EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2022GS Paper 4 (Ethics)QQ11 (Case Study) · 20 marksCase StudyModel answer

Case study: Rakesh was working as Joint Commissioner in Transport Department of a city.

DirectiveCritically examine
Marks20
Word limit250
PaperGS Paper 4 (Ethics)
What the examiner wants

Set out Rakesh's options, examine each critically, name the competing values and give a concrete plan to end the strike; all four sub-parts must be answered.

Common trap: Answers tend to side wholly with the union or with the management. A top answer separates the driver's fault from his family's need: it denies an award that would reward violence yet relieves the dependants through lawful humanitarian channels.

SyllabusCase Studies on above issues. (Public/Civil service values and Ethics in Public administration: ethical concerns and dilemmas in government and private institutions; laws, rules, regulations and conscience as sources of ethical guidance; accountability and ethical governance; corporate governance.)

The case

Rakesh was working as Joint Commissioner in Transport Department of a city. As a part of his job profile, among others, he was entrusted with the task of overseeing the control and functioning of City Transport Department. A case of strike by the drivers’ union of City Transport Department over the issue of compensation to a driver who died on duty while driving the bus came up before him for decision in the matter. He gathered that the driver (deceased) was plying Bus No. 528 which passed through busy and congested roads of the city. It so happened that near an intersection on the way, there was an accident involving the bus and a car driven by a middle-aged man. It was found that there was altercation between the driver and the car driver. Heated arguments between them led to fight and the driver gave him a blow. Lot of passerbys had gathered and tried to intervene but without success. Eventually, both of them were badly injured and profusely bleeding and were taken to the nearby hospital. The driver succumbed to the injuries and could not be saved. The middle-aged driver’s condition was also critical but after a day, he recovered and was discharged. Police had immediately come at the spot of accident and FIR was registered. Police investigation revealed that the quarrel in question was started by the bus driver and he had resorted to physical violence. There was exchange of blows between them. The City Transport Department management is considering of not giving any extra compensation to the driver’s (deceased) family. The family is very aggrieved, depressed and agitated against the discriminatory and non-sympathetic approach of the City Transport Department management. The bus driver (deceased) was 52 years of age, was survived by his wife and two school-college going daughters. He was the sole earner of the family. The City Transport Department workers’ union took up this case and when found no favourable response from the management, decided to go on strike. The union’s demand was two-fold. First was full extra compensation as given to other drivers who died on duty and secondly employment to one family member. The strike has continued for 10 days and the deadlock remains. (a) What are the options available to Rakesh to meet the above situation? (b) Critically examine each of the options identified by Rakesh. (c) What are the ethical dilemmas being faced by Rakesh? (d) What course of action would Rakesh adopt to diffuse the above situation?

Model answer

20 marks · 250-word limit

The driver died on duty, but in a fight that the police found he had started. Rakesh must reconcile two truths: the department cannot reward violence through its on-duty death award, yet a widow and two school- and college-going daughters have lost their sole earner, and a 10-day strike is hurting the city.

Rakesh's decision
  • Widow and two daughters
  • Workers' union
  • Department management and its rules
  • Commuters hit by the strike
  • Injured car driver
  • Rule of law and precedent
  • Morale of other drivers
Interests Rakesh must balance

(a) Options available to Rakesh

  • Option 1: Back the management: deny extra compensation and the job, and wait out the strike.
  • Option 2: Concede both demands in full.
  • Option 3: A middle path: release all dues promptly, offer humanitarian relief and consider compassionate appointment under the rules, while denying the on-duty death award.
  • Option 4: Refer the dispute to a committee or to conciliation and keep negotiating.

