With regard to morality of actions, one view is that means are of paramount importance and the other view is that the ends justify the means. Which view do you think is more appropriate? Justify your answer.
Take a clear position on which view is more appropriate and defend it with reasons and examples, while showing you have weighed the opposing view.
Common trap: Weak answers simply declare that means matter and quote Gandhi. A top answer states both positions fairly, shows why consequences cannot be ignored in policy, and then argues that ethical means set the limits within which good ends may be pursued.
SyllabusContributions of moral thinkers and philosophers from India and world.
Model answer
10 marks · 150-word limitThe debate is between deontology, which judges an act by its conformity to duty, and consequentialism, which judges it by its outcomes. Gandhi held that means and ends are as inseparable as seed and tree, while the slogan that ends justify means is popularly linked to Machiavelli's The Prince.
- Kant: duty, not outcome
- Persons never merely means
- Gandhi: pure means, pure ends
- Protects rights and rule of law
- Bentham, Mill: judge by results
- Greatest good of greatest number
- Machiavellian statecraft
- Risks abuse of power
Case for the ends
- Results matter in policy: Bentham and Mill judged an act right if it maximises welfare; an officer allocating scarce funds must weigh outcomes.
- Rigid rules can fail: Holding back flood relief until every document is verified honours procedure but defeats the purpose of the scheme.
Why means must come first
- Bad means corrupt the end: Forced sterilisations during the Emergency (1975-77) were defended as population control yet discredited family planning for years.
- Rule of law: Fake encounters are defended as quick justice; in PUCL v State of Maharashtra (2014) the Supreme Court laid down mandatory procedures for every police encounter death.
- Human dignity: Kant held that persons must always be treated as ends in themselves, never merely as means, which Article 21 also protects.
Assessment
- Means as limits, ends as direction: Good ends give purpose, but only lawful, honest and humane means are permissible routes to them.
- Gandhian practice: Gandhi called off the Non-Cooperation Movement after the violence at Chauri Chaura in 1922 rather than win freedom through violent means.
The view that means are paramount is more appropriate for a public servant, because the state's legitimacy rests on how it acts, not only on what it achieves. Ends should guide choice among ethical means, never license unethical ones.
Read more — sources
- BookM.K. Gandhi, Hind Swaraj (1909) — chapter on brute force
- BookImmanuel Kant, Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals (1785)
- BookJ.S. Mill, Utilitarianism (1861)
- OfficialSupreme Court of India, PUCL v State of Maharashtra (2014) — guidelines on police encounters
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 4 (Ethics) 2018
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.