"Good fences make good neighbours."
1800–2000 words, 200 marks. In the old pattern (2009) the candidate wrote ONE essay chosen from five topics. Graded on understanding of the topic, orderly arrangement of ideas and concise expression. A proverb from Robert Frost's 'Mending Wall' (1914): explain it, apply it to people and nations, and weigh Frost's own scepticism of it.
Common trap: The trap is writing only about India–Pakistan border fencing. The top essay notes the source — Frost's 'Mending Wall', where the narrator questions his neighbour's proverb ('Something there is that doesn't love a wall') — and argues both ways: clear boundaries and respect for each other's space prevent conflict (personal life, property, settled borders, sovereignty), but walls can also harden distrust (Berlin Wall). For India it covers settled versus unsettled borders with neighbours and concludes that good fences need open gates.
Essay brief
1800–2000 words · 125 marks- Literal reading: clearly marked boundaries prevent disputes over land, between households or nations.
- Relational reading: respect for each other's privacy and limits keeps relationships healthy.
- Critical reading (Frost's own): walls can divide and breed distrust; what matters is the relationship, not the fence.
- Balanced reading: settled and respected boundaries are the basis for good neighbourliness, but they must allow trade, travel and cooperation — fences with gates (strongest reading).
Source and meaning
- Robert Frost, 'Mending Wall' (1914): the neighbour repeats the proverb; the narrator doubts it
- Boundaries as clarity, respect, and limits
- Panchsheel (1954): mutual respect for territorial integrity and sovereignty
Fences in personal and social life
- Privacy and personal space in families and communities
- Property rights and clear land records reduce disputes and litigation
- Professional boundaries — separation of powers in a constitution
Fences between nations: where they help
- India–Bangladesh Ganga Water Treaty (1996) and settled maritime claims ease tension
- Settled boundary with Nepal and Bhutan; Indus Waters Treaty (1960) survived wars
- Border fencing in Punjab reduced infiltration and smuggling
- Europe: settled borders after 1945 enabled the European Union
Where unsettled fences cause conflict
- India–China: 1962 war, unsettled LAC; Special Representatives talks since 2003
- India–Pakistan: Kashmir and the LoC; Kargil (1999)
- Enclaves and undemarcated stretches with Bangladesh; Sir Creek
Counter-view: walls that divide
- Berlin Wall (1961–89) became a symbol of division; its fall in 1989 united Germany
- Israel's West Bank barrier — security versus humanitarian costs
- Fences can separate families and communities across borders (Punjab, Bengal)
Fences with gates
- SAARC and SAFTA (2006): trade across settled borders
- Bus diplomacy: Delhi–Lahore (1999), Srinagar–Muzaffarabad (2005)
- Confidence-building measures and people-to-people contact
Opening. Open with Frost's two farmers repairing the stone wall each spring — one repeating the proverb, the other asking why — and set out the two views.
Body. Explain the meaning, then fences in personal and social life, between nations where they help, and where unsettled boundaries cause conflict.
Counter-view. Give Frost's doubt its full due: walls can wall in distrust — the Berlin Wall — and divide people who share culture.
Conclusion. Close with the synthesis: good fences make good neighbours only when they are agreed, respected and have gates; good neighbours also make good fences.
- Robert Frost, 'Mending Wall' (1914) — Source of the proverb and its critique
- Indus Waters Treaty (1960) — A settled arrangement surviving conflict
- India–China 1962 war and LAC — Unsettled boundaries breeding conflict
- Ganga Water Treaty with Bangladesh (1996) — Agreed sharing improving relations
- Berlin Wall (1961–89) — Walls as division and their fall
- Delhi–Lahore bus (1999) and Srinagar–Muzaffarabad bus (2005) — Gates in the fence
- Panchsheel Agreement (1954) — Mutual respect for territorial integrity
- “Something there is that doesn't love a wall.” — Robert Frost, Mending Wall
- “Before I built a wall I'd ask to know / What I was walling in or walling out.” — Robert Frost, Mending Wall
- “You can change friends but not neighbours.” — Atal Bihari Vajpayee
- Writing only about border fencing with Pakistan
- Ignoring Frost's poem and its irony
- No personal or social dimension
- Treating all fences as good or all walls as bad
More from Essay 2009
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.