Assess the performance of India in attracting Foreign Direct Investment (FDI).
Judge India's FDI record up to 2008 against its policy reforms, peers and needs: show the achievements with trend and composition, then the weaknesses and their causes, and give a verdict.
Common trap: Weak answers list FDI caps. A top answer gives the trend (sharp rise after 2005–06), sources (Mauritius route), sectors, the comparison with China, and the structural constraints, ending with a balanced verdict.
SyllabusOld-pattern GS Paper II (2006–12): Indian Economy — foreign investment and the external sector
Model answer
30 marks · 250-word limitSince the New Industrial Policy of 1991 opened the economy, India has moved from being a marginal destination to one of the most attractive locations for Foreign Direct Investment. Inflows rose sharply in the mid-2000s, but India still attracts far less FDI than China, and the investment climate has well-known weaknesses.
- Inflows over US$ 30 bn in 2007–08
- Automatic route for most sectors
- Services, IT, telecom, construction lead
- Ranked among top FDI destinations
- Far below China's inflows
- Heavy reliance on Mauritius route
- Infrastructure and land hurdles
- Sectoral caps and policy delays
Policy framework
- Liberalisation: From 1991, automatic approval for FDI in most sectors, with the Foreign Investment Promotion Board (FIPB) handling cases outside it; FERA was replaced by the more liberal FEMA in 1999.
- Recent opening: Townships and construction development opened in 2005, single-brand retail up to 51% in 2006, and the SEZ Act, 2005 offered fiscal incentives.
Achievements
- Volume: According to RBI data, FDI inflows rose from under US$ 10 billion in 2005–06 to more than US$ 30 billion in 2007–08, a several-fold increase in two years.
- Composition: Services (financial and business), computer software and hardware, telecommunications, housing and real estate, and construction attracted the bulk of inflows.
- Sources: Mauritius was the largest source, followed by Singapore, the USA and the UK; the India–Mauritius tax treaty made it the preferred route.
- Perception: India ranked consistently second, behind China, in A.T. Kearney's FDI Confidence Index in the mid-2000s, reflecting its market size and skilled manpower.
Weaknesses
- Relative gap: China has attracted several times India's FDI, mostly into export-oriented manufacturing, whereas India's inflows are concentrated in services and a few cities.
- Constraints: Poor infrastructure, slow approvals, rigid labour laws, weak contract enforcement and land acquisition disputes (such as Singur in 2008) deter large manufacturing projects.
- Quality concerns: Round-tripping of Indian money through Mauritius, caps in insurance (26%) and the ban on multi-brand retail limit the depth of FDI.
India's FDI performance since 1991, and especially after 2005, is a real success, but it remains below potential. Second-generation reforms in infrastructure, land, labour and the ease of doing business, plus FDI in manufacturing, would let FDI support employment and growth on a larger scale.
Read more — sources
- OfficialEconomic Survey 2007–08, Government of India — chapter on external sector
- OfficialReserve Bank of India, Annual Report 2007–08 — capital flows
- ReportUNCTAD, World Investment Report 2008
- BookUma Kapila (ed.), Indian Economy Since Independence
More from GS Paper II (old) 2008
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.