EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2022GS Paper 4 (Ethics)QQ7 (Case Study) · 20 marksCase StudyModel answer

Case study: Prabhat was working as Vice President (Marketing) at Sterling Electric Ltd., a reputed multinational company.

DirectiveDiscuss / Critically examine
Marks20
Word limit250
PaperGS Paper 4 (Ethics)
What the examiner wants

Part (a) wants every ethical issue named and explained; part (b) wants each option weighed for merits and demerits; part (c) wants one reasoned choice with concrete steps.

Common trap: Most answers stop at refusing the documents. A top answer also rejects hiring Subhash, sees the national-security and procurement angle of a secret Defence tender, reports the leak, and addresses Prabhat's personal finances realistically.

SyllabusPublic/Civil service values and Ethics in Public administration: Status and problems; ethical concerns and dilemmas in government and private institutions; laws, rules, regulations and conscience as sources of ethical guidance; accountability and ethical governance; strengthening of ethical and moral values in governance; ethical issues in international relations and funding; corporate governance.

The case

Prabhat was working as Vice President (Marketing) at Sterling Electric Ltd., a reputed multinational company. But presently the company was passing through the difficult times as the sales were continuously showing downward trend in the last two quarters. His division, which hitherto had been a major revenue contributor to the company’s financial health, was now desperately trying to procure some big government order for them. But their best efforts did not yield any positive success or breakthrough. His was a professional company and his local bosses were under pressure from their London-based HO to show some positive results. In the last performance review meeting taken by the Executive Director (India Head), he was reprimanded for his poor performance. He assured them that his division is working on a special contract from the Ministry of Defence for a secret installation near Gwalior and tender is being submitted shortly. He was under extreme pressure and he was deeply perturbed. What aggravated the situation further was a warning from the top that if the deal is not clinched in favour of the company, his division might have to be closed and he may have to quit his lucrative job. There was another dimension which was causing him deep mental torture and agony. This pertained to his personal precarious financial health. He was a single earner in the family with two school-college going children and his old ailing mother. The heavy expenditure on education and medical was causing a big strain to his monthly pay packet. Regular EMI for housing loan taken from bank was unavoidable and any default would render him liable for severe legal action. In the above backdrop, he was hoping for some miracle to happen. There was sudden turn of events. His secretary informed that a gentleman—Subhash Verma wanted to see him as he was interested in the position of Manager which was to be filled in by him in the company. He further brought to his notice that his CV has been received through the office of the Minister of Defence. During interview of the candidate—Subhash Verma, he found him technically sound, resourceful and experienced marketeer. He seemed to be well-conversant with tendering procedures and having knack of follow-up and liaising in this regard. Prabhat felt that he was better choice than the rest of the candidates who were recently interviewed by him in the last few days. Subhash Verma also indicated that he was in possession of the copies of the bid documents that the Unique Electronics Ltd. would be submitting the next day to the Defence Ministry for their tender. He offered to hand over those documents subject to his employment in the company on suitable terms and conditions. He made it clear that in the process, the Sterling Electric Ltd. could outbid their rival company and get the bid and hefty Defence Ministry order. He indicated that it will be win-win situation for both—him and the company. Prabhat was absolutely stunned. It was a mixed feeling of shock and thrill. He was uncomfortable and perspiring. If accepted, all his problems would vanish instantly and he may be rewarded for securing the much awaited tender and thereby boosting company’s sales and financial health. He was in a fix as to the future course of action. He was wonder-struck at the guts of Subhash Verma in having surreptitiously removing his own company papers and offering to the rival company for a job. Being an experienced person, he was examining the pros and cons of the proposal/situation and he asked him to come the next day. (a) Discuss the ethical issues involved in the case. (b) Critically examine the options available to Prabhat in the above situation. (c) Which of the above would be the most appropriate for Prabhat and why?

Model answer

20 marks · 250-word limit

Prabhat's crisis tests whether integrity survives when career, family and company all point to the same shortcut. A rival's bid documents offered in exchange for a job are not a business opportunity but industrial espionage in a Defence Ministry tender for a secret installation near Gwalior.

Accept the stolen bid
  • Tender won, job saved for now
  • Criminal and blacklisting risk
  • Defence procurement rigged
  • Hostage to Subhash for life
vs
Refuse and report
  • Tender and division may be lost
  • Conscience and reputation intact
  • Fair, secure procurement protected
  • Credibility with HO and Ministry
The two paths before Prabhat

(a) Ethical issues involved

  • Integrity versus personal need: As single earner facing school-college fees, his ailing mother's medical bills and a housing-loan EMI, Prabhat is tempted; need explains temptation but cannot justify wrongful means.
  • Results at any cost: The London HO's pressure, the Executive Director's reprimand and the threat of closure breed what Gandhi called commerce without morality.
  • Theft and breach of trust: Subhash surreptitiously removed his own company's papers; using them would make Sterling complicit in the theft and in a criminal conspiracy under IPC s.120B.
  • Fairness and security of public procurement: A rigged Defence tender cheats the exchequer and an honest bidder; leaked papers of a secret installation are a security concern.
  • Undue influence: A CV routed through the Defence Minister's office hints at patronage, a conflict of interest that could taint the whole tender.