(b) Critical examination of the options

OptionMeritsDemerits
1. Back the managementConsistent with the police finding; no reward for misconductPunishes a family for the driver's fault; strike drags on
2. Concede fullyEnds the strike at onceRewards violence; sets a precedent; unfair to drivers who died blameless
3. Middle pathJustice and compassion together; strong case to end the strikeUnion may hold out for the full award
4. Committee or conciliationNeutral, deliberateDelay deepens hardship for commuters and the family

(c) Ethical dilemmas faced by Rakesh

  • Rules versus compassion: The on-duty death award presumes a blameless death; the family's distress is real all the same.
  • Individual fault versus collective punishment: The driver began the quarrel, but his wife and daughters did nothing wrong.
  • Workers' rights versus public interest: The right to protest clashes with commuters' need for buses on the city's busy routes.
  • Precedent versus expediency: Giving in may end this strike but invites the next one.

(d) Course of action to defuse the situation

  • Talk, and be transparent: Meet the union and the family at once, share the police findings candidly and show empathy for their loss.
  • Separate fault from need: Release every terminal due without delay, seek legal advice on any statutory compensation, and sanction humanitarian ex gratia relief clearly distinct from the on-duty award.
  • Compassionate appointment: Consider the wife or an eligible daughter under the department's rules; the Supreme Court in Umesh Kumar Nagpal (1994) held that such appointment exists to tide a family over sudden destitution, as here.
  • End the strike, prevent repeats: Ask the union to resume work, run alternative buses meanwhile, and introduce road-safety and anger-management training and a written compensation policy for misconduct cases.

Justice here is not all-or-nothing. By refusing an award that would reward violence while ensuring the family is not left destitute, Rakesh upholds both the rule of law and compassion, and gives the union a principled, face-saving way to call off the strike.

Answer length. This model answer runs to about 422 words so that every relevant angle is covered. In the exam, write to the 250-word limit: keep the opening, the strongest one or two points under each heading, the diagram and the conclusion.

Read more — sources

  • OfficialSupreme Court of India, Umesh Kumar Nagpal v. State of Haryana (1994) — compassionate appointment
  • OfficialIndustrial Disputes Act, 1947 — conciliation machinery
  • OfficialEmployees' Compensation Act, 1923

Related questions from earlier years

More from GS Paper 4 (Ethics) 2022

QQ1(a)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
Wisdom lies in knowing what to reckon with and what to overlook. An officer being engrossed with the periphery, ignoring the core issues before him, is not rare in the bureaucracy. Do you agree that such preoccupation of an administrator leads to travesty of…
Administrative wisdom is the ability to separate the essential from the incidental. When an officer perfects files and protocol while grievances wait, the rule becomes…
Read the model answer →
QQ1(b)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
Apart from intellectual competency and moral qualities, empathy and compassion are some of the other vital attributes that facilitate the civil servants to be more competent in tackling the crucial issues or taking critical decisions. Explain with suitable…
Intellect tells a civil servant what can be done and morality what ought to be done. Empathy, the capacity to understand another's situation from within, and…
Read the model answer →
QQ2(a)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
The Rules and Regulations provided to all the civil servants are same, yet there is difference in the performance. Positive minded officers are able to interpret the Rules and Regulations in favour of the case and achieve success, whereas negative minded…
Rules are general; cases are particular. Between the two lies discretion, and how it is used depends on attitude. A positive-minded officer reads a rule through its…
Read the model answer →
QQ2(b)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
It is believed that adherence to ethics in human actions would ensure in smooth functioning of an organization/system. If so, what does ethics seek to promote in human life? How do ethical values assist in the resolution of conflicts faced by him in his…
Ethics is the systematic study of right conduct and the good life. An organisation runs smoothly when its members can trust one another to act fairly without constant…
Read the model answer →
QQ3(a)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
What does each of the following quotations mean to you? “Ethics is knowing the difference between what you have the right to do and what is right to do.” — Potter Stewart
The line, attributed to US Supreme Court Justice Potter Stewart (on the bench 1958–81), separates legality from morality. Law marks the outer boundary of what one may…
Read the model answer →

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.