Case study: You are the head of the Human Resources department of an organisation.
Set out the possible recommendations with their merits and demerits from several angles (legal, ethical, industrial relations) and argue for the most balanced one.
Common trap: Many answers accept the drunkenness finding as the end of the matter. A top answer checks the law, which does not excuse the employer for a death on that ground, looks at the company's own supervision failure, and separates legal liability from humane support.
SyllabusPublic/Civil service values and Ethics in Public administration: Status and problems; ethical concerns and dilemmas in government and private institutions; laws, rules, regulations and conscience as sources of ethical guidance; accountability and ethical governance; strengthening of ethical and moral values in governance; ethical issues in international relations and funding; corporate governance.
The case
You are the head of the Human Resources department of an organisation. One day one of the workers died on duty. His family was demanding compensation. However, the company denied compensation because it was revealed in investigation that he was drunk at the time of the accident. The workers of the company went on to strike demanding compensation for the family of the deceased. The Chairman of the management board has asked for your recommendation. What recommendation would you provide to the management? Discuss the merits and demerits of each of the recommendations.
Model answer
20 marks · 250-word limitA worker's death on duty is first a human tragedy and only then a question of liability. The company's refusal may also be legally weak: under the Employees' Compensation Act, 1923, the drink-or-drugs defence in Section 3 covers only injuries that do not result in death or permanent total disablement.
- Independent inquiry into cause and safety lapses
- Pay statutory compensation without delay
- Add ex gratia support for the family
- Conciliation with union to end strike
- Fix supervision and alcohol-control systems
Stakeholders and ethical issues
| Stakeholder | Interest/stake |
|---|---|
| Deceased worker's family | Loss of breadwinner; livelihood, children's education and dignity |
| Workers and union | Solidarity, job security and a fair safety culture |
| Management and Chairman | Production, cost, discipline and reputation |
| HR head | Fairness, legal compliance and industrial peace |
- Justice versus discipline: Paying may seem to reward drunkenness, while refusing punishes a family that did nothing wrong.
- Shared responsibility: An intoxicated worker on duty also points to failed supervision, gate checks and safety procedures, so the company cannot blame only the worker.
Recommendations with merits and demerits
| Recommendation | Merits | Demerits |
|---|---|---|
| Uphold the denial | Signals zero tolerance for alcohol at work | Likely unlawful for a death; prolongs strike; harsh on an innocent family |
| Order an independent inquiry and post-mortem review | Establishes facts and the company's own lapses; credible to workers | Takes time; strike may continue meanwhile |
| Deposit statutory compensation promptly with the Commissioner, as Section 8 of the Act requires for a death, or route it through ESIC if the worker is covered | Complies with law; avoids interest and penalty under the Act; restores trust | Workers may see it as legal minimum only |
| Add ex gratia aid: education support, compassionate job for a dependant | Humane; strengthens loyalty; ends the strike faster | Extra cost; may be cited as precedent |
| Conciliation with the union under the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 | Ends strike through a binding settlement; dialogue | Needs concessions from both sides |
Recommended course of action
- Combine options two to five: Pay what the law requires, add humane support in a written settlement, and keep discipline through policy rather than by penalising the bereaved.
- Prevent recurrence: Introduce breath-analyser checks at entry, supervisor accountability, counselling and de-addiction support, and regular safety training.
- Communicate: Brief workers openly on the inquiry and settlement so that trust is restored.
- Since then: The Code on Social Security, 2020, which absorbs the 1923 Act, came into force on 21 November 2025.
Good corporate governance treats workers as stakeholders, not costs. Articles 42 and 43 of the Constitution envisage just and humane conditions of work. A fair, prompt and compassionate settlement, joined to a stronger safety system, serves the family, the workers and the company's long-term interest alike.
Read more — sources
- OfficialEmployees' Compensation Act, 1923 — Section 3 (employer's liability)
- OfficialIndustrial Disputes Act, 1947 — conciliation and settlement provisions
- OfficialEmployees' State Insurance Act, 1948 — dependants' benefit
- OfficialConstitution of India — Articles 42 and 43 (Directive Principles)
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 4 (Ethics) 2017
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.