategic sales: BALCO, VSNL
- 2004NCMP: no sale of profitable PSUs
- 2005National Investment Fund created
Reorientation
- Shrinking reservation: Private firms entered steel, telecom, power, aviation and banking; by 2001 only atomic energy and railways remained largely reserved.
- Disinvestment: Minority stake sales followed by strategic sales (Modern Foods 2000, BALCO 2001, VSNL 2002) raised revenue and improved efficiency.
- Autonomy: Memoranda of Understanding and Navratna (1997) and Miniratna status gave strong PSUs financial freedom to compete.
Continuing roles
- Infrastructure and energy: NTPC, ONGC, IOC and ONGC Videsh's overseas fields underpin energy security; public banks fund long-gestation projects.
- Competition and welfare: BSNL's entry pushed telecom tariffs down; public sector banks drive priority-sector lending and rural branches.
- Inclusive growth: The NCMP (2004) kept profitable PSUs public and put disinvestment receipts in the National Investment Fund for social sectors.
After reforms the public sector moved from controller to competitor and enabler. Its relevance now depends on governance reform, professional boards and performance, not on monopoly.
Read more — sources
- OfficialStatement on Industrial Policy, 24 July 1991, Government of India
- OfficialDepartment of Public Enterprises, Public Enterprises Survey 2005-06
- BookRamesh Singh, Indian Economy — chapter on public sector and disinvestment
More from GS Paper II (old) 2006
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.