EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2006GS Paper II (old)Q10(a) · 30 marksSci & TechModel answer

Justify with necessary logic “Biological clean-up methods can be cheaper than the conventional physical and chemical pollution treatments”.

DirectiveJustify
Marks30
Word limit250
PaperGS Paper II (old)
What the examiner wants

Give the reasons — with mechanisms and examples — why biological clean-up usually costs less than physical and chemical treatment, and note where the claim does not hold.

Common trap: A weak answer just defines bioremediation. A strong one justifies the cost claim point by point (energy, chemicals, excavation, by-products), uses Indian examples like TERI's Oilzapper and the East Kolkata Wetlands, and honestly states limits.

SyllabusOld-pattern GS Paper II (2006–12): Developments in Science and Technology — biotechnology and environment

Model answer

30 marks · 250-word limit

Biological clean-up, or bioremediation, uses micro-organisms, plants and natural ecosystems to break down or immobilise pollutants. Conventional treatment relies on excavation, incineration, chemical precipitation, oxidation or membranes, which need energy, reagents and infrastructure. For many wastes, living systems do the same work more cheaply.

Biological clean-up
  • Works in situ, little digging
  • Driven by sunlight and microbes
  • Few chemicals, low energy
  • Yields compost, biogas, biomass
vs
Physical-chemical treatment
  • Excavation and transport
  • High energy (incineration, pumping)
  • Costly reagents
  • Secondary sludge and emissions
Biological versus conventional pollution treatment

Methods of biological clean-up

  • Microbial degradation: Bacteria and fungi digest hydrocarbons, pesticides and organic waste into carbon dioxide and water; adding nutrients (biostimulation) or selected strains (bioaugmentation) speeds it up.
  • Phytoremediation: Plants such as Indian mustard, sunflower and vetiver absorb or stabilise heavy metals and organics in soil and water.
  • Natural systems: Constructed wetlands, oxidation ponds and biofilters treat sewage and industrial effluent with little machinery.
  • Composting and anaerobic digestion: Organic solid waste becomes manure or biogas instead of landfill.

Why it is cheaper — the logic

  • In situ treatment: Pollutants are treated where they lie, avoiding the cost of digging, transporting and landfilling contaminated soil.
  • Low energy and reagents: Microbes and plants run on sunlight and ambient temperatures, while incineration, chemical oxidation or reverse osmosis consume fuel, electricity and chemicals.
  • Complete destruction: Organic pollutants are mineralised rather than merely shifted to another medium, reducing secondary sludge disposal costs.
  • Value from waste: The East Kolkata Wetlands treat a large part of Kolkata's sewage naturally while supporting fisheries and vegetable farming — a Ramsar site since 2002.
  • Indian evidence: TERI's Oilzapper bacterial consortium, developed with IOC, has cleaned oily sludge and spill sites at refineries at modest cost; microbes also helped after the 1989 Exxon Valdez spill.

Limits of the claim

  • Slow: Biological methods may take months or years; emergencies may need physical containment.
  • Not universal: Very high concentrations, radioactive waste and some heavy metals are toxic to organisms or cannot be degraded, only transferred to plant biomass.
  • Site-specific: Temperature, moisture and soil chemistry affect results; monitoring and expertise are needed, and genetically engineered microbes raise biosafety concerns.

For most organic pollution, oil spills, sewage and diffuse contamination, biological methods are indeed cheaper, greener and more sustainable than conventional treatment. The best strategy is often hybrid: physical containment first, then low-cost biological polishing, supported by research such as the Department of Biotechnology's programmes on bioremediation.

Answer length. This model answer runs to about 343 words so that every relevant angle is covered. In the exam, write to the 250-word limit: keep the opening, the strongest one or two points under each heading, the diagram and the conclusion.

Read more — sources

  • NCERTNCERT Class XII Biology — Ch. 10, Microbes in Human Welfare (sewage treatment, biogas)
  • ReportThe Energy and Resources Institute (TERI), Oilzapper bioremediation technology
  • OfficialRamsar Convention, East Calcutta Wetlands site information (designated 2002)

More from GS Paper II (old) 2006

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.