"Cost-benefit analysis should not be the sole consideration, while deciding to host events like the Commonwealth Games." Critically comment on this perspective.
Evaluate the view that intangible benefits justify mega-events, set against the costs and risks shown by the 2010 Delhi Commonwealth Games, and reach a balanced position.
Common trap: Writing only about corruption misses the point. A top answer lists intangible gains (prestige, sport, urban infrastructure) and tangible costs (overruns, displacement, governance failures), and argues for cost-benefit plus a social and governance test, not cost-benefit alone.
SyllabusOld-pattern GS Paper I (2006–12): Current national issues and topics of social relevance
Model answer
12 marks · 150-word limitThe XIX Commonwealth Games in Delhi (3–14 October 2010) were finally held well, with India winning 101 medals including 38 gold, but only after cost overruns, delays, a footbridge collapse near the main stadium and corruption charges that led the Prime Minister to set up the Shunglu Committee.
- National prestige, soft power
- Sports culture, athletes' success
- Urban infrastructure legacy
- Tourism and city branding
- Budget overruns, idle venues
- Corruption and poor governance
- Slum evictions, workers' hardship
- Opportunity cost of public funds
The case for looking beyond cost-benefit
- Prestige and soft power: Mega-events signal capability, as the Beijing Olympics of 2008 did for China.
- Sport: India's best-ever CWG medal haul may inspire young athletes and sports investment.
- Urban legacy: The Games accelerated Delhi Metro lines, flyovers and the Barapullah elevated road, and airport upgrades.
- Social cohesion: Large events build national pride and volunteerism; the Games Village and venues can be reused for training and future bids.
Why the perspective needs qualification
- Financial risk: Athens 2004 shows mega-events can leave debt and unused stadiums.
- Opportunity cost: Funds could have gone to health, schools or sanitation in a city with large slums.
- Social and governance costs: Evictions, poor conditions for construction workers and opaque contracting damaged India's image.
- Accountability: Delayed preparation forced emergency spending without competitive bidding, which a strict cost-benefit and audit framework would have prevented.
Cost-benefit analysis should not be the only test, but it must be the first: intangible benefits are real only if events are planned early, transparently and with a clear legacy plan, as later reviews of the CWG showed.
Read more — sources
- OfficialHigh Level Committee for Commonwealth Games 2010 (V.K. Shunglu Committee), constituted October 2010
- ReportHousing and Land Rights Network, 'The 2010 Commonwealth Games: Whose Wealth? Whose Commonwealth?' (2010)
- BookAndrew Zimbalist, Circus Maximus: The Economic Gamble Behind Hosting the Olympics and the World Cup (2015)
More from GS Paper I (old) 2010
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.