"Disputes between the riparian states on sharing of river waters in post-Independence India are becoming increasingly complex." Objectively analyse the major disputes in this connection, with special reference to the Southern States.
Break the major inter-state river disputes into their causes, the legal machinery and its outcomes, giving each party's case fairly, with the southern disputes (Cauvery, Krishna, Godavari, Mullaperiyar) at the centre.
Common trap: Weak answers merely list rivers. A strong answer explains why disputes have grown more complex (rising demand, monsoon failure, delayed tribunals, political mobilisation), analyses each southern dispute with tribunal and court milestones, and ends with institutional reform.
SyllabusOld-pattern GS Paper I (2006–12): Geography of India — water resources; Indian Polity — Centre–State relations; current national issues
Model answer
20 marks · 250-word limitWater is a State subject (Entry 17, List II), but Parliament may regulate inter-state rivers (Entry 56, List I) and Article 262 lets it exclude courts from water disputes. Under the Inter-State River Water Disputes Act, 1956 tribunals adjudicate, yet in 2010 most southern disputes remain unresolved decades after they began, and they have grown more complex rather than simpler.
- Cauvery: Karnataka vs Tamil Nadu, Kerala, Puducherry
- Krishna: Maharashtra, Karnataka, Andhra Pradesh
- Godavari: Babli barrage, Maharashtra vs AP
- Mullaperiyar: Kerala vs Tamil Nadu
- Vansadhara: Odisha vs Andhra Pradesh
- Mahadayi: Goa vs Karnataka
Why the disputes are becoming more complex
- Rising demand: Irrigation expansion, drinking water for Bengaluru and Chennai, and industry now compete for flows that were allocated on old cropping patterns.
- Deficit years: Tribunal awards share water in normal years; in a weak monsoon there is no agreed formula for distress sharing, so every bad year reopens the quarrel.
- Delay and non-compliance: Tribunals take decades, awards are not notified for years, and States treat them as negotiable, sometimes passing laws to override them.
- Politicisation: Water has become an identity issue; bandhs, assembly resolutions and electoral pressure leave little room for compromise.
The major southern disputes
- Cauvery: Tribunal set up in 1990; its 1991 interim order was resisted by Karnataka. The final award of February 2007 allotted 419 TMC ft to Tamil Nadu, 270 to Karnataka, 30 to Kerala and 7 to Puducherry; both main States sought review and the award was not yet notified in 2010.
- Krishna: The Bachawat Tribunal (KWDT-I, award 1973–76) shared 2,060 TMC ft at 75% dependability; KWDT-II under Justice Brijesh Kumar (2004) is re-examining surplus flows, while Andhra Pradesh, the lower riparian, objects to the raising of Karnataka's Almatti dam.
- Godavari: The 1980 tribunal award largely settled shares, but Maharashtra's Babli barrage near the border is challenged by Andhra Pradesh before the Supreme Court.
- Mullaperiyar: A dam built in Kerala under an 1886 lease supplies Tamil Nadu. The Supreme Court in 2006 allowed the level to be raised to 142 ft; Kerala's 2006 amendment law capped it at 136 ft on safety grounds, and an Empowered Committee under Justice A.S. Anand (2010) is examining the dam's safety.
- Others: The Vansadhara tribunal (2010) on Andhra Pradesh's side-weir at Katragadda, and Goa's objection to Karnataka's Kalasa–Banduri diversion on the Mahadayi.
Weaknesses of the institutional framework
- Tribunal design: The 2002 amendment fixed time limits (tribunal within a year of request, award in three years, extendable by two), but delays in notification and enforcement remain.
- No basin bodies: The River Boards Act, 1956 has never been used to create a functioning river board, so no basin-wide data or management exists.
- Weak data: States dispute flow data and dependability figures, which lengthens hearings.
Way forward
- Basin approach: Basin authorities with representation of all riparian States, as the Sarkaria Commission and the National Water Policy 2002 urged.
- Distress-sharing formula: A pre-agreed, pro-rata formula for deficit years, with an independent regulator to release water.
- Demand management: Shift to less water-intensive crops, micro-irrigation and urban recycling, which reduces the stakes.
The southern disputes show that adjudication alone cannot settle water when demand keeps rising and awards are resisted. A durable solution lies in time-bound tribunals with enforceable awards, basin-level cooperative management and a demand-side shift in agriculture, so that water becomes a shared resource rather than a symbol of regional pride.
Read more — sources
- OfficialConstitution of India, Article 262 and the Inter-State River Water Disputes Act, 1956 (amended 2002)
- ReportReport of the Sarkaria Commission on Centre–State Relations (1988), chapter on inter-state river water disputes
- OfficialCauvery Water Disputes Tribunal, Final Decision (February 2007)
- BookRamaswamy R. Iyer, Water: Perspectives, Issues, Concerns (Sage, 2003)
More from GS Paper I (old) 2010
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.