With growing energy needs should India keep on expanding its nuclear energy programme? Discuss the facts and fears associated with nuclear energy.
Weigh the case for and against further expansion, then separate evidence-based facts from popular fears and reach a reasoned position.
Common trap: Weak answers either cheerlead or list Fukushima-style fears. A top answer quantifies nuclear's small present share, tests each fear against evidence (safety record, waste, cost, liability) and ends with a conditional yes.
SyllabusInfrastructure: Energy, Ports, Roads, Airports, Railways etc.
Model answer
15 marks · 250-word limitIn 2018 India's 22 operating reactors had an installed capacity of 6,780 MW, supplying only about 3% of its electricity. With low per-capita power use and a Paris pledge of 40% non-fossil capacity by 2030, the question is how, not whether, it should grow.
- Near-zero carbon, 24x7 baseload
- High capacity factor, small land footprint
- Three-stage plan to use thorium
- Indigenous 700 MW PHWR design
- Accidents: Chernobyl 1986, Fukushima 2011
- Long-lived radioactive waste
- High cost, long delays
- Displacement and local opposition
Why India should keep expanding
- Climate and baseload: IPCC AR5 puts nuclear's median life-cycle emissions at about 12 g CO2-eq per kWh against about 820 g for coal, and unlike solar and wind it runs round the clock.
- Energy security: Homi Bhabha's three-stage programme (PHWRs, fast breeders, thorium reactors) is designed to tap India's large thorium reserves; the 500 MW Prototype Fast Breeder Reactor at Kalpakkam is under construction.
- Fuel and technology access: The 2008 NSG waiver ended isolation; uranium imports from Kazakhstan, Canada and Russia eased the fuel shortage that once kept reactors under-loaded.
- Fleet mode: In May 2017 the Cabinet approved ten indigenous 700 MW PHWRs in fleet mode, boosting domestic industry.
Facts and fears examined
| Fear | Fact / response |
|---|---|
| Safety | No accident with off-site radiation release in over four decades of operation; post-Fukushima stress tests added backup cooling and power |
| Waste | India follows a closed fuel cycle, reprocessing spent fuel so that high-level waste volumes are small, though no deep geological repository exists yet |
| Cost and delay | Real: Kudankulam and the PFBR ran years late; imported reactors at Jaitapur (EDF) and Kovvada (Westinghouse) are stalled over price |
| Liability | Section 17(b) of the Civil Liability for Nuclear Damage Act, 2010 deters foreign suppliers; the India Nuclear Insurance Pool (2015) and CSC ratification (2016) only partly reassure |
| Local consent | Kudankulam protests (2011-12) ended with the Supreme Court upholding the plant in G. Sundarrajan (2013) subject to safety directions |
What must accompany expansion
- Independent regulator: The AERB reports to the Atomic Energy Commission, which also runs the programme; the lapsed Nuclear Safety Regulatory Authority Bill, 2011 needs revival.
- Transparency: Publish safety reviews and emergency plans to win local trust.
- Since then: Budget 2025-26 set a 100 GW by 2047 goal; the SHANTI Act, 2025 replaced the 1962 and 2010 Acts, opened licences to companies and made the AERB statutory; the PFBR went critical in April 2026.
India should keep expanding nuclear power, but as a steady, safety-first complement to renewables rather than a substitute. An independent regulator, honest public engagement and a workable liability regime will decide whether the fears fade or harden.
Read more — sources
- OfficialDepartment of Atomic Energy and NPCIL — annual reports and Parliament replies, 2017-18
- ReportIPCC Fifth Assessment Report (2014), Working Group III, Annex III — life-cycle emissions of electricity technologies
- OfficialCivil Liability for Nuclear Damage Act, 2010
- OfficialSupreme Court of India, G. Sundarrajan v. Union of India (2013)
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 3 2018
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.