EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2010GS Paper I (old)Q7(b) · 12 marksModel answer

"Cost-benefit analysis should not be the sole consideration, while deciding to host events like the Commonwealth Games." Critically comment on this perspective.

DirectiveCritically comment
Marks12
Word limit150
PaperGS Paper I (old)
What the examiner wants

Evaluate the view that intangible benefits justify mega-events, set against the costs and risks shown by the 2010 Delhi Commonwealth Games, and reach a balanced position.

Common trap: Writing only about corruption misses the point. A top answer lists intangible gains (prestige, sport, urban infrastructure) and tangible costs (overruns, displacement, governance failures), and argues for cost-benefit plus a social and governance test, not cost-benefit alone.

SyllabusOld-pattern GS Paper I (2006–12): Current national issues and topics of social relevance

Model answer

12 marks · 150-word limit

The XIX Commonwealth Games in Delhi (3–14 October 2010) were finally held well, with India winning 101 medals including 38 gold, but only after cost overruns, delays, a footbridge collapse near the main stadium and corruption charges that led the Prime Minister to set up the Shunglu Committee.

Intangible gains
  • National prestige, soft power
  • Sports culture, athletes' success
  • Urban infrastructure legacy
  • Tourism and city branding
vs
Costs and risks
  • Budget overruns, idle venues
  • Corruption and poor governance
  • Slum evictions, workers' hardship
  • Opportunity cost of public funds
Hosting mega-events: beyond cost-benefit

The case for looking beyond cost-benefit

  • Prestige and soft power: Mega-events signal capability, as the Beijing Olympics of 2008 did for China.
  • Sport: India's best-ever CWG medal haul may inspire young athletes and sports investment.
  • Urban legacy: The Games accelerated Delhi Metro lines, flyovers and the Barapullah elevated road, and airport upgrades.
  • Social cohesion: Large events build national pride and volunteerism; the Games Village and venues can be reused for training and future bids.

Why the perspective needs qualification

  • Financial risk: Athens 2004 shows mega-events can leave debt and unused stadiums.
  • Opportunity cost: Funds could have gone to health, schools or sanitation in a city with large slums.
  • Social and governance costs: Evictions, poor conditions for construction workers and opaque contracting damaged India's image.
  • Accountability: Delayed preparation forced emergency spending without competitive bidding, which a strict cost-benefit and audit framework would have prevented.

Cost-benefit analysis should not be the only test, but it must be the first: intangible benefits are real only if events are planned early, transparently and with a clear legacy plan, as later reviews of the CWG showed.

Answer length. This model answer runs to about 218 words so that every relevant angle is covered. In the exam, write to the 150-word limit: keep the opening, the strongest one or two points under each heading, the diagram and the conclusion.

Read more — sources

  • OfficialHigh Level Committee for Commonwealth Games 2010 (V.K. Shunglu Committee), constituted October 2010
  • ReportHousing and Land Rights Network, 'The 2010 Commonwealth Games: Whose Wealth? Whose Commonwealth?' (2010)
  • BookAndrew Zimbalist, Circus Maximus: The Economic Gamble Behind Hosting the Olympics and the World Cup (2015)

More from GS Paper I (old) 2010

Q1(a)·20 marks·250 words·Geography, Polity
"Disputes between the riparian states on sharing of river waters in post-Independence India are becoming increasingly complex." Objectively analyse the major disputes in this connection, with special reference to the Southern States.
Water is a State subject (Entry 17, List II), but Parliament may regulate inter-state rivers (Entry 56, List I) and Article 262 lets it exclude courts from water…
Read the model answer →
Q1(b)·20 marks·250 words·Economy
Critically examine the differing estimates for (i) poverty figures, and (ii) GDP growth data for April-June 2010, that have been in the news recently. In your view, what estimates are more reflective of the ground reality, and why?
In 2010 Indians were offered strikingly different numbers on two basic questions: how many of us are poor, and how fast the economy is growing. The differences arise…
Read the model answer →
Q2(a)·12 marks·150 words·History
"Dalhousie's predecessors had acted on the general principles of avoiding annexations, if these could be avoided. Dalhousie acted on the principles of annexation, if he could do so legitimately. His annexations were both of war and peace." Analyse.
Lord Dalhousie (1848–56) believed British rule was superior to native misrule and sought to extend it wherever a legal pretext existed. The quoted view is broadly…
Read the model answer →
Q2(b)·12 marks·150 words·Polity
With respect to Cooperative Societies what are the salient features of the 106th and 111th Constitutional Amendment Bills as at present?
Cooperatives in India had become politicised, frequently superseded by State governments and poorly audited. The 106th Amendment Bill, introduced in the 14th Lok Sabha,…
Read the model answer →
Q2(c)·12 marks·150 words·Economy, Agriculture
"Small-holder farms need to be strengthened to achieve national food security." Do you agree with this assessment? Substantiate.
I agree. Small and marginal holdings of under 2 hectares make up over four-fifths of India's farms and about two-fifths of operated area (Agriculture Census 2005-06),…
Read the model answer →

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.