EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2019EssayTopic 3 · 125 marksModel answer

Best for an individual is not necessarily best for the society.

DirectiveEssay
Marks125
Word limit1000–1200
PaperEssay
What the examiner wants

1000–1200 words, 125 marks. One topic from each Section. A philosophical topic is graded on interpretation, structure and range of illustration — not on reaching a particular conclusion. Declare your reading early and sustain it.

Common trap: Most candidates write about selfishness. A top essay uses the precise logic of collective-action problems — tragedy of the commons, the prisoner's dilemma, externalities — with vivid Indian cases such as stubble burning and groundwater depletion, then balances it: individual freedom and enterprise often do benefit society, and the task is to align the two through institutions, not to suppress the individual.

Essay brief

1000–1200 words · 125 marks
Ways to read the topic
  • Collective-action reading: individually rational choices can produce collectively harmful outcomes — the tragedy of the commons.
  • Ethical reading: personal gain at others' expense — corruption, tax evasion, pollution — is a failure of civic virtue.
  • Liberal counter-reading: individual freedom and self-interest often create social good, as Adam Smith argued; society should not override the individual lightly.
  • Alignment reading — the strongest: the gap between individual and social good is real but bridgeable, through law, incentives, norms and enlightened self-interest.
Dimensions to cover

The logic of the gap

  • Tragedy of the commons: each herder adds one more animal, and the pasture collapses
  • Externalities: the polluter gains, society pays
  • Free-rider problem in public goods such as vaccination and clean air

Indian illustrations

  • Stubble burning: cheapest for the farmer, smog for north India
  • Free electricity and groundwater pumping in Punjab and elsewhere depleting aquifers
  • Private vehicles, congestion and urban air pollution

Economy and markets

  • Profit-maximising choices can cause financial crises or environmental damage
  • Tax evasion is individually rational and socially corrosive
  • Antibiotic overuse: individual relief, collective drug resistance

Where individual good is social good

  • Adam Smith's invisible hand: enterprise creates jobs and wealth
  • Innovation by individuals — inventors and entrepreneurs — benefits all
  • Education and health of each person raise society's capacity

Aligning the two

  • Mill's harm principle: liberty limited only to prevent harm to others
  • Pigouvian taxes, regulation, community institutions — Ostrom's design principles for the commons
  • Gandhian trusteeship and constitutional duties as moral alignment

The counter-view

  • "Best for society" has been used to crush individuals — forced sterilisation during the Emergency
  • Majorities can define social good in oppressive ways
  • Answer: social good must respect rights; alignment, not subordination
Structure

Opening. Open with a Punjab farmer setting stubble alight — the cheapest choice for him, a health emergency for Delhi — to make the gap concrete.

Body. Explain the logic of collective-action problems, illustrate with Indian and global cases, then give a full section to where individual and social good coincide.

Counter-view. Warn against the opposite error — sacrificing individuals for a "social good" defined by power, as in forced sterilisation — and insist on rights.

Conclusion. Close with institutions and values that align the two, returning to the farmer now offered a happy seeder or a crop-residue market.

Examples to use
  • Stubble burning in Punjab and Haryana and winter smog in Delhi — A textbook externality in the Indian context
  • Groundwater depletion linked to free or subsidised farm power — Individually rational pumping draining a shared aquifer
  • Garrett Hardin's "The Tragedy of the Commons" (1968) and Elinor Ostrom's Nobel-winning work on governing the commons — The theory and its solution
  • Herd immunity and vaccine hesitancy — Individual choice with social consequences
  • Forced sterilisation during the Emergency (1975–77) — The danger of overriding individuals for a supposed social good
  • Antimicrobial resistance from antibiotic overuse — Individual benefit creating a collective threat
Quotes
  • “It is not from the benevolence of the butcher, the brewer, or the baker that we expect our dinner, but from their regard to their own interest.” — Adam Smith, The Wealth of Nations
  • “The only purpose for which power can be rightfully exercised over any member of a civilized community, against his will, is to prevent harm to others.” — John Stuart Mill, On Liberty
Pitfalls
  • Turning the essay into a sermon against selfishness without explaining the logic of collective action
  • Ignoring the cases where individual pursuit benefits society, which makes the essay one-sided
  • Concluding that society should always override the individual, which conflicts with constitutional rights

More from Essay 2019

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.