EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2009EssayTopic 3 · 200 marksModel answer

"The focus of health care is increasingly getting skewed towards the 'haves' of our society."

DirectiveEssay
Marks200
Word limit1800–2000
PaperEssay
What the examiner wants

1800–2000 words, 200 marks. In the old pattern (2009) the candidate wrote ONE essay chosen from five topics. Graded on understanding of the topic, orderly arrangement of ideas and concise expression. A statement to examine: test the claim with evidence, explain why the skew happens, note what is being done, and propose a way to health care for all.

Common trap: Weak essays describe hospitals and diseases generally. The top essay proves the skew with facts of 2009 — low public spending (around 1% of GDP), very high out-of-pocket spending, rural-urban gaps in doctors and beds, corporate hospitals and medical tourism for the rich while the poor fall into debt from illness — explains the causes (commercialisation, neglect of primary care, research on diseases of the rich), weighs counter-evidence (NRHM 2005, RSBY 2008), and argues for strong public primary care and pooled financing.

Essay brief

1800–2000 words · 125 marks
Ways to read the topic
  • Economic reading: health care is becoming a market commodity — the rich buy world-class care, the poor go without or into debt.
  • Spatial reading: doctors, hospitals and specialists are concentrated in cities, leaving rural India under-served.
  • Research reading: medicine and drugs focus on lifestyle diseases of the affluent over neglected tropical diseases of the poor (the '10/90 gap').
  • Balanced reading: the skew is real but not inevitable; NRHM and insurance show that the state can rebalance if it invests in public primary care (strongest reading).
Dimensions to cover

Evidence of the skew

  • Public health spending around 1% of GDP — among the lowest in the world
  • Out-of-pocket spending a very large share of total health spending; illness pushes millions into poverty each year
  • Shortage of doctors and specialists in rural primary and community health centres
  • Corporate super-speciality hospitals and medical tourism for foreigners and the rich

Causes

  • Neglect of the Bhore Committee (1946) vision of universal, state-provided care
  • Commercialisation of medical education — capitation-fee colleges
  • Urban bias in placement of facilities and doctors' preference for cities
  • Research and drug pricing driven by paying markets

Who are left out

  • Rural poor, tribals, urban slum dwellers, women and the elderly
  • Maternal and infant mortality remain high (NFHS-3, 2005–06: high child malnutrition)
  • Persisting TB, malaria, kala-azar — diseases of poverty

What is being done (by 2009)

  • National Rural Health Mission (2005): ASHAs, Janani Suraksha Yojana, flexible funds
  • Rashtriya Swasthya Bima Yojana (2008): insurance for BPL families
  • Generic medicine shops (Jan Aushadhi, 2008); Tamil Nadu's model of free drugs procurement
  • Andhra Pradesh's Aarogyasri (2007) for hospital care of the poor

Counter-view

  • Private sector innovation and low-cost models (Aravind Eye Care, Narayana Hrudayalaya) serve the poor too
  • Medical tourism earns foreign exchange and builds capacity
  • Life expectancy and polio campaign show broad gains

Towards health for all

  • Raise public health spending to 2–3% of GDP as the National Health Policy 2002 aimed
  • Strengthen primary care; compulsory rural service for new doctors
  • Regulate private hospitals and drug prices; rational use of generics
  • Address determinants: water, sanitation, nutrition
Structure

Opening. Open with two scenes — a foreign patient in a five-star hospital in a metro, and a tribal woman travelling miles to an empty PHC — and state the claim.

Body. Present evidence of the skew, then its causes, who is left out, and what the state is doing in 2009.

Counter-view. Weigh the counter-view: private innovation, falling mortality and new schemes show the picture is not only bleak.

Conclusion. Close with Alma-Ata's 'Health for All' and the idea that health is a right, not a privilege — the test of a just society is how it treats its sick poor.

Examples to use
  • Bhore Committee (1946) — Original vision of universal public health care
  • Alma-Ata Declaration (1978) — Primary health care and 'Health for All'
  • National Rural Health Mission (2005) — Attempt to rebuild rural public health
  • Rashtriya Swasthya Bima Yojana (2008) — Insurance for the poor
  • Aravind Eye Care and Narayana Hrudayalaya — Low-cost private models serving the poor
  • Medical tourism in Chennai, Delhi and Mumbai — World-class care for those who can pay
  • NFHS-3 (2005–06) — Evidence of malnutrition and health inequality
Quotes
  • “Of all the forms of inequality, injustice in health is the most shocking and inhumane.” — Martin Luther King Jr.
  • “The health of the people is really the foundation upon which all their happiness and all their powers as a state depend.” — Benjamin Disraeli
Pitfalls
  • Describing diseases instead of the distribution of health care
  • No data on spending or rural-urban gaps
  • Blanket condemnation of private health care
  • Citing later schemes (Ayushman Bharat 2018, NHM 2013) as existing in 2009

More from Essay 2009

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.