EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2022GS Paper 4 (Ethics)QQ9 (Case Study) · 20 marksCase StudyModel answer

Case study: The Supreme Court has banned mining in the Aravalli Hills to stop degradation of the forest cover and to maintain ecological balance.

DirectiveCritically evaluate / Suggest
Marks20
Word limit250
PaperGS Paper 4 (Ethics)
What the examiner wants

List Ashok's options, weigh each one's merits and demerits, name his dilemmas, pick the best option with reasons, and design practical police training; every sub-part needs its own answer.

Common trap: Many answers treat Ashok only as a whistle-blower. A top answer sees that the CMD's offer is an inducement to bury a murder, uses lawful channels outside the compromised local police, protects Ashok and his evidence, and gives police training that is tactical as well as ethical.

SyllabusProbity in Governance: Concept of public service; Philosophical basis of governance and probity; Information sharing and transparency in government, Right to Information, Codes of Ethics, Codes of Conduct, Citizen's Charters, Work culture, Quality of service delivery, Utilization of public funds, challenges of corruption.

The case

The Supreme Court has banned mining in the Aravalli Hills to stop degradation of the forest cover and to maintain ecological balance. However, the stone mining was still prevalent in the border district of the affected State with connivance of certain corrupt forest officials and politicians. Young and dynamic SP who was recently posted in the affected district promised to himself to stop this menace. In one of his surprise checks with his team, he found loaded truck with stone trying to escape the mining area. He tried to stop the truck but the truck driver overrun the police officer, killing him on the spot and thereafter managed to flee. Police filed FIR but no breakthrough was achieved in the case for almost three months. Ashok who was the Investigative Journalist working with leading TV channel, suo moto started investigating the case. Within one month, Ashok got breakthrough by interacting with local people, stone mining mafia and government officials. He prepared his investigative story and presented to the CMD of the TV channel. He exposed in his investigative report the complete nexus of stone mafia working with blessing of corrupt police and civil officials and politicians. The politician who was involved in the mafia was no one else but local MLA who was considered to be very close to the Chief Minister. After going through the investigative report, the CMD advised Ashok to drop the idea of making the story public through electronic media. He informed that the local MLA was not only the relative of the owner of the TV channel but also had unofficially 20 percent share in the channel. The CMD further informed Ashok that his further promotion and hike in pay will be taken care of in addition the soft loan of ₹ 10 lakhs which he has taken from the TV channel for his son’s chronic disease will be suitably adjusted if he hands over the investigative report to him. (a) What are the options available with Ashok to cope up with the situation? (b) Critically evaluate/examine each of the options identified by Ashok. (c) What are the ethical dilemmas being faced by Ashok? (d) Which of the options, do you think, would be the most appropriate for Ashok to adopt and why? (e) In the above scenario, what type of training would you suggest for police officers posted to such districts where stone mining illegal activities are rampant?

Model answer

20 marks · 250-word limit

Ashok holds evidence that a stone-mining mafia, protected by police, civil officials and an MLA close to the Chief Minister, defies a Supreme Court ban on Aravalli mining and whose loaded truck ran over an SP. His channel's CMD offers promotion, a pay hike and adjustment of a ₹10 lakh loan to bury it.

Illegal stone mining
  • Mining mafia
  • Corrupt police
  • Corrupt civil and forest officials
  • Local MLA close to CM
  • Owner relative; 20% share
  • Truck killed SP; FIR stalled
The nexus Ashok exposed

(a) Options available to Ashok

  • Option 1: Hand over the report to the CMD and accept the promotion, pay hike and loan adjustment.
  • Option 2: Persuade the CMD and editorial board to air it, with the owner's conflict of interest recused.
  • Option 3: Give his evidence to the police, a court or another lawful investigating authority.
  • Option 4: Resign and publish through another outlet.

(b) Critical evaluation of each option

OptionMeritsDemerits
1. Hand overRelieves the burden of his son's treatment; career securedBuries a murder and a defiance of the Supreme Court; makes him complicit; lifelong compromise
2. Persuade insideKeeps job and the channel credibleOwner and MLA likely to refuse
3. Go to authoritiesLawful; evidence aids justice; CrPC s.39 obliges people to report offences such as murderLocal police are part of the nexus; needs a trustworthy agency and protection
4. Resign and publishTruth reaches the publicLoss of income amid the loan and son's illness; legal and physical risk

(c) Ethical dilemmas faced

  • Family versus public interest: His son's chronic disease and the ₹10 lakh loan against exposing a murder.
  • Loyalty versus truth: Duty to his employer against journalism's duty to the public.
  • Editorial independence: Ownership interest, an unofficial 20 percent share held by the MLA, is dictating news.
  • Courage versus safety: A mafia that ran over an SP can harm him too.

