EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2017EssayTopic 8 · 125 marksModel answer

Social media is inherently a selfish medium.

DirectiveEssay
Marks125
Word limit1000–1200
PaperEssay
What the examiner wants

1000–1200 words, 125 marks. One topic from each Section. The essay is graded on interpretation, structure and range of illustration — not on reaching a particular conclusion. The word "inherently" is the hinge: decide whether selfishness lies in the medium's design or in how people use it.

Common trap: Most essays list the pros and cons of social media. The top essay tests the word "inherently": it shows how design — likes, follower counts, algorithms tuned for attention — rewards self-display, but also shows the same medium mobilising strangers for relief and justice, and concludes that selfishness is encouraged by design, not destined by it.

Essay brief

1000–1200 words · 125 marks
Ways to read the topic
  • Design reading: platforms are built around the self — the profile, the selfie, the like count — and algorithms reward attention-seeking; the medium nudges selfishness (strong reading).
  • Commercial reading: the medium is selfish in a deeper sense — it exists to capture users' attention and data for profit; the user is the product.
  • User reading: the medium is neutral; selfishness or service depends on users, as seen in crowdfunding, blood donation drives and disaster coordination.
  • Balanced reading: social media amplifies what people bring to it, and its design tilts the balance — so the remedy lies in design, regulation and digital literacy (strongest overall verdict).
Dimensions to cover

The case for "selfish"

  • Profiles, selfies and personal branding put the self at the centre
  • Likes and followers turn relationships into metrics; comparison breeds anxiety
  • Echo chambers: users seek affirmation rather than understanding

The business model

  • Free services financed by advertising and data
  • Algorithms optimise for engagement, often favouring outrage
  • Later revelations (Cambridge Analytica, 2018; Facebook files, 2021) — mark as post-2017

The case against

  • Arab Spring (2011) and civic movements organised online
  • Disaster relief: volunteers coordinating rescue during the Chennai floods (2015)
  • Ice Bucket Challenge (2014) raising funds for ALS research; blood donor groups

Harms to society

  • Fake news and rumour-driven violence
  • Online abuse, especially of women
  • Polarisation weakening democratic discussion

Regulation and rights

  • Shreya Singhal v. Union of India (2015) struck down Section 66A — free speech online matters
  • Intermediary liability and later IT Rules (2021)
  • Data protection debate; later the Digital Personal Data Protection Act (2023)

Way forward

  • Platform design that rewards quality, not only virality
  • Digital literacy in schools
  • Individual ethics — the same self-awareness one brings offline
Structure

Opening. Open with two posts on the same evening — a filtered holiday selfie with a thousand likes, and a message asking for O-negative blood for an accident victim that reaches a donor in minutes.

Body. Make the case for selfishness first — design and business model — then the case against, with concrete examples of collective action, and then the social harms and regulation.

Counter-view. The counter section is built in: after the case for "selfish", argue that the medium has served others at scale, which defeats the word "inherently".

Conclusion. Close with a clear verdict: social media is not inherently selfish but is designed in ways that reward the self; better design, law and personal ethics can tilt it back. Return to the two posts.

Examples to use
  • Arab Spring (2011) — Social media as a tool of collective political action
  • Chennai floods (2015) volunteer networks — Coordination for others, not the self
  • Ice Bucket Challenge (2014) — Self-display harnessed for a cause — shows the mixed nature
  • Shreya Singhal v. Union of India (2015) — Speech rights in the digital space
  • Cambridge Analytica scandal (2018) — The business model's selfishness; post-2017
  • Rumour-driven mob lynchings linked to messaging apps (2018) — Harms of viral misinformation; post-2017
Quotes
  • “The medium is the message.” — Marshall McLuhan
  • “Man is by nature a social animal.” — Aristotle (as commonly rendered)
Pitfalls
  • Writing a list of advantages and disadvantages without addressing "inherently"
  • Moralising against young users without examining platform design
  • Ignoring the positive uses that test the claim

More from Essay 2017

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.