Comment on the recent HFC-23 emissions controversy that includes in its ambit some Indian companies.
DirectiveComment
Marks5
Word limit50
PaperGS Paper I (old)
What the examiner wants
Explain the HFC-23 CDM controversy and India's stake in it, with a brief view.
Common trap: Explain why HFC-23 destruction earned huge credits (very high global warming potential) and the allegation of perverse incentives.
SyllabusOld-pattern GS Paper I (2006–12): Current national issues — environment and climate change
Model answer
5 marks · 50-word limitHFC-23 is a by-product of making the refrigerant HCFC-22 and a greenhouse gas thousands of times more potent than carbon dioxide.
The controversy
- Credits: Destroying HFC-23 under the Kyoto Protocol's Clean Development Mechanism earned very large carbon credits (CERs) at low cost; Indian and Chinese plants held most of them.
- Allegation: In 2010 CDM Watch and the Environmental Investigation Agency alleged that some plants raised HCFC-22 output just to earn credits, a perverse incentive.
- Response: The CDM Executive Board reviewed the methodology and withheld issuance for some projects; Indian firms denied wrongdoing.
(Later: the EU banned use of HFC-23 credits from 2013, and the Kigali Amendment of 2016 targets HFCs.)
Answer length. This model answer runs to about 108 words so that every relevant angle is covered. In the exam, write to the 50-word limit: keep the opening, the strongest one or two points under each heading and the conclusion.
Read more — sources
- OfficialUNFCCC CDM Executive Board, review of methodology AM0001 for HFC-23 destruction (2010)
- ReportCDM Watch and Environmental Investigation Agency, reports on HFC-23 projects (2010)
← Previous · Q8(a)How is disagreement between the Legislative Council and the Legislative…Next · Q8(c) →Comment on the recommendations of the Wadhwa Commission on the Public…
More from GS Paper I (old) 2010
"Disputes between the riparian states on sharing of river waters in post-Independence India are becoming increasingly complex." Objectively analyse the major disputes in this connection, with special reference to the Southern States.
Water is a State subject (Entry 17, List II), but Parliament may regulate inter-state rivers (Entry 56, List I) and Article 262 lets it exclude courts from water…
Read the model answer →
Critically examine the differing estimates for (i) poverty figures, and (ii) GDP growth data for April-June 2010, that have been in the news recently. In your view, what estimates are more reflective of the ground reality, and why?
In 2010 Indians were offered strikingly different numbers on two basic questions: how many of us are poor, and how fast the economy is growing. The differences arise…
Read the model answer →
"Dalhousie's predecessors had acted on the general principles of avoiding annexations, if these could be avoided. Dalhousie acted on the principles of annexation, if he could do so legitimately. His annexations were both of war and peace." Analyse.
Lord Dalhousie (1848–56) believed British rule was superior to native misrule and sought to extend it wherever a legal pretext existed. The quoted view is broadly…
Read the model answer →
With respect to Cooperative Societies what are the salient features of the 106th and 111th Constitutional Amendment Bills as at present?
Cooperatives in India had become politicised, frequently superseded by State governments and poorly audited. The 106th Amendment Bill, introduced in the 14th Lok Sabha,…
Read the model answer →
"Small-holder farms need to be strengthened to achieve national food security." Do you agree with this assessment? Substantiate.
I agree. Small and marginal holdings of under 2 hectares make up over four-fifths of India's farms and about two-fifths of operated area (Agriculture Census 2005-06),…
Read the model answer →
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.