EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2019EssayTopic 5 · 125 marksModel answer

South Asian societies are woven not around the state, but around their plural cultures and plural identities.

DirectiveEssay
Marks125
Word limit1000–1200
PaperEssay
What the examiner wants

1000–1200 words, 125 marks. One topic from each Section. A contemporary topic is graded on the balance of argument, the range of real evidence and the quality of the way forward — not on reaching a particular conclusion. Frame the problem early and keep every paragraph tied to it.

Common trap: This is the hardest topic of the year, and most candidates turn it into an India-only unity-in-diversity essay. A top essay works at the South Asian scale — Bangladesh's language movement, Sri Lanka's civil war, Nepal's federal debates, shared Sufi and Bhakti traditions — and makes an argument about state versus society: where states respected plurality they held together, where they imposed a single identity they fractured.

Essay brief

1000–1200 words · 125 marks
Ways to read the topic
  • Historical reading: South Asian societies existed long before modern states; their cohesion came from shared cultures, religions, languages and trade networks.
  • State-failure reading: where states tried to impose one identity — language, religion — societies resisted, as in East Pakistan and Sri Lanka.
  • Cross-border reading: plural identities transcend state borders — Punjabi, Bengali, Tamil, Buddhist and Sufi communities span nations.
  • Synthesis reading — the strongest: the state is a recent frame over an older plural fabric; stable South Asian states are those that accommodate plurality rather than override it.
Dimensions to cover

A society older than the state

  • Village communities, caste, kinship and religious networks organised life before modern states
  • Shared epics, Buddhism, Sufism, Bhakti and syncretic shrines
  • Colonial borders cut across older cultural regions

When states imposed one identity

  • Urdu imposed on East Pakistan — the 1952 Language Movement and Bangladesh's birth in 1971
  • Sri Lanka's Sinhala Only Act (1956) and decades of civil war
  • Madhesi protests over Nepal's 2015 constitution

When states accommodated plurality

  • India's linguistic reorganisation of states (1956) defused separatism
  • Federalism, Sixth Schedule and minority rights in the Indian Constitution
  • Sri Lanka's 13th Amendment (1987) on provincial devolution as a partial, contested attempt

Cross-border identities

  • Bengali culture spanning India and Bangladesh; Punjabi culture spanning India and Pakistan
  • Buddhist circuit, Kartarpur Corridor and shared pilgrimages
  • Cricket, cinema and music as South Asian common culture

Regional cooperation

  • SAARC's weakness reflects state rivalries, not societal distance
  • People-to-people ties often stronger than state relations
  • Culture as a basis for regional integration

The counter-view

  • States matter: security, welfare and rights depend on effective states
  • Plural identities can turn into ethnic conflict and fragmentation
  • Answer: the ideal is a state that protects plurality — constitutional pluralism
Structure

Opening. Open with 21 February 1952, when students in Dhaka died defending Bengali — now International Mother Language Day — to show identity outlasting the state that tried to override it.

Body. Show the plural fabric that predates states, then contrast states that imposed a single identity with those that accommodated plurality, and highlight cross-border identities.

Counter-view. Concede that effective states are essential and that identity politics can fragment societies; argue for a state that protects plurality.

Conclusion. Close on South Asia's shared civilisational fabric as the foundation for peace and regional cooperation, returning to the Language Movement.

Examples to use
  • Bengali Language Movement (1952) and UNESCO's International Mother Language Day on 21 February — Identity defeating state imposition
  • Sri Lanka's Sinhala Only Act (1956) and the civil war that ended in 2009 — Cost of majoritarian state-building
  • States Reorganisation Act (1956) in India — Accommodation of linguistic plurality strengthening the state
  • Kartarpur Corridor between India and Pakistan (opened in November 2019, shortly after this exam) — Shared faith transcending hostile borders — cite as a later confirmation
  • Nepal's 2015 constitution and Madhesi protests — Contest over inclusive identity in a new state
  • Sufi shrines such as Ajmer Sharif and Data Darbar drawing devotees across faiths — Syncretic culture as social glue
Quotes
  • “Ekam sat vipra bahudha vadanti — truth is one, the wise call it by many names.” — Rig Veda
Pitfalls
  • Writing only about India and ignoring the rest of South Asia
  • Romanticising plurality and ignoring ethnic and communal conflict
  • Dismissing the state entirely, when the real argument is about what kind of state works

More from Essay 2019

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.