Farming has lost the ability to be a source of subsistence for majority of farmers in India.
1000–1200 words, 125 marks. One topic from each Section. The essay is graded on interpretation, structure and range of illustration — not on reaching a particular conclusion. This is a claim to be tested, not a slogan to be endorsed: weigh the evidence for and against before you take a side.
Common trap: Most candidates write a generic "problems of Indian agriculture" note — irrigation, seeds, MSP — and never engage with the word "subsistence". The top essay asks whether a farm household can live off its land today, shows that most of its income now comes from wages and livestock rather than cultivation, and argues the real question is diversification and exit, not only farm support.
Essay brief
1000–1200 words · 125 marks- Economic: shrinking holdings, rising input costs and volatile prices mean cultivation alone no longer covers a family's basic needs for most small and marginal farmers — the core reading.
- Structural: the claim is really about a stalled transition — too many people remain on land that cannot support them because non-farm jobs did not grow fast enough to absorb them (strongest reading).
- Ecological: the natural base of farming — groundwater, soil health, a predictable monsoon — is eroding, so subsistence is under threat from below as well as from markets.
- Counter-reading: farming has not "lost" its ability; it has been starved of public investment, and with irrigation, price support and collectives it can again sustain families.
Size of the holding
- Repeated division across generations has left the great majority of holdings small or marginal (Agriculture Census)
- Below about one hectare, even good prices barely cover a family's food, school and health costs
- Tenant and sharecropping farmers, often unrecorded, carry the risk without access to formal credit or PM-KISAN
Income and markets
- NSS Situation Assessment Survey (70th round, 2013): cultivation provided less than half of an agricultural household's income
- Price crashes in onion, tomato and potato wipe out a season; MSP procurement reaches a minority of crops and states
- Input costs (diesel, fertiliser, labour) rise faster than farm-gate prices — the terms of trade problem
Risk and debt
- Rain-fed farming on about half the net sown area exposes families to monsoon failure
- Dependence on moneylenders for consumption and inputs turns one bad season into a debt trap
- NCRB data on farmer suicides as the most tragic marker of distress, concentrated in cash-crop and rain-fed belts
The ecological base
- Groundwater over-extraction in Punjab, Haryana and western UP; free power encouraging paddy in water-scarce zones
- Soil degradation from imbalanced fertiliser use — the logic behind Soil Health Cards (2015)
- Climate variability: heat waves at grain-filling stage, unseasonal hailstorms
Where farmers still thrive
- Diversification into dairy (Amul's cooperative model), poultry, fisheries and horticulture raises and stabilises income
- Farmer Producer Organisations give small farmers bargaining power in inputs and sales
- Irrigated, diversified districts show farming can still sustain families where investment has gone in
Counter-view
- Subsistence is a low bar; Indian agriculture still produces record food output and feeds a large population
- Rural household income now blends farm and non-farm work — that is normal structural change, not failure
- The problem is too many people on the land, not farming itself; fixing agriculture alone cannot solve it
Way forward
- Price and income support: PM-KISAN (2019), crop insurance (PMFBY, 2016), e-NAM (2016), better procurement
- Water: micro-irrigation, crop shifts away from paddy in water-stressed zones
- Non-farm jobs in food processing and rural manufacturing so that exit from farming is a choice, not distress
Opening. Open with a concrete household — a two-acre cotton farmer in Vidarbha whose son drives an auto in Nagpur and whose wife works on MGNREGA sites; ask which of these incomes actually feeds the family.
Body. Move from evidence to explanation: first show what the data say about farm income, then the causes — holding size, prices, risk, ecology — and then the places where farming still works.
Counter-view. Give a full paragraph to the view that the claim confuses structural change with crisis: in every developed economy, people left farming as incomes rose.
Conclusion. Close by reframing the question: the goal is not to keep every farmer on the farm but to make farming viable for those who stay and exit dignified for those who leave. Return to the opening family.
- NSS 70th round Situation Assessment Survey of Agricultural Households (2013) — Evidence that cultivation is no longer the main income source for many farm households
- National Commission on Farmers (M.S. Swaminathan, 2004–06) — Its recommendation of MSP at cost plus 50% shows how long the income question has been on the table
- Amul and the cooperative dairy model (Verghese Kurien) — Proof that small producers with collective bargaining can earn steady incomes
- Doubling Farmers' Income committee (Ashok Dalwai, 2016–18) — The official shift from a production goal to an income goal
- Punjab's groundwater crisis and the free-power paddy cycle — How policy that once raised output now undermines the base of farming
- PM-KISAN direct income support (2019) and Telangana's Rythu Bandhu (2018) — Later evidence that the state itself began treating cultivation income as insufficient; flag that these came after 2017
- Sikkim declared a fully organic state (2016) — An alternative model that cuts input costs, with its own yield trade-offs
- “If agriculture goes wrong, nothing else will have a chance to go right.” — M.S. Swaminathan
- “Everything else can wait, but not agriculture.” — Jawaharlal Nehru
- Turning the essay into a list of agricultural schemes with no argument about subsistence
- Romanticising the farmer or writing only about suicides; the examiner wants balance and evidence
- Ignoring the non-farm economy — the claim cannot be judged without asking where the surplus labour should go
More from Essay 2017
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.