Many State Governments further bifurcate geographical administrative areas like Districts and Talukas for better governance. In light of the above, can it also be justified that more number of smaller States would bring in effective governance at State level? Discuss.
Use the logic of smaller districts and talukas to test whether smaller States also improve governance, giving evidence for and against and a balanced conclusion.
Common trap: In 2013, with Telangana under decision, answers often took sides emotionally. A top answer compares the experience of the three States created in 2000, shows that size is only one variable, and proposes criteria and a commission before new States are carved.
SyllabusFunctions and responsibilities of the Union and the States, issues and challenges pertaining to the federal structure, devolution of powers and finances up to local levels and challenges therein.
Model answer
10 marks · 200-word limitStates carve new districts and talukas because a smaller unit brings the administration physically closer to people and lets officers supervise schemes better. Whether the same logic holds for States is contested: the experience of Uttarakhand, Jharkhand and Chhattisgarh (2000) shows that size helps only when matched by capacity and stable politics.
- Administration closer to people
- Focus on regional needs
- Ends neglect by distant capital
- Chhattisgarh, Uttarakhand gains
- New capital and bureaucracy costs
- Revenue and resource imbalance
- Instability, as in Jharkhand
- Demand for ever more States
Why smaller units can govern better
- Span of control: A Chief Minister and secretariat can monitor fewer districts closely, as a Collector does in a smaller district.
- Regional focus: Policies fit local geography and needs; Uttarakhand's hill economy and Chhattisgarh's tribal and mineral belt were neglected by Lucknow and Bhopal.
- Evidence: Chhattisgarh's public distribution system reforms and Uttarakhand's faster growth after 2000 are cited as gains of separation.
- Democratic voice: Identity and backwardness grievances, as in Telangana and Vidarbha, are addressed politically rather than through prolonged agitation.
Why size alone does not decide
- Jharkhand: Despite mineral wealth, it saw frequent changes of government and spells of President's Rule, showing that instability can follow smaller size.
- Costs: New capitals, High Courts and cadres are expensive, and division of rivers, power and debt creates disputes.
- Viability: Some proposed States would depend heavily on central transfers; very small States may also be more vulnerable to capture by narrow interests.
- Large but well-run: Larger States such as Tamil Nadu and Gujarat show that governance quality depends on institutions and leadership.
Way forward
- Criteria first: A second States Reorganisation Commission could set criteria of economic viability, administrative convenience and popular will, while decentralisation through panchayats and municipalities is deepened.
Smaller States can bring effective governance only when they are economically viable and backed by stable politics and capable institutions. Instead of piecemeal creation under agitation, India needs objective criteria and deeper devolution within States.
Read more — sources
- ReportStates Reorganisation Commission (Fazl Ali) Report, 1955
- ReportCommittee for Consultations on the Situation in Andhra Pradesh (Srikrishna Committee), Report 2010
- OfficialConstitution of India, Article 3
- NCERTPolitics in India since Independence (Class XII) — Ch. Challenges of Nation Building
More from GS Paper 2 2013
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.