Social media is inherently a selfish medium.
1000–1200 words, 125 marks. One topic from each Section. The essay is graded on interpretation, structure and range of illustration — not on reaching a particular conclusion. The word "inherently" is the hinge: decide whether selfishness lies in the medium's design or in how people use it.
Common trap: Most essays list the pros and cons of social media. The top essay tests the word "inherently": it shows how design — likes, follower counts, algorithms tuned for attention — rewards self-display, but also shows the same medium mobilising strangers for relief and justice, and concludes that selfishness is encouraged by design, not destined by it.
Essay brief
1000–1200 words · 125 marks- Design reading: platforms are built around the self — the profile, the selfie, the like count — and algorithms reward attention-seeking; the medium nudges selfishness (strong reading).
- Commercial reading: the medium is selfish in a deeper sense — it exists to capture users' attention and data for profit; the user is the product.
- User reading: the medium is neutral; selfishness or service depends on users, as seen in crowdfunding, blood donation drives and disaster coordination.
- Balanced reading: social media amplifies what people bring to it, and its design tilts the balance — so the remedy lies in design, regulation and digital literacy (strongest overall verdict).
The case for "selfish"
- Profiles, selfies and personal branding put the self at the centre
- Likes and followers turn relationships into metrics; comparison breeds anxiety
- Echo chambers: users seek affirmation rather than understanding
The business model
- Free services financed by advertising and data
- Algorithms optimise for engagement, often favouring outrage
- Later revelations (Cambridge Analytica, 2018; Facebook files, 2021) — mark as post-2017
The case against
- Arab Spring (2011) and civic movements organised online
- Disaster relief: volunteers coordinating rescue during the Chennai floods (2015)
- Ice Bucket Challenge (2014) raising funds for ALS research; blood donor groups
Harms to society
- Fake news and rumour-driven violence
- Online abuse, especially of women
- Polarisation weakening democratic discussion
Regulation and rights
- Shreya Singhal v. Union of India (2015) struck down Section 66A — free speech online matters
- Intermediary liability and later IT Rules (2021)
- Data protection debate; later the Digital Personal Data Protection Act (2023)
Way forward
- Platform design that rewards quality, not only virality
- Digital literacy in schools
- Individual ethics — the same self-awareness one brings offline
Opening. Open with two posts on the same evening — a filtered holiday selfie with a thousand likes, and a message asking for O-negative blood for an accident victim that reaches a donor in minutes.
Body. Make the case for selfishness first — design and business model — then the case against, with concrete examples of collective action, and then the social harms and regulation.
Counter-view. The counter section is built in: after the case for "selfish", argue that the medium has served others at scale, which defeats the word "inherently".
Conclusion. Close with a clear verdict: social media is not inherently selfish but is designed in ways that reward the self; better design, law and personal ethics can tilt it back. Return to the two posts.
- Arab Spring (2011) — Social media as a tool of collective political action
- Chennai floods (2015) volunteer networks — Coordination for others, not the self
- Ice Bucket Challenge (2014) — Self-display harnessed for a cause — shows the mixed nature
- Shreya Singhal v. Union of India (2015) — Speech rights in the digital space
- Cambridge Analytica scandal (2018) — The business model's selfishness; post-2017
- Rumour-driven mob lynchings linked to messaging apps (2018) — Harms of viral misinformation; post-2017
- “The medium is the message.” — Marshall McLuhan
- “Man is by nature a social animal.” — Aristotle (as commonly rendered)
- Writing a list of advantages and disadvantages without addressing "inherently"
- Moralising against young users without examining platform design
- Ignoring the positive uses that test the claim
More from Essay 2017
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.