Case study: Edward Snowden, a computer expert and former CIA systems administrator, released confidential Government documents to the press about the existence…
Take a clear position on whether the act was ethically justified, support it by weighing the competing values on both sides, and acknowledge the strongest counter-arguments before concluding.
Common trap: Many answers simply praise or condemn Snowden. A top answer separates the end (exposing unlawful surveillance) from the means (scale of disclosure, evading trial) and takes a reasoned, qualified position anchored in a principle such as civil disobedience or proportionality.
SyllabusCase Studies on above issues. (Public/Civil service values and Ethics in Public administration: ethical concerns and dilemmas in government and private institutions; laws, rules, regulations and conscience as sources of ethical guidance; accountability and ethical governance.)
The case
Edward Snowden, a computer expert and former CIA systems administrator, released confidential Government documents to the press about the existence of Government surveillance programmes. According to many legal experts and the US Government, his actions violated the Espionage Act of 1917, which identified the leak of State secrets as an act of treason. Yet, despite the fact that he broke the law, Snowden argued that he had a moral obligation to act. He gave a justification for his “whistle blowing” by stating that he had a duty “to inform the public as to that which is done in their name and that which is done against them.” According to Snowden, the Government’s violation of privacy had to be exposed regardless of legality since more substantive issues of social action and public morality were involved here. Many agreed with Snowden. Few argued that he broke the law and compromised national security, for which he should be held accountable. Do you agree that Snowden’s actions were ethically justified even if legally prohibited? Why or why not? Make an argument by weighing the competing values in this case.
Model answer
20 marks · 250-word limitIn June 2013 Edward Snowden gave journalists at The Guardian and The Washington Post documents revealing that the US National Security Agency was collecting the telephone records of millions of Americans in bulk. The case asks whether conscience can justify breaking a law in order to expose a wrong done by the state itself.
- Right to privacy
- Public right to know
- Democratic accountability
- National security
- Rule of law
- Oath of confidentiality
- Conscience and duty
Arguments that the act was ethically justified
- Wrong later confirmed: In ACLU v Clapper (2015) a US appeals court held that the bulk phone-records programme was not authorised by Section 215 of the Patriot Act, and Congress ended it through the USA FREEDOM Act, 2015.
- Publicity principle: Kant argued that a policy affecting others' rights which cannot survive being made public is unjust; secret mass surveillance fails that test.
- Consent of the governed: Citizens cannot hold a government accountable for what is done in their name if they cannot know of it.
- Privacy as a core right: India's Supreme Court in Puttaswamy (2017) likewise made privacy a fundamental right, limited only by legality, necessity and proportionality.
Arguments against
- Rule of law: An official who decides alone which secrets to reveal sets a precedent that anyone can claim conscience to override law.
- Scale and method: Critics, including US officials, argued that the leaks went beyond domestic surveillance to foreign intelligence operations, risking security and allies.
- Accountability: Charged under the Espionage Act in June 2013, he stayed beyond reach in Russia; in the tradition of Gandhi's satyagraha and Rawls's account of civil disobedience, conscientious law-breaking is open and accepts the penalty, as Daniel Ellsberg did by surrendering to stand trial after leaking the Pentagon Papers in 1971.
Weighing the values: my assessment
- Ends justified: Exposing unlawful mass surveillance of one's own citizens served a public interest greater than the duty of secrecy, so the core disclosure was ethically defensible.
- Means partly unjustified: Indiscriminate release and avoidance of trial weaken the moral claim; disclosure should be the minimum needed to expose the wrong.
- Lesson for institutions: Strong, safe internal and legislative channels for whistle-blowers make such dilemmas rarer.
Yes, the central act of revealing unlawful surveillance was ethically justified, because legality cannot be the final test of morality when the law itself is being broken in secret. But justified disobedience must be proportionate and accountable; conscience earns its authority by accepting, not evading, the consequences.
Read more — sources
- OfficialUS Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, ACLU v Clapper (2015)
- OfficialSupreme Court of India, Justice K.S. Puttaswamy (Retd.) v Union of India (2017)
- BookJohn Rawls, A Theory of Justice — chapter on civil disobedience
- BookImmanuel Kant, Perpetual Peace — Appendix II, on the transcendental formula of public right
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 4 (Ethics) 2018
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.