Case study: You are a municipal commissioner of a large city, having the reputation of a very honest and upright officer.
Discuss asks you to lay out the ethical issues from several angles; the options and the selected course must then be explained with reasons, showing why the chosen path beats the alternatives.
Common trap: Weak answers stop at refusing the bribe. A top answer also handles the friendship with the previous commissioner as a conflict of interest, treats the POSH threat as intimidation without belittling the law, and puts the victims' relief and systemic reform alongside punishment.
SyllabusPublic/Civil service values and Ethics in Public administration: Status and problems; ethical concerns and dilemmas in government and private institutions; laws, rules, regulations and conscience as sources of ethical guidance; accountability and ethical governance; strengthening of ethical and moral values in governance.
The case
You are a municipal commissioner of a large city, having the reputation of a very honest and upright officer. A huge multipurpose mall is under construction in your city in which a large number of daily wage earners are employed. One night, during monsoons, a big chunk of the roof collapsed causing instant death of four labourers including two minors. Many more were seriously injured requiring immediate medical attention. The mishap resulted in a big hue and cry, forcing the government to institute an enquiry. Your preliminary enquiry has revealed a series of anomalies. The material used for the construction was of poor quality. Despite the approved building plans permitting only one basement, an additional basement has been constructed. This was overlooked during the periodic inspections by the building inspector of the municipal corporation. In your enquiry, you noticed that the construction of the mall was given the green signal despite encroaching on areas earmarked for a green belt and a slip road in the Zonal Master Plan of the city. The permission to construct the mall was accorded by the previous Municipal Commissioner who is not only your senior and well known to you professionally, but also a good friend. Prima facie, the case appears to be of a widespread nexus between officials of the Municipal Corporation and the builders. Your colleagues are putting pressure on you to go slow in the enquiry. The builder, who is rich and influential, happens to be a close relative of a powerful minister in the state cabinet. The builder is persuading you to hush up the matter, promising you a fortune to do so. He also hinted that if this matter is not resolved at the earliest in his favour there is somebody in his office who is waiting to file a case against you under the POSH Act. Discuss the ethical issues involved in the case. What are the options available to you in this situation? Explain your selected course of action.
Model answer
20 marks · 250-word limitFour labourers, two of them minors, died because an illegal basement, poor material and a plan that swallowed a green belt all passed municipal scrutiny. The case tests whether an honest officer's integrity survives friendship, peer pressure, inducement and threats together.
- Victims and families seeking justice
- Friendship with previous commissioner
- Colleagues urging go-slow
- Builder's bribe offer
- Minister's influence
- Threat of a false POSH case
Stakeholders
| Stakeholder | Interest / stake |
|---|---|
| Dead and injured workers, their families | Medical care, compensation, justice |
| Citizens of the city | Safe buildings, green belt and slip road as planned |
| Builder and his minister relative | Avoid liability and loss |
| Previous commissioner, inspectors | Reputation and possible culpability |
| Me, as commissioner | Integrity, personal safety, credibility of the enquiry |
(a) Ethical issues involved
- Right to life and safety: Poor material and an unapproved second basement show profit placed above workers' lives; the death of two minors raises a child-labour question the enquiry must pursue.
- Corruption and regulatory capture: An overlooked basement and a mall approved over Zonal Master Plan land point to a nexus that converts public trust into private gain.
- Conflict of interest: My friendship with the previous commissioner, who granted the permission, can colour my objectivity or be seen to.
- Inducement and intimidation: The bribe offer and the hint of a planted POSH complaint test integrity and courage, and misuse a law meant to protect women.
- Loyalty versus duty: Pressure from colleagues sets misplaced organisational loyalty against accountability to the public.
(b) Options available
| Option | Merits | Demerits |
|---|---|---|
| Hush up for money | Personal gain, no conflict with the powerful | Bribery under the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988; betrays victims |
| Go slow or seek transfer | Avoids confrontation and the friend's embarrassment | Abdication of duty; the nexus survives |
| Recuse from the friend's role only | Removes bias over that part | Alone, it leaves the wider enquiry exposed to pressure |
| Impartial, documented, time-bound enquiry | Upholds law, justice and public trust | Political backlash and personal risk |
(c) Selected course of action
- Victims first: Ensure treatment for the injured and interim relief for families; seal the site pending structural audit.
- Refuse and record: Decline the offer and put the bribe attempt and the POSH threat in writing to the Chief Secretary and the state vigilance or anti-corruption bureau.
- Handle the conflict openly: Disclose my friendship to superiors and let an independent officer examine the original approval, while I continue the rest of the enquiry.
- Fix accountability: Proceed on evidence against the builder, inspectors and officials alike; recommend demolition of the illegal basement and restoration of plan-reserved land.
- Fix the system: Propose third-party structural audits, geo-tagged online inspections and public disclosure of approved plans.
Integrity here is not only refusing money but acting with courage and transparency when friendship and power pull the other way. A clean record, written disclosures and institutional allies are the honest officer's best protection against threats, and justice to the dead workers is the measure of the enquiry.
Read more — sources
- OfficialPrevention of Corruption Act, 1988 (as amended in 2018), including the offence of giving a bribe
- OfficialSexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal) Act, 2013
- OfficialBuilding and Other Construction Workers (Regulation of Employment and Conditions of Service) Act, 1996
- ReportSecond Administrative Reforms Commission, Fourth Report: Ethics in Governance (2007)
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 4 (Ethics) 2020
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.