Case study: Rakesh is a responsible district level officer, who enjoys the trust of his higher officials.
Lay out the ethical dilemma, weigh the realistic options and recommend a concrete, justified course of action for the officer.
Common trap: Weak answers either grant the aid out of sympathy or reject it coldly. A top answer refuses to bend criterion (b) yet actively finds other lawful routes for the couple and flags the policy gap through proper channels.
SyllabusAptitude and foundational values for Civil Service, integrity, impartiality and non-partisanship, objectivity, dedication to public service, empathy, tolerance and compassion towards the weaker sections.
The case
Rakesh is a responsible district level officer, who enjoys the trust of his higher officials. Knowing his honesty, the government entrusted him with the responsibility of identifying the beneficiaries under a healthcare scheme meant for senior citizens. The criteria to be a beneficiary are the following: (a) 60 years of age or above. (b) Belonging to a reserved community. (c) Family income of less than ₹ 1 lakh per annum. (d) Post-treatment prognosis is likely to be high to make a positive difference to the quality of life of the beneficiary. One day, an old couple visited Rakesh’s office with their application. They have been the residents of a village in his district since their birth. The old man is diagnosed with a rare condition that causes obstruction in the large intestine. As a consequence, he has severe abdominal pain frequently that prevents him from doing any physical labour. The couple have no children to support them. The expert surgeon whom they contacted is willing to do the surgery without charging any fee. However, the couple will have to bear the cost of incidental charges, such as medicines, hospitalization, etc., to the tune of ₹ 1 lakh. The couple fulfills all the criteria except criterion ‘b’. However, any financial aid would certainly make a significant difference in their quality of life. How should Rakesh respond to the situation?
Model answer
20 marks · 250-word limitRakesh faces a classic clash between rule-bound duty and compassion. A targeted scheme draws its legitimacy from its criteria, yet Article 41 of the Constitution asks the State to provide public assistance in old age and sickness. The right response keeps the rules intact without abandoning the couple.
- Verify the application honestly
- Record ineligibility under criterion (b)
- Link couple to other health and relief funds
- Mobilise hospital, NGO and CSR support
- Flag the criteria gap to superiors
Stakeholders
| Stakeholder | Interest/stake |
|---|---|
| The old couple | Urgent treatment, relief from pain and dignity in old age without any family support |
| Rakesh | Integrity, the trust of his superiors and his own conscience |
| Eligible beneficiaries | Fair access to a limited fund meant for reserved communities |
| Government | Credibility of targeting and proper use of public money |
| Expert surgeon | His free service should not go waste for want of incidental funds |
Ethical issues involved
- Rule of law versus compassion: Bending criterion (b) would be an abuse of discretion, while a cold rejection would ignore genuine distress.
- Distributive justice: Reservation-based targeting reflects Article 46, which directs the State to promote the interests of weaker sections, especially SCs and STs; diverting funds would hurt them.
- Integrity and trust: Rakesh was chosen for his honesty, so one exception would weaken the scheme and invite others.
- Need-based justice: Rawls's difference principle favours the least advantaged, and this couple is clearly among them.
Options available
| Option | Merits | Demerits |
|---|---|---|
| Approve the aid by relaxing criterion (b) | Immediate relief to the couple | Illegal, unfair to eligible applicants, sets a precedent |
| Reject and close the file | Follows the rules strictly | Mechanical, lacks empathy, couple left to suffer |
| Reject under this scheme but arrange help elsewhere | Lawful and humane; uses the full system | Needs extra effort and time from Rakesh |
How Rakesh should respond
- Decide fairly and transparently: Record that the couple meet criteria (a), (c) and (d) but not (b), and explain this to them politely.
- Explore other public avenues: Check their eligibility under other state or central health assistance schemes, the Chief Minister's relief fund and the Prime Minister's National Relief Fund, and help them fill the forms.
- Mobilise local support: Request the hospital, the surgeon's team, Red Cross units, NGOs and CSR funds to cover the medicines and hospital stay.
- Use proper channels for gaps: Send a reasoned note to superiors suggesting that aged, destitute patients outside reserved communities be covered under some other window, without demanding an exception for this case.
- Follow up: Track the case until treatment is complete, reflecting Gandhi's talisman of recalling the poorest person before acting.
Ethical administration is not a choice between rules and mercy. Rakesh should keep the scheme's criteria intact, but use his position to open every lawful door for the couple, showing that integrity and compassion strengthen each other.
Read more — sources
- OfficialConstitution of India — Articles 41 and 46 (Directive Principles of State Policy)
- ReportSecond Administrative Reforms Commission, 4th Report: Ethics in Governance (2007)
- BookJohn Rawls, A Theory of Justice (1971)
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 4 (Ethics) 2018
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.