We may brave human laws but cannot resist natural laws.
1000–1200 words, 125 marks. One topic from each Section. The essay is graded on interpretation, structure and range of illustration — not on reaching a particular conclusion. The topic contrasts two kinds of law; the essay should explain why one can be defied and the other cannot, and what that means for human conduct.
Common trap: Weak essays drift into a general environment essay. The strong one first explains the difference — human laws are conventions enforced by people and can be broken or changed; natural laws are regularities that enforce themselves through consequences — then shows the price of ignoring them in ecology, health and the body, and adds that defying unjust human laws has sometimes been a moral duty.
Essay brief
1000–1200 words · 125 marks- Ecological reading: we can violate environmental rules and escape fines, but we cannot escape floods, droughts and climate change that follow from breaking ecological limits — the strongest and most usable reading.
- Moral reading: brave human laws in the sense of civil disobedience — Gandhi's salt march defied unjust laws — while natural moral law (conscience, natural justice) cannot be defied without self-harm.
- Personal reading: one may escape a traffic challan, but not the consequence of a crash; the body's laws of health and ageing cannot be negotiated.
- Humility reading: science lets us understand and use natural laws, not suspend them — progress is learning to work with nature rather than conquer it.
Two kinds of law
- Human laws are made, enforced and changed by people; they can be evaded or defied
- Natural laws — gravity, thermodynamics, ecological limits — describe what must happen; no court can suspend them
- Punishment for human laws depends on detection; consequences of natural laws are certain
Braving human laws
- Civil disobedience against unjust laws — Salt Satyagraha (1930), Martin Luther King's campaigns
- But also defiance for private gain — illegal mining, encroachment on floodplains
- Human laws gain legitimacy when they align with natural justice
Nature's self-enforcing laws
- Construction on floodplains and riverbeds meets floods — Kedarnath (2013), Chennai (2015)
- Groundwater over-extraction in Punjab and Rajasthan leads to falling water tables
- Antibiotic overuse produces resistance — natural selection at work
Global scale
- Climate change as the clearest case: emissions obey physics regardless of politics
- Paris Agreement (2015) and Sendai Framework (2015) as attempts to make human law follow natural law
- The Aral Sea's shrinkage after Soviet irrigation diversion
Counter-view
- Humans have used natural laws to overcome natural limits — flight, vaccines, Green Revolution
- Some human laws are also unyielding in effect, such as market forces
- Natural law can be misused to justify inequality as "natural"
The lesson for governance
- Align human law with ecological law: Environmental Impact Assessment, eco-sensitive zones, coastal regulation
- Precautionary principle and polluter pays (recognised by Indian courts in Vellore Citizens' Welfare Forum, 1996)
- Respect for limits as the basis of sustainable development
Opening. Open with the image of the 2013 Kedarnath flood — buildings put up in defiance of rules, swept away by a river that followed only gravity.
Body. Explain the two kinds of law first, then show what happens when each is defied — in society, in ecology, in the body, and at the planetary scale.
Counter-view. Give a paragraph to the counter-view that human ingenuity has outwitted natural limits, and answer it: science works by obeying natural laws, not by breaking them.
Conclusion. Close with Bacon's idea that nature, to be commanded, must be obeyed: the task is to make human laws wise enough to respect natural ones. Return to the river.
- Kedarnath floods (2013) and Chennai floods (2015) — Natural laws enforcing themselves on unplanned construction
- Salt Satyagraha (1930) — Braving an unjust human law as moral duty
- Western Ghats Ecology Expert Panel (Madhav Gadgil, 2011) — Warnings that align law with ecology, largely ignored
- Vellore Citizens' Welfare Forum v. Union of India (1996) — Supreme Court adopting the precautionary and polluter-pays principles
- Antimicrobial resistance — Biology punishing misuse with certainty
- Aral Sea shrinkage — A global lesson of defying hydrological limits
- Joshimath land subsidence (2023) — Later example of the same pattern; mark as post-2017
- “Nature, to be commanded, must be obeyed.” — Francis Bacon, Novum Organum
- “The world has enough for everyone's need, but not enough for everyone's greed.” — Mahatma Gandhi
- Turning it into a pure climate-change essay without explaining the contrast between the two kinds of law
- Implying that breaking human laws is always wrong — civil disobedience complicates this
- Fatalism: suggesting humans are helpless before nature
More from Essay 2017
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.