South Asian societies are woven not around the state, but around their plural cultures and plural identities.
1000–1200 words, 125 marks. One topic from each Section. A contemporary topic is graded on the balance of argument, the range of real evidence and the quality of the way forward — not on reaching a particular conclusion. Frame the problem early and keep every paragraph tied to it.
Common trap: This is the hardest topic of the year, and most candidates turn it into an India-only unity-in-diversity essay. A top essay works at the South Asian scale — Bangladesh's language movement, Sri Lanka's civil war, Nepal's federal debates, shared Sufi and Bhakti traditions — and makes an argument about state versus society: where states respected plurality they held together, where they imposed a single identity they fractured.
Essay brief
1000–1200 words · 125 marks- Historical reading: South Asian societies existed long before modern states; their cohesion came from shared cultures, religions, languages and trade networks.
- State-failure reading: where states tried to impose one identity — language, religion — societies resisted, as in East Pakistan and Sri Lanka.
- Cross-border reading: plural identities transcend state borders — Punjabi, Bengali, Tamil, Buddhist and Sufi communities span nations.
- Synthesis reading — the strongest: the state is a recent frame over an older plural fabric; stable South Asian states are those that accommodate plurality rather than override it.
A society older than the state
- Village communities, caste, kinship and religious networks organised life before modern states
- Shared epics, Buddhism, Sufism, Bhakti and syncretic shrines
- Colonial borders cut across older cultural regions
When states imposed one identity
- Urdu imposed on East Pakistan — the 1952 Language Movement and Bangladesh's birth in 1971
- Sri Lanka's Sinhala Only Act (1956) and decades of civil war
- Madhesi protests over Nepal's 2015 constitution
When states accommodated plurality
- India's linguistic reorganisation of states (1956) defused separatism
- Federalism, Sixth Schedule and minority rights in the Indian Constitution
- Sri Lanka's 13th Amendment (1987) on provincial devolution as a partial, contested attempt
Cross-border identities
- Bengali culture spanning India and Bangladesh; Punjabi culture spanning India and Pakistan
- Buddhist circuit, Kartarpur Corridor and shared pilgrimages
- Cricket, cinema and music as South Asian common culture
Regional cooperation
- SAARC's weakness reflects state rivalries, not societal distance
- People-to-people ties often stronger than state relations
- Culture as a basis for regional integration
The counter-view
- States matter: security, welfare and rights depend on effective states
- Plural identities can turn into ethnic conflict and fragmentation
- Answer: the ideal is a state that protects plurality — constitutional pluralism
Opening. Open with 21 February 1952, when students in Dhaka died defending Bengali — now International Mother Language Day — to show identity outlasting the state that tried to override it.
Body. Show the plural fabric that predates states, then contrast states that imposed a single identity with those that accommodated plurality, and highlight cross-border identities.
Counter-view. Concede that effective states are essential and that identity politics can fragment societies; argue for a state that protects plurality.
Conclusion. Close on South Asia's shared civilisational fabric as the foundation for peace and regional cooperation, returning to the Language Movement.
- Bengali Language Movement (1952) and UNESCO's International Mother Language Day on 21 February — Identity defeating state imposition
- Sri Lanka's Sinhala Only Act (1956) and the civil war that ended in 2009 — Cost of majoritarian state-building
- States Reorganisation Act (1956) in India — Accommodation of linguistic plurality strengthening the state
- Kartarpur Corridor between India and Pakistan (opened in November 2019, shortly after this exam) — Shared faith transcending hostile borders — cite as a later confirmation
- Nepal's 2015 constitution and Madhesi protests — Contest over inclusive identity in a new state
- Sufi shrines such as Ajmer Sharif and Data Darbar drawing devotees across faiths — Syncretic culture as social glue
- “Ekam sat vipra bahudha vadanti — truth is one, the wise call it by many names.” — Rig Veda
- Writing only about India and ignoring the rest of South Asia
- Romanticising plurality and ignoring ethnic and communal conflict
- Dismissing the state entirely, when the real argument is about what kind of state works
More from Essay 2019
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.