(d) Most appropriate option and why

  • Options 2 and 3 together: Refuse the inducement in writing, keep copies of the evidence safe, press the channel to air the story, and in any case hand the evidence to an agency outside the local nexus or to the court enforcing the ban.
  • Why: Press freedom under Article 19(1)(a) exists for such public-interest stories; Gandhi's talisman asks whom the choice helps, here the SP's family and the Aravalli ecology. If the channel still refuses, resigning to publish elsewhere is the honourable last step.

(e) Training for police in mining districts

  • Law: Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957, forest laws, and seizure and prosecution procedure.
  • Tactical safety: Interception with barricades, backup and body cameras, never standing before a truck.
  • Technology: Drone and satellite surveillance, and GPS-tracking of mineral trucks.
  • Integrity and coordination: Anti-corruption ethics, rotation, joint drives with forest, mining and revenue officials, and witness protection.

Ashok's choice decides whether an SP's death becomes a statistic or a turning point. Journalism that sells silence for a loan adjustment fails the public; truth told safely and lawfully is both his duty and the slain officer's due.

Answer length. This model answer runs to about 447 words so that every relevant angle is covered. In the exam, write to the 250-word limit: keep the opening, the strongest one or two points under each heading, the diagram and the conclusion.

Read more — sources

  • OfficialMines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957 — Sections 4 and 21
  • OfficialCode of Criminal Procedure, 1973 — Section 39
  • OfficialMahender Chawla v. Union of India (Supreme Court, December 2018) — Witness Protection Scheme, 2018
  • ReportSecond Administrative Reforms Commission, 5th Report: Public Order (2007)

Related questions from earlier years

2021 · GS Paper 4 (Ethics) · QQ7 (Case Study)·20 marks·250 words·Case Study
Sunil is a young civil servant and has a reputation for his competence, integrity, dedication and relentness pursuit of difficult and onerous jobs. Considering his profile, he was picked up by his bosses to handle a very challenging and sensitive assignment.…
Sunil was chosen for this district precisely because he would not bend. The muscleman's threat, the stalking of his wife and old mother and the memory of an officer…
Read the case-study answer →
2022 · GS Paper 4 (Ethics) · QQ6(a)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
Whistle-blower, who reports corruption and illegal activities, wrongdoing and misconduct to the concerned authorities, runs the risk of being exposed to grave danger, physical harm and victimization by the vested interests, accused persons and his team. What…
Whistle-blowers keep public institutions honest, yet in India some have paid with their lives: Satyendra Dubey of the NHAI was murdered in 2003 after flagging highway…
Read the model answer →
2015 · GS Paper 4 (Ethics) · QQ4(b)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
Some recent developments such as introduction of RTI Act, media and judicial activism, etc., are proving helpful in bringing about greater transparency and accountability in the functioning of the government. However, it is also being observed that at times…
The Right to Information Act, 2005, a vigilant media and public interest litigation have shifted the default in governance from secrecy to disclosure. Yet every…
Read the model answer →

More from GS Paper 4 (Ethics) 2022

QQ1(a)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
Wisdom lies in knowing what to reckon with and what to overlook. An officer being engrossed with the periphery, ignoring the core issues before him, is not rare in the bureaucracy. Do you agree that such preoccupation of an administrator leads to travesty of…
Administrative wisdom is the ability to separate the essential from the incidental. When an officer perfects files and protocol while grievances wait, the rule becomes…
Read the model answer →
QQ1(b)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
Apart from intellectual competency and moral qualities, empathy and compassion are some of the other vital attributes that facilitate the civil servants to be more competent in tackling the crucial issues or taking critical decisions. Explain with suitable…
Intellect tells a civil servant what can be done and morality what ought to be done. Empathy, the capacity to understand another's situation from within, and…
Read the model answer →
QQ2(a)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
The Rules and Regulations provided to all the civil servants are same, yet there is difference in the performance. Positive minded officers are able to interpret the Rules and Regulations in favour of the case and achieve success, whereas negative minded…
Rules are general; cases are particular. Between the two lies discretion, and how it is used depends on attitude. A positive-minded officer reads a rule through its…
Read the model answer →
QQ2(b)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
It is believed that adherence to ethics in human actions would ensure in smooth functioning of an organization/system. If so, what does ethics seek to promote in human life? How do ethical values assist in the resolution of conflicts faced by him in his…
Ethics is the systematic study of right conduct and the good life. An organisation runs smoothly when its members can trust one another to act fairly without constant…
Read the model answer →
QQ3(a)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
What does each of the following quotations mean to you? “Ethics is knowing the difference between what you have the right to do and what is right to do.” — Potter Stewart
The line, attributed to US Supreme Court Justice Potter Stewart (on the bench 1958–81), separates legality from morality. Law marks the outer boundary of what one may…
Read the model answer →

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.