As high as 45% of the under-5 children, brought to the outdoor clinics of 4 major State-run hospitals in Kolkata last year, were found to be victims of malnutrition. Incidence of malnutrition among the under-5 children in the city must, therefore, be alarmingly high. Explain why you support the argument, or disagree with it.
DirectiveExplain
Marks2
Word limit30
PaperGS Paper II (old)
What the examiner wants
Decide whether hospital-clinic data can be generalised to all children in the city, and why.
Common trap: The trap is selection bias: children brought to clinics are not a random sample. Disagree, and say what data would be needed.
SyllabusOld-pattern GS Paper II (2006–12): Statistical analysis, graphs and diagrams
Model answer
2 marks · 30-word limitI disagree: the 45% figure comes from a biased sample and cannot be generalised to all under-5 children in Kolkata.
Reasons
- Selection bias: Children taken to hospital clinics are usually ill, and malnourished children fall ill more often, so they are over-represented.
- Not representative: State-run hospitals serve mainly poorer families; children of better-off families who use private doctors are excluded.
- What is needed: A random sample survey of all under-5 children, like the National Family Health Survey, is required to estimate city-wide incidence.
Answer length. This model answer runs to about 82 words so that every relevant angle is covered. In the exam, write to the 30-word limit: keep the opening, the strongest one or two points under each heading and the conclusion.
Read more — sources
- NCERTNCERT Class XI Statistics for Economics — Ch. 3–5 (organisation, presentation of data, measures of central tendency)
- OfficialNational Family Health Survey-3 (2005-06) — sampling design
← Previous · Q15(a)A union leader complained: “That the owners of this factory have adopted a…Next · Q15(c) →In a community support project, the average grants (in Rs) received by the…
More from GS Paper II (old) 2006
Write a short note on: US policy on Iran’s nuclear programme
US policy on Iran's nuclear programme in 2006 aimed to stop Tehran from acquiring the capability to enrich uranium, which Washington saw as a path to a weapon. It…
Read the model answer →
Terrorism : Sources in Pakistan and Afghanistan
The Pakistan-Afghanistan belt became the world's leading incubator of jihadi terrorism after the anti-Soviet war of 1979–89. In 2006 its sources lay in historical…
Read the model answer →
Write a short note on: Crippling the King in Nepal
King Gyanendra's seizure of absolute power on 1 February 2005 united Nepal's mainstream parties and the Maoists against him. The people's movement of April 2006 (Jana…
Read the model answer →
Write a short note on: Simla Agreement
The Simla Agreement was signed on 2 July 1972 by Indira Gandhi and Zulfikar Ali Bhutto after the 1971 war.
Read the model answer →
India-Israel cooperation in the field of agriculture
Israel, a world leader in dryland farming, has been a key partner for Indian agriculture since diplomatic ties began in 1992.
Read the model answer →
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.