Neglect of primary health care and education in India are reasons for its backwardness.
1000–1200 words, 125 marks. One topic from each Section. A contemporary topic is graded on the balance of argument, the range of real evidence and the quality of the way forward — not on reaching a particular conclusion. Frame the problem early and keep every paragraph tied to it.
Common trap: The danger is a GS-2 answer listing schemes. A top essay argues causation — how weak primary health and schooling depress productivity, perpetuate poverty and inequality, and blunt the demographic dividend — compares India with East Asia, Sri Lanka and Kerala, and also tests the claim: neglect is a major reason but not the only one, and "backwardness" itself is uneven.
Essay brief
1000–1200 words · 125 marks- Human-capital reading: health and education are the foundations of productivity; neglecting them caps growth and keeps India behind.
- Comparative reading: East Asian economies and Kerala invested early in primary health and education and reaped broad-based development.
- Capability reading — the strongest: following Amartya Sen, development is the expansion of capabilities, so neglect of health and education is not just a cause of backwardness but backwardness itself.
- Qualified reading: neglect matters greatly, but governance, infrastructure, social hierarchy and policy choices also explain India's lag.
How the neglect causes backwardness
- Malnutrition and stunting reduce cognitive ability and lifetime earnings
- Poor foundational learning leaves youth unemployable despite degrees
- High out-of-pocket health spending pushes families into poverty
The state of primary health care
- Public health spending well below the 2.5% of GDP target set by the National Health Policy 2017
- Shortages of doctors and staff in rural primary health centres
- Ayushman Bharat (2018): health and wellness centres and insurance as responses
The state of primary education
- Near-universal enrolment but weak learning outcomes (ASER reports)
- Teacher absenteeism and shortages, poor infrastructure
- RTE Act (2009) achieved access more than quality
Lessons from others
- East Asian economies built mass literacy and health before industrialisation
- Sri Lanka and Bangladesh achieving better social indicators at lower incomes
- Kerala's early investment in schooling and health
Equity and the demographic dividend
- Neglect hits girls, Dalits, Adivasis and the rural poor hardest
- A young population becomes a burden without health and skills
- Women's education linked to lower fertility and better child health
The counter-view
- Other factors matter: infrastructure, governance, land, labour laws, global conditions
- India has made real gains — polio elimination, enrolment, falling maternal mortality
- Answer: neglect is a central, not sole, cause; priority must shift to quality and primary levels
Opening. Open with a child in a rural school who can read a textbook's title but not a simple paragraph, and whose family borrowed for a hospital bill — two neglects, one future.
Body. Show the causal chain from neglect to backwardness, diagnose primary health and education separately, then compare with East Asia, Sri Lanka and Kerala and draw out equity effects.
Counter-view. Acknowledge other causes of backwardness and real Indian achievements, then argue neglect remains the most fixable and highest-return lever.
Conclusion. Close with a vision of public investment in primary health and foundational learning as the base of a developed India, returning to the child.
- ASER reports on learning outcomes in rural India — Gap between enrolment and learning
- NFHS data on child stunting and anaemia — Health neglect undermining human capital
- National Health Policy 2017 target of public health spending at 2.5% of GDP — Benchmark for chronic under-investment
- Ayushman Bharat (2018): Health and Wellness Centres and PM-JAY — Recent attempt to strengthen primary and secondary care
- Kerala's social development record — Early investment in health and education producing high human development
- Jean Drèze and Amartya Sen, An Uncertain Glory (2013) — Scholarly argument that India neglected social investment relative to its growth
- Alma-Ata Declaration (1978) on primary health care — The global consensus India has struggled to implement
- “Education is the most powerful weapon which you can use to change the world.” — Nelson Mandela
- Listing schemes and statistics without a causal argument
- Ignoring the distinction between access and quality, which is the core of the education problem
- Overstating the claim — treating neglect as the only cause of backwardness
More from Essay 2019
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.