EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2017EssayTopic 7 · 125 marksModel answer

We may brave human laws but cannot resist natural laws.

DirectiveEssay
Marks125
Word limit1000–1200
PaperEssay
What the examiner wants

1000–1200 words, 125 marks. One topic from each Section. The essay is graded on interpretation, structure and range of illustration — not on reaching a particular conclusion. The topic contrasts two kinds of law; the essay should explain why one can be defied and the other cannot, and what that means for human conduct.

Common trap: Weak essays drift into a general environment essay. The strong one first explains the difference — human laws are conventions enforced by people and can be broken or changed; natural laws are regularities that enforce themselves through consequences — then shows the price of ignoring them in ecology, health and the body, and adds that defying unjust human laws has sometimes been a moral duty.

Essay brief

1000–1200 words · 125 marks
Ways to read the topic
  • Ecological reading: we can violate environmental rules and escape fines, but we cannot escape floods, droughts and climate change that follow from breaking ecological limits — the strongest and most usable reading.
  • Moral reading: brave human laws in the sense of civil disobedience — Gandhi's salt march defied unjust laws — while natural moral law (conscience, natural justice) cannot be defied without self-harm.
  • Personal reading: one may escape a traffic challan, but not the consequence of a crash; the body's laws of health and ageing cannot be negotiated.
  • Humility reading: science lets us understand and use natural laws, not suspend them — progress is learning to work with nature rather than conquer it.
Dimensions to cover

Two kinds of law

  • Human laws are made, enforced and changed by people; they can be evaded or defied
  • Natural laws — gravity, thermodynamics, ecological limits — describe what must happen; no court can suspend them
  • Punishment for human laws depends on detection; consequences of natural laws are certain

Braving human laws

  • Civil disobedience against unjust laws — Salt Satyagraha (1930), Martin Luther King's campaigns
  • But also defiance for private gain — illegal mining, encroachment on floodplains
  • Human laws gain legitimacy when they align with natural justice

Nature's self-enforcing laws

  • Construction on floodplains and riverbeds meets floods — Kedarnath (2013), Chennai (2015)
  • Groundwater over-extraction in Punjab and Rajasthan leads to falling water tables
  • Antibiotic overuse produces resistance — natural selection at work

Global scale

  • Climate change as the clearest case: emissions obey physics regardless of politics
  • Paris Agreement (2015) and Sendai Framework (2015) as attempts to make human law follow natural law
  • The Aral Sea's shrinkage after Soviet irrigation diversion

Counter-view

  • Humans have used natural laws to overcome natural limits — flight, vaccines, Green Revolution
  • Some human laws are also unyielding in effect, such as market forces
  • Natural law can be misused to justify inequality as "natural"

The lesson for governance

  • Align human law with ecological law: Environmental Impact Assessment, eco-sensitive zones, coastal regulation
  • Precautionary principle and polluter pays (recognised by Indian courts in Vellore Citizens' Welfare Forum, 1996)
  • Respect for limits as the basis of sustainable development
Structure

Opening. Open with the image of the 2013 Kedarnath flood — buildings put up in defiance of rules, swept away by a river that followed only gravity.

Body. Explain the two kinds of law first, then show what happens when each is defied — in society, in ecology, in the body, and at the planetary scale.

Counter-view. Give a paragraph to the counter-view that human ingenuity has outwitted natural limits, and answer it: science works by obeying natural laws, not by breaking them.

Conclusion. Close with Bacon's idea that nature, to be commanded, must be obeyed: the task is to make human laws wise enough to respect natural ones. Return to the river.

Examples to use
  • Kedarnath floods (2013) and Chennai floods (2015) — Natural laws enforcing themselves on unplanned construction
  • Salt Satyagraha (1930) — Braving an unjust human law as moral duty
  • Western Ghats Ecology Expert Panel (Madhav Gadgil, 2011) — Warnings that align law with ecology, largely ignored
  • Vellore Citizens' Welfare Forum v. Union of India (1996) — Supreme Court adopting the precautionary and polluter-pays principles
  • Antimicrobial resistance — Biology punishing misuse with certainty
  • Aral Sea shrinkage — A global lesson of defying hydrological limits
  • Joshimath land subsidence (2023) — Later example of the same pattern; mark as post-2017
Quotes
  • “Nature, to be commanded, must be obeyed.” — Francis Bacon, Novum Organum
  • “The world has enough for everyone's need, but not enough for everyone's greed.” — Mahatma Gandhi
Pitfalls
  • Turning it into a pure climate-change essay without explaining the contrast between the two kinds of law
  • Implying that breaking human laws is always wrong — civil disobedience complicates this
  • Fatalism: suggesting humans are helpless before nature

More from Essay 2017

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.