EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2008GS Paper II (old)Q4(a) · 30 marksEconomyModel answer

Discuss India’s stand on agricultural issues in WTO’s Ministerial Conferences since Doha Round.

DirectiveDiscuss
Marks30
Word limit250
PaperGS Paper II (old)
What the examiner wants

Trace, ministerial by ministerial since Doha (2001), what India demanded on agriculture and why, and weigh how far its stand succeeded.

Common trap: Weak answers say 'India protects farmers'. A top answer goes conference by conference (Doha, Cancun, the July 2004 framework, Hong Kong, the July 2008 Geneva talks), names the coalitions (G-20, G-33) and the instruments (Special Products, SSM, AMS, export subsidies), and explains the livelihood logic behind India's defensive and offensive interests.

SyllabusOld-pattern GS Paper II (2006–12): India and the World — international economic institutions (WTO) and Indian agriculture

Model answer

30 marks · 250-word limit

Agriculture is the heart of the Doha Development Agenda launched at the fourth WTO Ministerial Conference in November 2001. With most of its workforce dependent on small, subsistence farms, India has consistently argued that the Round must remove the distortions created by rich-country subsidies while protecting the food and livelihood security of poor farmers in developing countries.

  1. Doha, Nov 2001Development agenda; India resists Singapore issues
  2. Cancun, Sept 2003G-20 formed against US–EU joint text; talks collapse
  3. Geneva, July 2004Framework: SPs and SSM accepted in principle
  4. Hong Kong, Dec 2005Export subsidies to end by 2013
  5. Geneva, July 2008Mini-ministerial fails over SSM trigger
India's agricultural stand at WTO ministerials since Doha

Doha and Cancun: setting the terms

  • Doha (2001): India, led by Commerce Minister Murasoli Maran, accepted the Round only with a development focus, insisting on 'special and differential treatment' and resisting the Singapore issues (investment, competition, government procurement, trade facilitation).
  • Cancun (2003): When the US and EU tabled a joint agricultural text that went soft on their own subsidies, India joined Brazil, China and South Africa in the G-20 of developing countries; the conference collapsed, but the South emerged as a real negotiating bloc.
  • July 2004 framework: The General Council framework accepted the idea of Special Products and a Special Safeguard Mechanism for developing countries, and dropped three Singapore issues.

Hong Kong (2005) and Geneva (2008)

  • Export subsidies: At Hong Kong in December 2005 members agreed to eliminate agricultural export subsidies by 2013, a long-standing Indian demand.
  • G-33 positions: India, with Indonesia, led the G-33, which demanded self-designated Special Products, exempt from deep tariff cuts, chosen on food security, livelihood security and rural development criteria.
  • July 2008 collapse: At the Geneva mini-ministerial, Commerce Minister Kamal Nath refused a high trigger for the Special Safeguard Mechanism proposed by the USA; the talks broke down over this protection against import surges.

The substance of India's stand

IssueIndia's positionReason
Domestic supportDeep cuts in developed countries' trade-distorting support (amber and blue box)Rich-country subsidies depress world prices
Market accessLower cuts for developing countries; Special ProductsProtect small farmers from import surges
SSMSimple, usable trigger for extra dutiesPrice and volume shocks hurt poor farmers
Public stockholdingFlexibility for food security programmesPDS and minimum support prices
Cotton and tropical productsSupport African cotton producersSolidarity of the South

Assessment

  • Gains: India helped turn the WTO from a US–EU club into a forum where developing countries must be accommodated, and won the export-subsidy deadline.
  • Critique: Critics argue India's defensive stance also blocked market access gains for Indian exporters and that the Round's stalling benefits no one.

India's consistent message has been that there can be no development round without fair agricultural rules for the poor. A balanced deal would combine real cuts in rich-country subsidies with workable safeguards for developing-country farmers. (Later: the 2013 Bali Ministerial granted a 'peace clause' for public stockholding.)

Answer length. This model answer runs to about 408 words so that every relevant angle is covered. In the exam, write to the 250-word limit: keep the opening, the strongest one or two points under each heading, the diagram and the conclusion.

Read more — sources

  • OfficialWTO, Doha Ministerial Declaration (WT/MIN(01)/DEC/1, 2001) and Hong Kong Ministerial Declaration (2005)
  • OfficialMinistry of Commerce and Industry, Annual Report 2007–08 — WTO negotiations
  • OfficialEconomic Survey 2007–08, Government of India — chapter on international trade

More from GS Paper II (old) 2008

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.