The role of individual MPs (Members of Parliament) has diminished over the years and as a result healthy constructive debates on policy issues are not usually witnessed. How far can this be attributed to the anti-defection law which was legislated but with a different intention?
Weigh how much of the decline of the individual MP and of debate is due to the Tenth Schedule, and how much to other causes, and give a reasoned verdict on the extent.
Common trap: Many answers only describe the Tenth Schedule. A top answer shows the mismatch between its intention (stopping 'Aaya Ram Gaya Ram' floor-crossing) and its effect (whip on every vote), then gives equal weight to the other causes of decline and ends with reforms such as limiting the whip to confidence and money votes.
SyllabusParliament and State legislatures—structure, functioning, conduct of business, powers & privileges and issues arising out of these.
Model answer
10 marks · 200-word limitThe 52nd Amendment (1985) added the Tenth Schedule to end the 'Aaya Ram Gaya Ram' politics of the late 1960s, when legislators changed sides for office and toppled governments. It was meant to protect the people's mandate, not to silence MPs; yet by disqualifying a member who votes against the party whip on any motion, it has turned many MPs into party delegates.
- Floor-crossing for office (1967 onwards)
- 52nd Amendment 1985: Tenth Schedule
- Whip binds on every vote, Para 2(1)(b)
- MP votes as party directs
- Debate becomes ritual, decided in party rooms
How the law contributes
- Whip on every vote: Para 2(1)(b) disqualifies a member who votes or abstains contrary to the party direction, so even an ordinary bill becomes a test of loyalty and dissent on merits is costly.
- Party over constituency: An MP cannot vote on a farm or regional issue as constituents want; the incentive to study bills and argue a personal view weakens.
- Speaker as judge: Petitions are decided by the presiding officer, often a party nominee and sometimes slowly. Kihoto Hollohan (1992) upheld the Schedule but made the Speaker's decision open to judicial review.
- Mergers still allowed: The 91st Amendment (2003) removed the one-third 'split' exception but kept the two-thirds 'merger' route, so group defection survives while individual conscience does not.
Other causes that matter as much
- Fewer sittings and disruption: Sittings have fallen sharply since the 1950s, and adjournments over scams wash out whole sessions, as in the Winter Session of 2010 over the 2G JPC demand.
- Executive dominance: Ordinances, bills passed without debate in the last hours, and bills not referred to committees reduce the space for backbenchers.
- Party structure: Highly centralised, often family-run parties with no internal democracy control tickets, so MPs defer to the leadership regardless of the whip.
- Coalition era: Bargaining among coalition partners shifts decisions outside the House to steering committees.
Reforms suggested
- Limit the whip: Dinesh Goswami Committee (1990) and the Law Commission's 170th Report (1999) suggested applying the law only to confidence, no-confidence and money votes.
- Neutral adjudicator: Let the President or Governor decide on the advice of the Election Commission, as proposed by the NCRWC (2002), within a fixed time.
- Better House business: A minimum number of sitting days and mandatory committee scrutiny of bills would restore deliberation.
The anti-defection law is a significant but partial explanation: it has curbed the freedom of the individual MP on every vote, while disruption, executive dominance and centralised parties have done as much damage. Confining the whip to votes that affect the survival of the government would keep stability and give debate back its meaning.
Read more — sources
- BookM. Laxmikanth, Indian Polity — Ch. Anti-Defection Law (Tenth Schedule)
- OfficialKihoto Hollohan v. Zachillhu (1992), Supreme Court of India
- ReportNational Commission to Review the Working of the Constitution (NCRWC), Report 2002 — Ch. on Parliament
- ReportLaw Commission of India, 170th Report on Reform of the Electoral Laws (1999)
More from GS Paper 2 2013
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.