Account for the legal and political factors responsible for the reduced frequency of using Article 356 by the Union Governments since mid 1990s.
Give the reasons that explain the trend; the question wants two clear sets of reasons, legal and political, each backed by cases, events or institutional changes.
Common trap: Many answers only describe Bommai. A top answer separates legal from political factors, explains why the mid-1990s is the turning point, and notes that misuse has not vanished but has changed form.
SyllabusFunctions and responsibilities of the Union and the States, issues and challenges pertaining to the federal structure, devolution of powers and finances up to local levels and challenges therein.
Model answer
15 marks · 250-word limitArticle 356 lets the President assume a state's functions when its government cannot be carried on in accordance with the Constitution. Used over a hundred times since 1950, most often against opposition-ruled states, it has become rare after the mid-1990s, a shift driven by courts, coalitions and voters.
- Governor's report treated as conclusive
- Majority tested in Raj Bhavan
- Mass dismissals in 1977 and 1980
- Single-party dominance at the Centre
- Proclamation open to judicial review
- Majority tested on the floor
- Assembly kept suspended till Parliament approves
- Coalition and regional checks
Legal factors
- S.R. Bommai v Union of India (1994): A nine-judge bench held the proclamation judicially reviewable, required the material behind it to be relevant, made the floor of the House the test of majority, and barred dissolution of the assembly before both Houses approve.
- 44th Amendment, 1978: It deleted the 38th Amendment's bar on judicial review and limited continuation beyond one year to a national emergency plus an Election Commission certificate.
- Later judgments: Rameshwar Prasad (2006) declared the 2005 Bihar dissolution unconstitutional; in 2016 the Court ordered a floor test in Uttarakhand and, in Nabam Rebia, restored the Arunachal government.
- Commission guidance: The Sarkaria Commission (1988) urged its use only as a last resort after warning the state; the Punchhi Commission (2010) endorsed this restraint.
Political factors
- Coalition era: From 1989 to 2014 Union governments depended on regional parties that would not support the dismissal of state governments.
- Rajya Sabha check: The proclamation needs approval of both Houses; in 1999 Bihar's President's rule was revoked within weeks as Rajya Sabha support was lacking.
- Presidential scrutiny: President K.R. Narayanan returned the cabinet's recommendations on Uttar Pradesh in 1997 and Bihar in 1998 for reconsideration.
- Electoral cost: Dismissals were increasingly seen by voters as an assault on their mandate, and rising federal consciousness made them politically risky.
Assessment
- Changed form: Pressure has shifted to Governors' discretion in government formation, delays over bills and engineered defections, while the Tenth Schedule's limits are tested in court.
- Still in use: Jammu and Kashmir (2018–19) and Maharashtra (2019) show that Article 356 remains available for genuine breakdowns.
Bommai turned Article 356 from a political weapon into the dead letter Ambedkar had hoped for. Codifying the Sarkaria and Punchhi safeguards and reforming the Governor's office would extend that restraint to the subtler instruments of central pressure.
Read more — sources
- NCERTIndian Constitution at Work (Class XI) — Ch. 7, Federalism
- OfficialSupreme Court of India — S.R. Bommai v Union of India (1994)
- ReportReport of the Commission on Centre-State Relations (Sarkaria Commission), 1988
- ReportReport of the Commission on Centre-State Relations (Punchhi Commission), 2010
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 2 2023
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.