EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2009EssayTopic 2 · 200 marksModel answer

Are we a 'soft' state?

DirectiveEssay
Marks200
Word limit1800–2000
PaperEssay
What the examiner wants

1800–2000 words, 200 marks. In the old pattern (2009) the candidate wrote ONE essay chosen from five topics. Graded on understanding of the topic, orderly arrangement of ideas and concise expression. A question topic built on Gunnar Myrdal's concept: define 'soft state', test India against it with evidence, and give a reasoned answer.

Common trap: Many candidates read 'soft' only as weak against terror. The top essay starts from Gunnar Myrdal's 'Asian Drama' (1968): a soft state is one that lacks social discipline — laws are made but not enforced, and corruption and evasion go unpunished. It then applies both meanings — internal (rule of law, corruption, delay in justice) and security (Kandahar 1999, Parliament attack 2001, 26/11 Mumbai 2008) — notes the counter-evidence of a resilient democracy, and ends with reforms that make the state firm, not harsh.

Essay brief

1800–2000 words · 125 marks
Ways to read the topic
  • Myrdal's reading: a soft state lacks social discipline — laws are not enforced and powerful people evade obligations.
  • Security reading: India responds weakly to terrorism, infiltration and insurgency, inviting more attacks.
  • Counter-reading: India's restraint is strategic maturity and democratic strength, not softness — a 'soft power' is different from a 'soft state'.
  • Balanced reading: India is soft in enforcement and implementation, but resilient as a democracy; the cure is capacity and rule of law, not authoritarian harshness (strongest reading).
Dimensions to cover

The concept

  • Gunnar Myrdal, 'Asian Drama' (1968): soft state = lack of social discipline and enforcement
  • Soft state versus soft power (Joseph Nye) — not the same
  • Firm state is not the same as an authoritarian state

Evidence of softness: rule of law

  • Laws on paper, poor enforcement — encroachments, tax evasion, adulteration
  • Corruption and impunity; slow trials — millions of cases pending in courts
  • Police reform directions in Prakash Singh (2006) largely not implemented by states
  • Vote-bank politics shielding offenders

Evidence of softness: security

  • Kandahar hijack (IC-814, 1999): release of terrorists including Masood Azhar
  • Parliament attack (2001); serial blasts of 2008
  • 26/11 Mumbai attacks (Nov 2008): intelligence and coordination failures
  • Porous borders, illegal infiltration, Naxal violence in central India

Counter-evidence: a firm state

  • Defeat of Punjab militancy by the early 1990s; Pokhran-II (1998); Kargil (1999)
  • Free and fair elections on a vast scale; peaceful transfers of power
  • Post-26/11 response: NIA (2008), amended UAPA, NSG hubs, coastal security

Making the state firm

  • Police and judicial reforms; faster trials
  • Second ARC recommendations on public order and ethics (2007–09)
  • Intelligence coordination; modernised forces
  • Consistent enforcement — the same law for the powerful and the weak
Structure

Opening. Open with Myrdal's phrase and the scene of 26/11 — and ask whether the problem is that India is not strong enough, or that its laws are not obeyed.

Body. Define the concept, then examine the evidence of softness in rule of law and in security, then the counter-evidence of resilience and the post-2008 response.

Counter-view. Argue the other side: restraint is not weakness; democracies accept constraints on force, and India's strategic patience has its benefits.

Conclusion. Close with the verdict: India is soft where it should be firm — enforcement and justice — and the answer is a capable, rule-bound state, not a harsh one.

Examples to use
  • Gunnar Myrdal, 'Asian Drama' (1968) — Origin of the 'soft state' concept
  • IC-814 Kandahar hijack (1999) — Capitulation to terrorists' demands
  • 26/11 Mumbai attacks (2008) — Exposed weaknesses of intelligence and response
  • NIA Act and UAPA amendment (December 2008) — Steps towards a firmer counter-terror state
  • Prakash Singh v Union of India (2006) — Police reform ordered but not implemented
  • End of Punjab militancy (early 1990s) — Evidence that the state can be firm
  • Second Administrative Reforms Commission (2005–09) — Blueprint for public order and ethics reform
Quotes
  • “The soft state is one in which policies decided on are often not enforced, if they are enacted at all.” — Gunnar Myrdal (paraphrase, Asian Drama)
  • “Speak softly and carry a big stick.” — Theodore Roosevelt
Pitfalls
  • Reducing the essay to terrorism only
  • Advocating authoritarian solutions or suspension of rights
  • Not mentioning Myrdal's concept
  • Confusing a soft state with soft power

More from Essay 2009

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.