(b) Options available to Prabhat

OptionMeritsDemerits
1. Take the documents and hire SubhashTender likely won; job, division and EMIs savedIllegal; prosecution, blacklisting, blackmail; one who betrays an employer will betray the next
2. Hire him on merit, refuse the documentsGains a technically sound, resourceful marketeerHe has shown he lacks integrity; the Minister-office referral looks like quid pro quo
3. Refuse quietly and say nothingPrabhat stays personally cleanLeak of secret-project bid papers goes unreported
4. Refuse, report to management, alert the MinistryLawful; protects fair competition, security and the company nameTender may still be lost; possible displeasure of influential patrons

(c) Most appropriate course and why

  • Choose option 4: When Subhash returns, decline both the documents and his candidature, and record the meeting.
  • Make it a company decision: Brief the Executive Director (India Head) and the legal team in writing.
  • Alert the buyer: Through the company, inform the Defence Ministry's vigilance channel and Unique Electronics that the bid papers are compromised, in the spirit of the integrity pact bidders sign in defence procurement.
  • Compete on merit: Sharpen Sterling's own bid on price, technology and service.
  • Why: By Kant's test of universalisability, if every bidder stole rival bids, tendering would collapse; a win built on theft invites blacklisting and blackmail. His family is better served by asking the bank to restructure his EMI than by a crime.

Prabhat's real asset is his credibility. Saying no may cost a contract, but it protects the company, the Defence Ministry and his own children from a future built on a stolen bid; ethical firms win the next tender because buyers trust them.

Answer length. This model answer runs to about 441 words so that every relevant angle is covered. In the exam, write to the 250-word limit: keep the opening, the strongest one or two points under each heading, the diagram and the conclusion.

Read more — sources

  • OfficialMinistry of Defence, Defence Acquisition Procedure 2020 — Pre-Contract Integrity Pact
  • OfficialIndian Penal Code, 1860 — Section 120B (criminal conspiracy)
  • BookImmanuel Kant, Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals (1785)
  • BookM.K. Gandhi, Seven Social Sins, Young India (22 October 1925)

Related questions from earlier years

2017 · GS Paper 4 (Ethics) · QQ12 (Case Study)·20 marks·250 words·Case Study
You are the manager of a spare parts company A and you have to negotiate a deal with the manager of a large manufacturing company B. The deal is highly competitive and sealing the deal is critical for your company. The deal is being worked out over a dinner.…
Under Section 161(2) of the CrPC a person examined by the police is bound to answer truly, and Sections 279 and 338 of the IPC punish rash driving that causes grievous…
Read the case-study answer →
2016 · GS Paper 4 (Ethics) · QQ9 (Case Study)·20 marks·250 words·Case Study
A fresh engineering graduate gets a job in a prestigious chemical industry. She likes the work. The salary is also good. However, after a few months she accidentally discovers that a highly toxic waste is being secretly discharged into a river nearby. This…
Discharging toxic effluent into a river is an offence under Section 24 of the Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1974, and it violates the villagers'…
Read the case-study answer →
2023 · GS Paper 4 (Ethics) · QQ1(a)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
What do you understand by ‘moral integrity’ and ‘professional efficiency’ in the context of corporate governance in India? Illustrate with suitable examples.
Corporate governance is the system by which a company is directed and controlled in the interest of shareholders and wider stakeholders. Moral integrity supplies its…
Read the model answer →

More from GS Paper 4 (Ethics) 2022

QQ1(a)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
Wisdom lies in knowing what to reckon with and what to overlook. An officer being engrossed with the periphery, ignoring the core issues before him, is not rare in the bureaucracy. Do you agree that such preoccupation of an administrator leads to travesty of…
Administrative wisdom is the ability to separate the essential from the incidental. When an officer perfects files and protocol while grievances wait, the rule becomes…
Read the model answer →
QQ1(b)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
Apart from intellectual competency and moral qualities, empathy and compassion are some of the other vital attributes that facilitate the civil servants to be more competent in tackling the crucial issues or taking critical decisions. Explain with suitable…
Intellect tells a civil servant what can be done and morality what ought to be done. Empathy, the capacity to understand another's situation from within, and…
Read the model answer →
QQ2(a)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
The Rules and Regulations provided to all the civil servants are same, yet there is difference in the performance. Positive minded officers are able to interpret the Rules and Regulations in favour of the case and achieve success, whereas negative minded…
Rules are general; cases are particular. Between the two lies discretion, and how it is used depends on attitude. A positive-minded officer reads a rule through its…
Read the model answer →
QQ2(b)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
It is believed that adherence to ethics in human actions would ensure in smooth functioning of an organization/system. If so, what does ethics seek to promote in human life? How do ethical values assist in the resolution of conflicts faced by him in his…
Ethics is the systematic study of right conduct and the good life. An organisation runs smoothly when its members can trust one another to act fairly without constant…
Read the model answer →
QQ3(a)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
What does each of the following quotations mean to you? “Ethics is knowing the difference between what you have the right to do and what is right to do.” — Potter Stewart
The line, attributed to US Supreme Court Justice Potter Stewart (on the bench 1958–81), separates legality from morality. Law marks the outer boundary of what one may…
Read the model answer →

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.