EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2008GS Paper II (old)Q13(b) · 6 marksModel answer

Prior to constructing a dam on a river the engineers performed a series of tests to measure the water flow at the proposed location of the dam. The results of the testing were used to construct the following frequency distribution. Water flow (thousands of gallons per minute) | Frequency 1001 - 1050 | 7 1051 - 1100 | 21 1101 - 1150 | 32 1151 - 1200 | 49 1201 - 1250 | 58 1251 - 1300 | 41 1301 - 1350 | 27 1351 - 1400 | 11 Construct an appropriate diagram to estimate what proportion of the flow occurs at less than 1300 thousands of gallons per minute. Give the estimate.

DirectiveConstruct and estimate
Marks6
Word limit60
PaperGS Paper II (old)
What the examiner wants

Draw a 'less than' ogive from cumulative frequencies against upper class boundaries and read off the proportion of flows below 1,300 thousand gallons per minute.

Common trap: The right diagram for 'what proportion is less than x' is a less-than ogive. Convert class limits to boundaries (1000.5, 1050.5, ...), plot cumulative frequencies, and read the value at 1,300; then convert to a proportion of the total 246.

SyllabusOld-pattern GS Paper II (2006–12): Statistical analysis, graphs and diagrams

Model answer

6 marks · 60-word limit

A 'less than' cumulative frequency curve (ogive) answers 'what proportion lies below a value'. The classes are inclusive integers, so we use class boundaries (1000.5, 1050.5, ...); the total number of tests is 246.

  1. Convert class limits to boundaries
  2. Cumulate frequencies (total 246)
  3. Plot cf against upper boundaries
  4. Join points by a smooth curve
  5. Read cf at 1,300 and divide by 246
Reading the proportion from a less-than ogive

Working

Upper boundary ('000 gal/min)FrequencyLess-than cumulative frequencyCumulative %
1000.5000.0
1050.5772.8
1100.5212811.4
1150.5326024.4
1200.54910944.3
1250.55816767.9
1300.54120884.6
1350.52723595.5
1400.511246100.0

Method and result

  • Drawing: Take water flow on the x-axis (1 cm = 50 thousand gallons per minute, starting at 1000.5) and cumulative frequency or percentage on the y-axis (1 cm = 20 tests); plot the points and join them by a smooth rising curve.
  • Reading: Draw a vertical line from 1,300 on the x-axis to the ogive and read the y-value: about 208 of the 246 tests.
  • Result: Proportion of flows below 1,300 thousand gallons per minute = 208 ÷ 246 ≈ 0.845, i.e. about 84.5% (interpolating to exactly 1,300 gives about 84.4%).

About 84–85% of measured flows were below 1,300 thousand gallons per minute.

Answer length. This model answer runs to about 173 words so that every relevant angle is covered. In the exam, write to the 60-word limit: keep the opening, the strongest one or two points under each heading, the diagram and the conclusion.

Read more — sources

  • NCERTStatistics for Economics (Class XI) — Ch. 3, Organisation of Data; Ch. 4, Presentation of Data (ogives)
  • BookS. C. Gupta, Fundamentals of Statistics — cumulative frequency curves

More from GS Paper II (old) 2008

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.