Data security has assumed significant importance in the digitized world due to rising cyber-crimes. The Justice B. N. Srikrishna Committee Report addresses issues related to data security. What, in your view, are the strengths and weaknesses of the Report relating to protection of personal data in cyber space?
Give your own reasoned assessment: identify the Report's real strengths and weaknesses on personal data protection and justify your view with its specific provisions.
Common trap: Generic privacy essays score poorly. Examiners look for the Report's actual design (data fiduciary, consent, DPA, localisation, penalties) and a balanced critique, especially on state exemptions and localisation.
SyllabusChallenges to internal security through communication networks, role of media and social networking sites in internal security challenges, basics of cyber security; money-laundering and its prevention.
Model answer
15 marks · 250-word limitThe Justice B.N. Srikrishna Committee, set up by MeitY in July 2017 as a nine-judge bench heard Puttaswamy (which in August 2017 held privacy a fundamental right), submitted its report, A Free and Fair Digital Economy, with a draft Personal Data Protection Bill on 27 July 2018. NCRB data showed cyber crime rising year on year.
- Data principal gives informed consent
- Data fiduciary owes a duty of care
- Purpose and storage limits; serving copy in India
- Breach notified to the Data Protection Authority
- Penalties up to Rs 15 crore or 4% of turnover
Strengths
- Rights-based fiduciary model: It treats individuals as data principals and companies as data fiduciaries who owe a duty of fair and reasonable processing, a middle path between the US market model and the EU's GDPR.
- Meaningful consent and rights: Consent must be free, informed, specific, clear and withdrawable; data principals get rights of access, correction, portability and a limited right to be forgotten.
- Higher protection for sensitive data: Health, financial, biometric, caste and religious data need explicit consent, and children's data cannot be profiled or tracked.
- Strong regulator and deterrence: A Data Protection Authority of India, breach notification where harm is likely, audits and data protection officers for significant fiduciaries, and penalties up to Rs 15 crore or 4% of worldwide turnover, whichever is higher.
Weaknesses
- Wide state exemptions: Processing for state security and crime prevention is exempt from most obligations if authorised by law, while the report itself noted that intelligence surveillance lacks independent oversight and left reform outside the Bill.
- Data localisation: A serving copy of all personal data must stay in India and critical personal data may be processed only here, raising compliance costs for start-ups and trade friction without clear security gains.
- Regulator independence: The DPA's members are appointed by the central government and much is left to rules, which may weaken its autonomy.
- Limited scope: The right to be forgotten only restricts disclosure rather than erasing data, and the proposed amendment to Section 8(1)(j) of the RTI Act could curb transparency.
- Since then: The 2019 Bill was withdrawn in 2022 and replaced by the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023, which dropped strict localisation but kept broad state exemptions.
The Report gave India a sound rights-based architecture for data protection. Its credibility, however, depends on parliamentary and judicial oversight of state surveillance, a genuinely autonomous regulator and proportionate localisation, so that privacy protection does not become a gateway to new state power.
Read more — sources
- ReportCommittee of Experts under Justice B.N. Srikrishna — A Free and Fair Digital Economy: Protecting Privacy, Empowering Indians (MeitY, 2018)
- OfficialDraft Personal Data Protection Bill, 2018
- OfficialSupreme Court of India, Justice K.S. Puttaswamy (Retd.) v. Union of India (2017)
- OfficialNCRB — Crime in India 2016
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 3 2018
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.